Select Home Warranty and 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty look like opposites on the shelf, and in one respect they are. Select Home Warranty is the familiar name in the middle of most shortlists: a standard three-part shelf — a systems plan, an appliances plan, and a combined plan that joins the two — priced entirely by quote, the plan shoppers most often collect as the third quote before they decide. 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is the builder-and-closing-table veteran: founded in 1980 in Colorado, built on builder structural warranties and real-estate transactions, selling in 48 states, and since December 2024 owned by Frontdoor, Inc., the same parent company as American Home Shield. Unlike Select, 2-10 publishes flat prices — Systems at $39.99/mo and Pinnacle at $59.99/mo — and publishes claim caps clearer than most of the industry’s. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Select Home Warranty review and 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty review.
The short version: between the two, 2-10 wins the transparency rounds outright. It publishes flat prices that do not change with your home’s size, age, or location, and it publishes claim caps — $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, $50,000 per term — that are the clearest in its class. Select wins the rounds that rest on flexibility and familiarity: its three doors include an appliances-only plan that 2-10 does not offer at all, and it is the name homeowners already know how to shop, with a public record written directly by the homeowners who hold its plans. But read 2-10’s headline price carefully, because it is not the whole-home price: the cheaper Systems plan at $39.99/mo covers no appliances at all, and to cover the whole home the way a combined plan does, a 2-10 buyer steps up to Pinnacle at $59.99/mo — before a reported 9.5% processing markup on monthly billing, and with a service fee chosen at checkout rather than published as one figure. Select, for its part, publishes no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps at all — all three live inside a quote and a contract. And both companies run the same traditional model behind the shelf: a 30-day wait before coverage starts and a phone-driven claims process where a queue and a paperwork cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, a full $10.99/mo below 2-10’s comparable Pinnacle tier, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, from its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.
Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1
Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that legacy sellers still do by phone queue, paperwork, and waiting — handled with integrity and respect, and backed in its sample contract by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims at (855) 203-9876. Terms come from the Comprehensive sample booklet and vary by plan, administrator, and state.
Where does that leave the head-to-head itself? Honestly scored, 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty beats Select Home Warranty on the rounds that rest on publication: it prints flat prices and printed caps, and Select prints neither. Select beats 2-10 on the rounds that rest on the shelf itself and the direct homeowner relationship: its three doors include an appliances-only option 2-10 never offers, its combined plan is the standard whole-home shape shoppers already understand, and its public record is the one written by homeowners rather than by builders and closing tables. On claims speed, neither legacy brand beats the other, because both run the same traditional claims architecture. A homeowner buying on checkable facts gets more verifiable value from Empire Home Protect than from either — and between these two alone, the deciding fact is whether you trust printed numbers with a trap door in the cheap one (2-10) or a familiar shelf with no numbers printed at all (Select).
One honesty note before the rounds, because it matters to how we rank: we publish no star rating or review count for Empire Home Protect anywhere in this comparison, because no verified review record for it exists yet and we will not invent one. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 here on checkable contract terms — published price, published flat fee, published annual limit, and a stated digital claims process — not on a reputation score nobody can verify. Select and 2-10 both have longer public records than Empire Home Protect, and where that record wins a round below, we say so plainly.
See Your Empire Home Protect Price
Get your quote online in minutes — full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, and claims approved the same day. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteSelect Home Warranty vs 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick
Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7; terms printed in the sample booklet (Aegis Administration, LLC; Assurance Express, LLC; Lexington National Insurance Corporation) before you buy.
Select Home Warranty: the standard three-part structure — a systems plan, an appliances plan, and a combined plan joining the two; pricing by quote only — no published starting figure a buyer can verify in advance; service fee and claim limits set in the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims process; the familiar third quote on most shortlists, with a readable homeowner-facing public record.
