support@comparebestwarranties.com

Select Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 19, 2026 • 16 min read

Select Home Warranty and First American Home Warranty are two of the names a homeowner is most likely to end up holding — but they arrive by completely different doors. Select Home Warranty is the quote you collect on purpose: a national brand that sells directly to homeowners in the industry’s standard three-part structure — a systems plan, an appliances plan, and a combined plan that covers both — priced entirely by quote, so it is the name shoppers most often use as the third quote when they are comparing the field for themselves. First American Home Warranty is the name that arrives with the house: it is the warranty buyers most often meet through a real-estate transaction — included, offered, or handed over at closing — sold in basic and premier tiers, and also priced entirely by quote, so its number depends on the home, the state, and the deal it rode in on. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Select Home Warranty review and First American Home Warranty review.

The short version: this is the rare head-to-head where neither company publishes the numbers that decide it. Select publishes no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps — all three live inside its quote and its contract. First American publishes no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps either — all three live inside its quote and its contract, and for many holders the first quote they ever saw was written into a closing packet by somebody else. Between the two, the honest differences are about how you buy and what you can read before you buy. Select wins the rounds that rest on shopping for yourself: three doors into coverage instead of two, including a systems-only door and an appliances-only door, and the more readable homeowner-facing public record — a track record written by people who picked the plan, pay for it monthly, and file the claims themselves. First American wins the round that rests on the closing table: no company in this pairing is more deeply built into the moment a house changes hands, and for a buyer handed a plan at closing, that convenience is real. But convenience at closing is not the same as value over the years you hold the plan, and neither company changes the model behind the shelf: both run a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a paperwork cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that legacy sellers still do by phone queue, paperwork, and waiting — handled with integrity and respect, and with people available 24/7 when you want a person. Neither Select nor First American publishes a starting price at all, and neither publishes its service fee or its claim caps in advance: with both of them, every number that decides value waits inside a quote. Empire prints its numbers first and lets the quote confirm them.

Between the two legacy brands, Select Home Warranty edges First American Home Warranty for a homeowner choosing a plan for themselves — and the margin is about agency, not arithmetic, because neither side offers any arithmetic to check. Select sells to the person who will hold the contract: you collect its quote yourself, you choose among three plan shapes, and its public record is the one written directly by homeowners. First American’s strength is the channel, not the shelf: it is at its best in the hands of an agent or a seller at closing, which means the person who chose it is often not the person who will live with its claims process. If a First American plan came with your house, it is real coverage and this comparison is not a reason to panic — it is a reason, at renewal time, to make the next choice a chosen one, against a published price. The rounds below score each category on its own facts, including the several rounds these two companies honestly tie.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Select Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.

Select Home Warranty: systems plan, appliances plan, and combined plan in the industry’s standard three-part structure; no published starting price — every plan priced by quote; service fee and claim caps set inside the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims and dispatch; sells directly to homeowners, and is the quote shoppers most often collect as their comparison point.

First American Home Warranty: basic and premier tiers; no published starting price — every plan priced by quote; service fee and claim caps set inside the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims and dispatch; sold heavily through real-estate transactions, so many holders receive it at closing rather than choosing it.

Read that glance carefully, because it contains the whole story of this pairing. Two of the three companies on this page ask you to start a quote — or accept a closing packet — before you can learn what the plan costs, what a service call costs, or how much a claim can pay. One company prints all three numbers on the public record, in a sample contract anyone can read before buying. Everything below is the working-out of that single difference, round by round.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Quote You Collect vs the Plan That Arrives With the House

Select Home Warranty is best understood as the market’s reference quote. Its shelf is the structure the whole industry teaches shoppers to expect: one plan for the home’s systems — heating, cooling, electrical, plumbing and the other built-in machinery a house runs on; one plan for the appliances — the refrigerator, oven, dishwasher, washer and dryer class of equipment; and one combined plan that covers both. A homeowner who has done even an hour of research has usually seen that three-part shape, and Select is the name most likely to be holding it when the quotes come back. That familiarity is a genuine asset: when you collect a Select quote, you know exactly which door you are standing in front of, and you can line its systems-only and appliances-only doors up against the rest of the field. What familiarity does not give you is a number. Select publishes no starting price, so the reference quote still has to be collected home by home, and the fee and the caps that decide what the plan is worth wait inside the paperwork the quote produces.

