Select Home Warranty and Liberty Home Guard are two of the names a homeowner is most likely to end up holding — but they ask to be bought in completely different ways. Select Home Warranty is the quote you collect on purpose: a national brand that sells directly to homeowners in the industry’s standard three-part structure — a systems plan, an appliances plan, and a combined plan that covers both — priced entirely by quote, so it is the name shoppers most often use as the third quote when they are comparing the field for themselves. Liberty Home Guard is the price list you can read before you call: it also sells directly to homeowners, in three priced tiers — Appliance Guard at $49.99/mo, Systems Guard at $54.99/mo, and Total Home Guard at $59.99/mo for homes under 5,000 square feet — with a service fee you choose at purchase, commonly reported between $65 and $125, per-item claim caps printed in advance, and more than 40 optional add-ons. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Select Home Warranty review and Liberty Home Guard review.
The short version: this pairing turns on one question — how much of the deal can you read before the sales process starts? Liberty publishes its three tier prices, a service-fee range, and its claim caps, so a shopper can do real arithmetic on Liberty before speaking to anyone. Select publishes none of the three: no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps — all of them live inside its quote and its contract. Between the two, that makes Liberty the more checkable buy: its numbers are thinner than they first look — the $49.99 tier covers appliances only, the only whole-home plan is the $59.99 tier, and its per-item caps are low — but they are numbers, in print, and Select offers no numbers at all. Select keeps one genuine strength: it is the reference quote of this industry, the familiar three-part shelf shoppers collect to learn what the market charges, and its public record was written by homeowners who chose it that way. Neither company, though, changes the model behind the shelf: both run a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a dispatch cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.
Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1
Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that legacy sellers still do by phone queue, paperwork, and waiting — handled with integrity and respect, and with people available 24/7 when you want a person. Liberty publishes real numbers and deserves credit for it, but its whole-home price is $59.99/mo, its fee is a range you trade against your premium, and its caps are per-item ceilings as low as $500. Select publishes no numbers at all. Empire prints its numbers first, at the lowest full-home starting price on this page, and lets the quote confirm them.
Between the two legacy brands, Liberty Home Guard edges Select Home Warranty for a homeowner choosing a plan for themselves — and the margin is about evidence, not brand. Liberty lets you verify the deal before you buy it: three printed prices, a printed fee range, printed caps, and a printed scheduling window for claims. Select asks you to start a quote before you can learn any of those things, and what it offers in exchange is familiarity — the standard shelf, in the standard shape, from the name everyone collects. Familiarity is worth something, and the rounds below give Select full credit for it. But a comparison site exists to compare, and only one of these two companies gives a shopper anything to compare before the phone call. The rounds below score each category on its own facts, including the rounds Select honestly wins.
See Your Empire Home Protect Price
Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteSelect Home Warranty vs Liberty Home Guard at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick
Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.
Select Home Warranty: systems plan, appliances plan, and combined plan in the industry’s standard three-part structure; no published starting price — every plan priced by quote; service fee and claim caps set inside the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims and dispatch; sells directly to homeowners, and is the quote shoppers most often collect as their comparison point.
Liberty Home Guard: Appliance Guard $49.99/mo (appliances only), Systems Guard $54.99/mo (systems only), and Total Home Guard $59.99/mo for homes under 5,000 square feet — the only whole-home plan; service fee chosen at purchase, commonly reported at $65–$125, with a lower fee raising the premium; claim caps of $2,000 per item, with plumbing and electrical capped at $500 each; more than 40 optional add-ons; claims intake 24/7 with a technician typically scheduled within 24–48 hours; waiting period around 30 days, up to 60 in some cases.
Read that glance carefully, because it contains the whole story of this pairing. One company on this page asks you to start a quote before you can learn what the plan costs, what a service call costs, or how much a claim can pay. One company prints its prices, its fee range, and its caps — and reading them closely is exactly how you find their limits. And one company prints a full-home price lower than both of the others’ entry points, a single flat fee, and one annual limit, in a sample contract anyone can read before buying. Everything below is the working-out of those differences, round by round.