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty: two homeowner plans at flat published prices — Systems at $39.99/mo (systems only, no appliances) and Pinnacle at $59.99/mo (systems plus kitchen and laundry appliances); published claim caps of $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, and $50,000 per term; a service fee you choose at purchase rather than one published figure; a reported 9.5% processing markup on monthly billing; 30-day wait and traditional dispatch claims; founded in 1980, available in 48 states, owned by Frontdoor, Inc. since December 2024.
What Each Company Actually Is: the Familiar Third Quote vs the Builder-Channel Veteran
A home warranty is a service contract: when a named system or appliance in your tier fails from normal wear and tear, you file a claim, pay a per-claim service fee, and the plan arranges and pays toward the repair or replacement, up to the contract’s limits. It is not homeowners insurance (that covers perils like fire and theft), and it is not maintenance (filters, flushing, and servicing stay your job, and keep systems eligible). Both companies in this head-to-head sell that same underlying contract. What differs is the shape of the shelf and who the company was built to sell to.
Select Home Warranty sells the contract in the industry’s most standard shape. Its shelf is three doors: a plan for the home’s systems (the furnace, the air conditioning, the plumbing and electrical backbone), a plan for its appliances (the kitchen and laundry machines), and a combined plan that covers both halves together. Almost every established seller uses some version of that structure, which is exactly why Select is so easy to shop against: a buyer who has collected one or two quotes already knows what each Select door means, and Select is the name most often gathered as the third quote that settles the comparison. The rest of the architecture is the older pattern: the price arrives by quote after you share details about your home and state, and claims move through a phone-driven process.
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty sells the same contract from the other side of the closing table. It was founded in 1980 in Colorado on builder structural warranties — the multi-year coverage builders put on new homes — and grew through real-estate transactions, where a plan is included in a sale or handed over in a closing packet. It says it has covered more than 5.5 million homes over its history, a company claim we print as a claim, not as an audited figure. Its homeowner plans are the retail shelf on top of that builder business, and since December 2024 the whole company has sat inside Frontdoor, Inc., alongside American Home Shield. None of that makes 2-10 a bad plan — its published caps are genuinely the clearest in this pairing — but a buyer should know the company’s deepest relationships are with builders and agents, not with the homeowner holding the contract.
The question this head-to-head asks is narrower and more useful than which name is more familiar: on the day your furnace dies in January, what does each model actually do for you? In the traditional process both of these companies run, a phone queue and a paperwork cycle come first. On a digital platform, a claim approved the same day and service approved in minutes is the whole point. Keep that day in mind through every round below.
Round 1 — Price: a Quote vs Flat Prices With a Trap Door vs a Published $49/mo
Between the two, 2-10 wins this round, and it is not close on the narrow question of publication. 2-10 prints its prices: Systems at a flat $39.99/mo and Pinnacle at a flat $59.99/mo, reported as the same regardless of your home’s size, location, or age. A buyer can write both numbers down before any conversation begins. Select prints nothing: its price arrives by quote, after you provide your home’s size, location, and the door you want, so there is no published starting figure for us, or for you, to verify in advance.
Now the two catches inside 2-10’s win, because both are structural. First, the headline price is not the whole-home price. Systems at $39.99/mo covers systems only — no appliances at all. The day the refrigerator or the washer fails, a Systems buyer has no coverage for it. To cover the whole home the way a combined plan does, a 2-10 buyer steps up to Pinnacle at $59.99/mo. Second, monthly billing carries a processing-fee markup reported at 9.5%, so the monthly payer’s real premium runs above the printed flat price. Neither catch erases the round — a printed price with catches still beats no printed price — but both belong in the math in Round 8.
Against the #1 pick, the like-for-like comparison is the one that matters. Empire Home Protect publishes $49/mo as the starting price for full-home tiers — coverage that includes appliances from the first tier up. Set against the only 2-10 plan that covers the whole home, Pinnacle at $59.99/mo, Empire starts $10.99/mo lower, before 2-10’s reported monthly markup widens the gap further. Select cannot enter this comparison at all until it quotes your home. Round 1 to 2-10 between the two; Empire Home Protect ahead of both on comparable full-home price.