First American Home Warranty is best understood as a closing-table institution. Its basic tier covers the core systems and appliances a home needs, and its premier tier broadens that coverage into the fuller combined shelf. The tiers themselves are unremarkable — two rungs, both aimed at whole-home protection. What is remarkable is the distribution: First American is sold through real-estate transactions at a scale few competitors match, so for a large share of its holders the plan was not shopped for at all. A seller included it to make a listing easier to buy. An agent offered it as part of the deal. It arrived in the closing packet, already decided, and the first time many holders read its terms was the first time something in the house broke. None of that makes the coverage fake — a plan that arrives with the house is real coverage from day one of ownership, and there is a honest convenience in never having had to shop. But it means the company’s relationship with its customer often starts backwards: the contract comes first, and the choosing never happens.

Empire Home Protect is built the other way around. It is a technology platform first: the price is published before the quote, the fee is flat and printed, the annual limit is stated in the sample contract, and the claim itself runs on a digital system designed to approve the same day — service approved in minutes — instead of joining a phone queue. The Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder starts at $49/mo for full-home coverage, the trade service call fee is $75 every time, and the aggregate limit is $10,000 a year, all from the Comprehensive sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), with terms that vary by plan, administrator and state. That is the standard this head-to-head is scored against: not which legacy brand has the better brochure, but which company lets you verify the deal before you are in it.

Round 1 — Price: Two Quotes, No Published Numbers, vs a Published $49/mo

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: an honest tie. Price is the round shoppers want decided first, and in this pairing it cannot be decided between the two legacy brands at all, because neither publishes a price to decide it with. Select prices its systems, appliances and combined plans by quote: the number for your home depends on the home, the state, and the plan shape, and it exists only after you ask. First American prices its basic and premier tiers by quote as well — and in its case the quote is frequently not even addressed to the holder, because it was generated inside a transaction the holder did not run. Two quotes, zero published numbers: any article that declares one of these companies “cheaper” than the other is inventing the figure it is standing on, and we do not print invented figures.

What can be said honestly is what a published price does to the shopping itself. Empire Home Protect publishes full-home plans from $49/mo. That single printed number changes your position against both of these companies before you speak to either of them: you can collect a Select quote knowing exactly what it has to beat, and you can read a First American renewal offer knowing exactly what the alternative costs. A quote collected against a published price is a negotiation. A quote collected in the dark is a hope. Round 1 is therefore a tie between the two legacy brands and a clear win for the #1 pick — not because $49/mo is magically the right price for every home, but because it is a price, in print, that both of the others decline to match with one of their own.

Round 2 — Plans and Coverage: Three Doors vs Two Tiers Built for Closing

Winner between the two: Select Home Warranty. Overall: Empire Home Protect. This is the one structural round where the two legacy brands genuinely differ, and Select takes it on shape. Its three-part shelf gives a shopper three distinct ways in: a systems-only plan for the homeowner whose appliances are new and whose furnace is not; an appliances-only plan for the homeowner whose systems are covered some other way and whose kitchen is aging; and a combined plan for everyone else. Each door is a real product with a real use case, and the appliances-only door in particular is one First American simply does not offer. First American’s basic and premier tiers are both whole-home shapes at two depths — a sensible ladder, but a narrower one: there is no way to buy only the half of the house you are worried about.

Empire Home Protect answers the same need differently, and in our scoring better. Its Silver / Supreme / Titanium tiers are all full-home plans at three depths, starting from the published $49/mo — so the choice is not which half of your house to protect, but how much protection to buy, at a price you can see before you choose. A systems-only door matters most to a shopper trying to spend as little as possible on a partial problem; a published full-home ladder matters more to a shopper trying to protect the whole house without a quote-first obstacle course. Select wins the head-to-head round on doors. Empire wins the comparison on the combination that actually decides value: full-home tiers, three depths, one published starting price.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Fee Inside the Quote vs a Fee Inside the Closing Packet vs a Flat $75 in Print

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: an honest tie. The service fee is the price of using the plan you already paid for, and it is the number homeowners feel most often — every claim starts with it. Select does not publish its fee in advance: the amount is set inside the quote and the contract for your home and your plan. First American does not publish its fee in advance either: the amount is set inside its quote and contract too — and its holders face the extra wrinkle that many of them first encounter the figure after closing, in documents assembled by other people, at the exact moment they are least positioned to question it. Neither arrangement is a scandal; both are simply the legacy model, in which the fee is a term you discover rather than a term you compare.