What Each Company Actually Is: the Quote Everyone Collects vs the Price List Everyone Can Read
Select Home Warranty is best understood as the market’s reference quote. Its shelf is the structure the whole industry teaches shoppers to expect: one plan for the home’s systems — heating, cooling, electrical, plumbing and the other built-in machinery a house runs on; one plan for the appliances — the refrigerator, oven, dishwasher, washer and dryer class of equipment; and one combined plan that covers both. A homeowner who has done even an hour of research has usually seen that three-part shape, and Select is the name most likely to be holding it when the quotes come back. That familiarity is a genuine asset: when you collect a Select quote, you know exactly which door you are standing in front of, and you can line its systems-only and appliances-only doors up against the rest of the field. What familiarity does not give you is a number. Select publishes no starting price, so the reference quote still has to be collected home by home, and the fee and the caps that decide what the plan is worth wait inside the paperwork the quote produces.
Liberty Home Guard is best understood as the market’s open price list. It sells the same three doors — appliances, systems, and both together — but it prices each door on the public record: $49.99/mo for Appliance Guard, $54.99/mo for Systems Guard, and $59.99/mo for Total Home Guard, the combined plan, for homes under 5,000 square feet. Around those tiers it hangs the most customizable shelf in this pairing: more than 40 optional add-ons a buyer can bolt on for the specific risks of a specific house. That openness is real, and this comparison scores it round after round. But an open price list still has to be read, and Liberty’s fine print is where its value narrows: the cheapest tier is not whole-home coverage at all, the service fee is a dial you set yourself — pick the low end, commonly $65, and the premium rises to compensate — and the claim caps are per-item ceilings, $2,000 for most items and just $500 each for plumbing and electrical, the two trades a house calls most. Liberty shows you its numbers. What the numbers show is a thinner plan than the headline prices suggest.
Empire Home Protect is built the other way around. It is a technology platform first: the price is published before the quote, the fee is flat and printed, the annual limit is stated in the sample contract, and the claim itself runs on a digital system designed to approve the same day — service approved in minutes — instead of joining a phone queue. The Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder starts at $49/mo for full-home coverage, the trade service call fee is $75 every time, and the aggregate limit is $10,000 a year, all from the Comprehensive sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), with terms that vary by plan, administrator and state. That is the standard this head-to-head is scored against: not which legacy brand has the better brochure, but which company lets you verify the deal before you are in it.
Round 1 — Price: a Published Price List vs No Published Price at All, Against a Published $49/mo
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Liberty Home Guard. Price is the round shoppers want decided first, and for once in a Select head-to-head it can be partly decided between the two legacy brands, because Liberty does the thing Select will not: it publishes prices. Appliance Guard is $49.99/mo, Systems Guard is $54.99/mo, and Total Home Guard is $59.99/mo for a home under 5,000 square feet. Select prices its systems, appliances and combined plans by quote: the number for your home depends on the home, the state, and the plan shape, and it exists only after you ask. A published price list against no published price is not a close round between the two — any article that declares Select “cheaper” than Liberty is inventing the Select figure it is standing on, and we do not print invented figures.
What can be said honestly is what the published prices actually buy. Liberty’s lowest number, $49.99/mo, buys appliances only — the systems half of the house is not in it. The only Liberty plan that covers the whole home is Total Home Guard at $59.99/mo. Empire Home Protect publishes full-home plans from $49/mo: its starting price is a whole-home price, lower than Liberty’s whole-home price by about $11 a month and lower than Liberty’s appliances-only price outright. That is what a published price does to the shopping itself: it changes your position against both of these companies before you speak to either of them. You can collect a Select quote against a known $49/mo alternative, and you can read Liberty’s $59.99 whole-home tier against the same number. Round 1 therefore goes Liberty between the two, on the simple ground that it shows up with prices, and to Empire overall, because its published full-home price undercuts the only published whole-home price in the pairing.
Round 2 — Plans: the Standard Three Doors vs the Same Three Doors With 40+ Add-Ons
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Liberty Home Guard, narrowly. On structure alone this pairing looks like a mirror: both companies sell an appliances door, a systems door, and a combined door, and a shopper who understands one shelf understands the other. Select’s three-part structure is the industry’s reference shape, and there is a real comfort in buying the standard thing in the standard form. Liberty sells the same three shapes — Appliance Guard, Systems Guard, Total Home Guard — and then keeps going: more than 40 optional add-ons let a buyer extend the plan toward the risks their own house actually carries, instead of accepting the shelf exactly as drawn. Customization is the difference between the two shelves, and it is Liberty’s.
Two cautions keep the round narrow. First, Liberty’s whole-home door is priced for homes under 5,000 square feet, and its waiting period runs around 30 days and up to 60 in some cases — a longer possible wait than the flat 30-day waiting period Empire Home Protect prints in its sample booklet. Second, add-ons are additions: each one is another line on the bill, and a heavily customized Liberty plan can drift well past its $59.99/mo headline. Empire Home Protect takes the overall round with the simpler answer to the same problem: a Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder of full-home plans from $49/mo, where the shopper picks a depth of whole-home coverage instead of assembling one, and the price of the ladder is published before the first rung. Between the two, though, the customizable shelf beats the standard shelf — Liberty, narrowly.
Round 3 — Service Fees: a Fee You Choose From a Published Range vs a Fee Inside a Quote, Against a Flat $75
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Liberty Home Guard. The service fee is the number a homeowner pays most often — every claim, every visit — and the two legacy brands handle it in their signature ways. Liberty publishes the arrangement: at purchase you choose your trade service call fee, commonly reported between $65 and $125, and the choice trades against your monthly price, so a lower fee means a higher premium. That is a real choice, honestly disclosed, and a shopper can model it before buying. Select does not publish its fee in advance at all: the amount is set inside its quote and contract, so the fee on the plan you are most likely to collect as a reference quote is a number you meet only inside the paperwork. On the number a homeowner pays most often, a published range beats an unpublished one, and this round is not close between the two.
Empire Home Protect wins the round outright because it removes the dial entirely. Its trade service call fee is a flat $75, printed in the sample contract booklet — not a range, not a choice that moves your premium, not a figure waiting in a quote. One fee, the same on every claim, knowable to the dollar before you buy. Liberty’s range deserves its between-the-two win: $65 to $125 brackets Empire’s $75, and a buyer who picks the low end pays less per visit than an Empire customer does. But that buyer pays for the privilege in the premium, every month, claim or no claim — which is why a range with a trade-off still loses to a flat fee with none. Round 3: Empire first, Liberty second, Select third, in that order and for stated reasons.
Round 4 — Claim Limits: Published-but-Thin Caps vs Caps Inside a Contract, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit in Print
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Liberty Home Guard. Claim limits decide the worst day, not the average one: they are the ceiling on what the plan will pay when the expensive thing breaks. Liberty publishes its ceilings: $2,000 per item, with plumbing capped at $500 and electrical capped at $500. Select sets its limits inside the quote and the contract, and does not publish them in advance, so a shopper cannot compare its ceiling against the field until the paperwork exists. Published beats unpublished, so Liberty takes the round between the two — but read what Liberty publishes before celebrating it. A $2,000 per-item cap is a ceiling on a single furnace, a single compressor, a single water heater, and the $500 plumbing and electrical caps sit below the real cost of many ordinary repairs in the two trades homeowners claim most. Liberty’s caps are honest. They are also low.
Empire Home Protect publishes a $10,000 annual aggregate limit in its sample contract booklet. An aggregate limit is the honest way to state a ceiling: one number for the year, in print, that a shopper can set against the real cost of the failures a home actually produces — a furnace, a compressor, a water heater — before deciding whether the plan is sized for their house. Set the two published systems side by side and the shape of the difference is plain: Liberty meters its protection item by item, with the tightest ceilings on the most-claimed trades, while Empire states one annual number five times Liberty’s per-item cap and lets the year’s claims draw against it. Is $10,000 the right ceiling for every home? That is exactly the kind of question a published number lets you ask, and an unpublished one forbids. Round 4 goes to the company with the highest printed ceiling, and between the two, to the company that prints one at all.