Empire Home Protect publishes a flat $75 trade service call fee in its sample contract booklet. Flat matters as much as published: the fee does not move by plan, by trade, or by how the quote went. When the furnace fails in January, an Empire holder knows the first $75 of the story before the story starts, and knew it before buying. A Select holder learns the fee from the contract they signed after quoting; a First American holder may learn it from a closing packet they received before they owned the house. On the number a homeowner pays most often, print beats paperwork, and this round is not close.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: Caps Inside Two Contracts vs a $10,000 Annual Limit in Print

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: an honest tie. Claim limits decide the worst day, not the average one: they are the ceiling on what the plan will pay when the expensive thing breaks. Select sets its limits inside the quote and the contract, and does not publish them in advance, so a shopper cannot compare its ceiling against the field until the paperwork exists. First American sets its limits the same way, inside the quote and the contract — with the same closing-table wrinkle as its fee, because a limit you first read after you own the home is a limit you never had the chance to weigh. Two contracts, two sets of unpublished ceilings: there is no honest way to score one legacy brand above the other here, and any ranking that pretends otherwise is grading documents it has not shown you.

Empire Home Protect publishes a $10,000 annual aggregate limit in its sample contract booklet. An aggregate limit is the honest way to state a ceiling: one number for the year, in print, that a shopper can set against the real cost of the failures a home actually produces — a furnace, a compressor, a water heater — before deciding whether the plan is sized for their house. Is $10,000 the right ceiling for every home? That is exactly the kind of question a published number lets you ask, and an unpublished one forbids. Round 4 goes to the company that prints its ceiling, for the same reason Round 1 and Round 3 did: a term you can read before you buy is worth more than a term you are handed after.

Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Dispatch Models vs Same-Day Digital Approval

Winner: Empire Home Protect, outright. When something breaks, the two legacy brands run the same play, because it is the industry’s old play: you call, you join a queue, you describe the failure, the claim is logged and worked through a paperwork cycle, a contractor is dispatched, and the repair moves at the speed of that chain. Select runs it. First American runs it. Neither publishes a faster standard, and neither has rebuilt the process around anything digital — the phone call is not one channel among several; it is the front door, the hallway, and most of the rooms. For a homeowner standing in a cold house, the difference between the two legacy brands in this round is the hold music.

Empire Home Protect was built to make this round unfair. Its claims run on a fully digital platform, claims are approved the same day, and service is approved in minutes — the approval step that legacy processes measure in days of queue and callback happens at platform speed. Claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7, because a digital platform does not replace the humans; it removes the waiting that used to stand between the customer and the humans. This is the technology gap in one round: Tesla-and-Apple-class process against the mailer-era model, and it is why claims speed — the moment the product either works or does not — belongs to the #1 pick by the widest margin in this comparison. Our full head-to-heads, Empire Home Protect vs Select Home Warranty and Empire Home Protect vs First American Home Warranty, work through that gap against each brand on its own.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Already holding a quote from one of these companies? Set it next to a published price: Empire Home Protect full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Prefer to talk it through? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 6 — Standout Features: the Quote Everyone Collects vs the Plan That Is Simply There at Closing

Winner: split. Every pairing has one round where each side’s best argument is real, and this is it. Select’s standout is its position in the shopping itself: it is the quote everyone collects. Because its three-part structure is the industry’s reference shape, a Select quote functions as a measuring stick — shoppers collect it to learn what the market charges a home like theirs, and many of them buy it for the same reason they collected it: it was the familiar name with the familiar shelf, and the quote came back acceptable. Familiarity at that scale is a feature, and for a homeowner actively shopping, it is the strongest thing in Select’s column.