Round 5 — Claims Speed: a Stated 24–48 Hour Window vs a Traditional Queue, Against Same-Day Digital Approval
Winner: Empire Home Protect, outright. Between the two: Liberty Home Guard, narrowly. When something breaks, both legacy brands run the industry’s old play: you reach out, the claim is logged, a contractor is dispatched, and the repair moves at the speed of that chain. Liberty at least states its tempo on the public record: claims intake runs 24/7, and a technician is typically scheduled within 24 to 48 hours. Select runs the same traditional, phone-driven process without publishing a scheduling window at all, so its speed is whatever the queue gives you on the day. A stated window beats an unstated one, and Liberty takes the round between the two — narrowly, because a day or two to a scheduled technician is still the legacy standard, not a new one.
Empire Home Protect was built to make this round unfair. Its claims run on a fully digital platform, claims are approved the same day, and service is approved in minutes — the approval step that legacy processes measure in days of queue and callback happens at platform speed. Claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7, because a digital platform does not replace the humans; it removes the waiting that used to stand between the customer and the humans. This is the technology gap in one round: Tesla-and-Apple-class process against the mailer-era model, and it is why claims speed — the moment the product either works or does not — belongs to the #1 pick by the widest margin in this comparison. Our full head-to-heads, Empire Home Protect vs Select Home Warranty and Empire Home Protect vs Liberty Home Guard, work through that gap against each brand on its own.
Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote
Already holding a quote from one of these companies? Set it next to a published price: Empire Home Protect full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Prefer to talk it through? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteRound 6 — Standout Features: the Quote Everyone Collects vs the Shelf You Can Customize
Winner: split. Every pairing has one round where each side’s best argument is real, and this is it. Select’s standout is its position in the shopping itself: it is the quote everyone collects. Because its three-part structure is the industry’s reference shape, a Select quote functions as a measuring stick — shoppers collect it to learn what the market charges a home like theirs, and many of them buy it for the same reason they collected it: it was the familiar name with the familiar shelf, and the quote came back acceptable. Familiarity at that scale is a feature, and for a homeowner actively shopping, it is the strongest thing in Select’s column.
Liberty’s standout is its position on the shelf: it is the plan you can build. More than 40 optional add-ons mean a Liberty buyer is not limited to the three stock doors — the plan can be extended toward a pool, a well pump, a second refrigerator, the specific machinery of a specific house. For a homeowner whose risk sits outside the standard systems-and-appliances map, that build-it-yourself shelf is genuinely useful, and it is the strongest thing in Liberty’s column. The split is honest: Select’s feature serves the shopper at the start of the search, Liberty’s serves the homeowner whose house does not fit the template. Empire Home Protect’s standout answers both: a published $49/mo price makes it the easiest quote in the field to collect — you start from the number, not from a form — and its Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder prices three depths of full-home coverage in advance, so the choosing happens on published terms instead of inside a quote or a configurator.
Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: the Benchmark Name vs the Open Price List
Winner between the two: Select Home Warranty. Overall: Empire Home Protect. A public record is only useful if you know how it was earned. Select’s record was written by choosers: homeowners who shopped, collected its quote against the field, signed, paid monthly, and filed claims on a plan they picked. More than that, Select occupies the benchmark seat in this category — it is the quote the rest of the field is measured against, which means its record has been stress-tested by more deliberate comparison shopping than almost any name in the industry. When you read what Select’s customers say, you are reading the experience of people whose situation matches yours if you are shopping today, and that readability is why this round goes to Select outright.