First American’s standout is its position in the transaction: it is simply there at closing. No shopping, no quoting, no decision fatigue in the most decision-fatigued week of a buyer’s life — the house changes hands and the warranty is already standing in the corner, covering the systems and appliances from the start of ownership. For a first-time buyer with an older home and no reserve fund, that instant, effort-free coverage has genuine value, and it is the strongest thing in First American’s column. The split is honest: Select’s feature serves the shopper, First American’s serves the transaction. Empire Home Protect’s standout answers both: a published $49/mo price makes it the easiest quote in the field to collect — you start from the number, not from a form — and its digital enrollment makes it nearly as effortless to start as a plan that arrives with the house, without surrendering the choice to the closing packet.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Record Written by Choosers vs a Record Written by Transactions

Winner between the two: Select Home Warranty. Overall: Empire Home Protect. A public record is only useful if you know who wrote it. Select’s record was written by choosers: homeowners who shopped, collected its quote against the field, signed, paid monthly, and filed claims on a plan they picked. That makes its record the more readable of the two — when you read what Select’s customers say, you are reading the experience of people whose situation matches yours if you are shopping today. It is also the more accountable arrangement: a company that must win the customer at the quote lives under a different discipline than a company that meets the customer after the decision.

First American’s record was written substantially by transactions. A large share of its holders never chose it, never compared it, and in many cases never read its terms until a failure forced the introduction — so its public record blends two different things: the experience of the coverage itself, and the friction of holding a contract you did not pick, with a fee and caps you met late. That does not make the record worthless, but it makes it harder to read as a shopping signal, and it is why this round goes to Select outright. Empire Home Protect takes the overall round on a different basis: it publishes no rating it cannot stand behind and invents no review count for itself — instead it publishes the verifiable terms of the deal, from $49/mo to the $75 fee to the $10,000 limit, and lets the record be built by customers who chose it with their eyes open. In a category where records are this easy to misread, printing checkable facts is the strongest record of all.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Select Home Warranty, narrowly. End where the money is. A home warranty’s real price is a year of premiums plus the fees on the claims you actually file, measured against the caps that limit what comes back. Run that math for Empire Home Protect and every input is on the public record: a year at the published $49/mo starting price is $588 in premiums, and a two-claim year adds two flat $75 service fees — $588 plus $150 is $738, computable to the dollar before you buy, against a published $10,000 annual limit. Run the same math for Select and it stops at the first step: no published premium, no published fee, no published caps, so the total exists only inside a quote written for one home on one day. Run it for First American and it stops at the same step, one layer further removed, because the quote may not even be addressed to you. Uncomputable is not a tie at zero; it is a finding about how each company asks to be bought.

Between the two, Select takes the round narrowly on control. Its quote is one you collect yourself, for a plan shape you chose, with the option to walk away and collect another — the ordinary discipline of shopping. First American’s most common path runs the other way: the plan is selected inside a transaction, its terms travel with the house, and the holder’s first real decision point is renewal, a year later, after the fee and the caps have already introduced themselves. A year is a long time to wait for your first decision. So the buying round reads: Empire first, because it publishes the math; Select second, because its math is at least yours to request; First American third, because its math so often arrives already decided.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Buy Empire Home Protect if you want the comparison finished before the sales process starts: published full-home plans from $49/mo in Silver / Supreme / Titanium, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in the sample contract, a 30-day waiting period, and claims approved the same day on a digital platform, with people available 24/7. That is the profile this comparison ranks #1, and it fits the large majority of homeowners reading a head-to-head like this one: people choosing a plan for themselves, for a home they own, with money they would rather verify than trust.

Between only the two legacy brands, Select is the better fit for a homeowner actively shopping: three doors into coverage, a quote you collect and control, and the public record written by people who chose it. First American is the better fit only in the narrow case where its one standout feature is the whole point — a plan arriving with a house at closing, when no shopping will happen at all. And if a First American plan already came with your home, keep the coverage, learn its fee and caps now rather than at the first breakdown, and treat renewal as the moment the plan finally gets chosen — against a published $49/mo alternative.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

Select Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty is a contest between the quote everyone collects and the plan that arrives with the house — and on the facts, Select edges it for anyone shopping for themselves, on three doors instead of two, a quote you control, and a record written by choosers. First American keeps the closing table, and only the closing table. But the larger fact of this pairing is what neither brand publishes: no starting price, no service fee, no claim caps, and a claims process that still begins in a phone queue. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it answers every one of those gaps in print and in process — full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, a 30-day waiting period, and same-day digital claims approval with service in minutes, handled with integrity and respect. Do not take this page’s word for any of it: the sample contract is public, the price is published, and the quote takes minutes. Check the #1 pick first, then let every other quote — including both of these — try to beat a number you can actually see.