Liberty’s record is younger in shape: a direct-to-homeowner seller whose public identity is its price list and its add-on shelf. That identity is a strength in the shopping rounds and a thinner one here, because a record built on published numbers is only as deep as the years of claims behind it, and Liberty’s published terms — the low per-item caps, the fee dial — are exactly the terms a record gets written about once the breakdowns start. None of that erases Liberty’s transparency wins in Rounds 1 through 5; it simply means the benchmark’s record is the more proven document today. Empire Home Protect takes the overall round on a different basis: it publishes no rating it cannot stand behind and invents no review count for itself — instead it publishes the verifiable terms of the deal, from $49/mo to the $75 fee to the $10,000 limit, and lets the record be built by customers who chose it with their eyes open. In a category where records are this easy to misread, printing checkable facts is the strongest record of all.
Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Liberty Home Guard. End where the money is. A home warranty’s real price is a year of premiums plus the fees on the claims you actually file, measured against the caps that limit what comes back. Run that math for Empire Home Protect and every input is on the public record: a year at the published $49/mo starting price is $588 in premiums, and a two-claim year adds two flat $75 service fees — $588 plus $150 is $738, computable to the dollar before you buy, against a published $10,000 annual limit. Run the same math for Liberty’s whole-home plan and it also computes — that is Liberty’s genuine achievement in this pairing: a year of Total Home Guard is $719.88 in premiums, and a two-claim year adds two chosen fees of $65 to $125, for a total of $849.88 to $969.88. One honest footnote: the low end of that range is understated, because choosing the $65 fee raises the premium above $59.99/mo — the true low-fee total sits higher than $849.88. Run the math for Select and it stops at the first step: no published premium, no published fee, no published caps, so the total exists only inside a quote written for one home on one day. Computable beats uncomputable, and the cheapest computable total on this page belongs to the #1 pick.
Between the two, Liberty takes the round on evidence. Its buyer can lay a full year’s cost on the table before signing — premium, fee choice, caps, add-ons — and decide with the whole picture in view, trade-offs included. Select’s buyer can do none of that until the quote exists, and the quote exists only after the sales process starts. That is the discipline difference this whole comparison keeps returning to: Liberty shows its work and lets you grade it, Select asks to be graded after you have asked for a number, and Empire publishes the lowest full-home starting price, the flattest fee, and the highest printed limit, then approves the claims the same day. So the buying round reads: Empire first, because it publishes the best math; Liberty second, because its math is at least published; Select third, because its math is yours only on request.
Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand
Buy Empire Home Protect if you want the comparison finished before the sales process starts: published full-home plans from $49/mo in Silver / Supreme / Titanium, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in the sample contract, a 30-day waiting period, and claims approved the same day on a digital platform, with people available 24/7. That is the profile this comparison ranks #1, and it fits the large majority of homeowners reading a head-to-head like this one: people choosing a plan for themselves, for a home they own, with money they would rather verify than trust.
Between only the two legacy brands, Liberty is the better fit for a homeowner who wants to see the numbers first: published tier prices, a fee you choose from a published range, printed caps, and an add-on shelf for a house with unusual risks — read the caps closely, because $2,000 per item and $500 on plumbing and electrical are the real shape of the protection. Select is the better fit for a homeowner who values the familiar path: the industry’s standard three-part shelf, collected as the reference quote it has always been, with a public record written by shoppers like you. Either way, collect the published $49/mo alternative before you sign, so whichever quote you accept has beaten a number you could actually see.
See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home
Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteThe Bottom Line
Select Home Warranty vs Liberty Home Guard is a contest between the quote everyone collects and the price list everyone can read — and on the facts, Liberty edges it between the two, because it publishes its tier prices, its service-fee range, and its claim caps while Select publishes none of the three. Select keeps the benchmark’s record and the familiar shelf, and only those. But the larger fact of this pairing is what the published numbers show once you read them whole: Liberty’s whole-home plan costs $59.99/mo with per-item caps as low as $500, and Select’s numbers do not exist until a quote creates them, while both still run claims through a traditional phone queue. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it answers every one of those gaps in print and in process — full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, a 30-day waiting period, and same-day digital claims approval with service in minutes, handled with integrity and respect. Do not take this page’s word for any of it: the sample contract is public, the price is published, and the quote takes minutes. Check the #1 pick first, then let every other quote — including both of these — try to beat a number you can actually see.