Round 2 — Plans and Coverage: Three Familiar Doors vs a Systems-Only Door and a Full Door
Select’s shelf is three doors, and the middle one is the point of this round. A systems plan covers the backbone; an appliances plan covers the kitchen and laundry on its own; and a combined plan joins both halves into whole-home coverage. That appliances-only door matters more than it looks: a homeowner whose systems are newer, or whose landlord or association already handles the backbone, can cover exactly the machines most likely to fail without paying for a systems plan they do not need. It is the standard structure for a reason — each door means what a shopper expects it to mean.
2-10’s shelf is two plans, counted more precisely than Select’s: Systems covers 19 systems and Pinnacle covers 28 items, systems plus kitchen and laundry appliances. That item-level clarity is real, and we credit it. But the structure carries the trap from Round 1 into the coverage itself: there is no appliances-only door at all, and the entry plan excludes the entire appliance category. A homeowner who buys the cheaper plan in a hurry — or receives it in a closing packet without reading closely — can reasonably believe they hold whole-home coverage until the first appliance claim says otherwise. Separate builder structural warranties and seller plans also run through 2-10’s real-estate channels, which is depth for builders, not simplicity for homeowners.
Empire Home Protect’s ladder is three tiers with no category trap: Silver for core systems coverage, Supreme for full home coverage, and Titanium for total coverage plus premium perks — each tier a step up the same whole-home frame, priced from a published $49/mo. Round 2 to Select between the two, narrowly: its three doors include the one door 2-10 never offers. Empire’s three-tier ladder stays the clearest shelf in the comparison.
Round 3 — Service Fees: a Fee Inside the Quote vs a Fee Chosen at Checkout vs a Flat $75 in Print
Every claim in every plan here carries a per-claim service fee, and in a two- or three-claim year that fee line can matter as much as the premium. Neither company in this head-to-head publishes one single fee figure a buyer can shop against — but they hide it in different places, and the difference is worth a round.
Select sets its service fee inside the quote and the contract: you learn the number as part of a sales conversation, attached to a specific home and tier, and it is not printed anywhere you can check before that conversation starts. 2-10 lets the buyer choose the service fee at purchase, from a menu at checkout: the number is visible before you sign, and choosing a higher fee generally trades against the premium. Published sources report those menus inconsistently across years, so we print no single 2-10 fee figure here — but a fee you pick yourself, in the open, before paying, is a more honest arrangement than a fee that arrives inside a quote. Round 3 to 2-10 between the two, narrowly, on visibility at the moment of purchase.
Empire Home Protect prints the simplest version of this line in the field: a flat $75 trade service call fee, stated in the sample booklet before you buy, the same for every claim. No menu, no quote, no conversation required to know it. That is the standard both legacy brands are being measured against, and neither reaches it.
Round 4 — Claim Limits: Caps Inside the Contract vs the Clearest Published Caps in the Class
This is 2-10’s best round, and it wins it outright. 2-10 publishes its claim caps: $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, and $50,000 per agreement term. Those are per-item and per-term figures a buyer can read before paying, compare against the replacement cost of the systems in their own home, and hold the company to afterward. Most of this industry — Select included — does not do that.
Select’s caps live in the quote and the contract. They exist, they bind, and they vary — but a buyer shopping before the sales conversation cannot see them, cannot compare them against a rival’s, and cannot do the replacement-cost check that 2-10’s printed caps make possible. On the single discipline of publishing the limits that decide what a claim is actually worth, Select is behind not only 2-10 but the standard this guide applies to everyone.
Empire Home Protect publishes its limit in a different shape: a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, printed in the sample booklet. An aggregate is easier to reason about across a bad year — one pot, stated plainly — while 2-10’s per-item caps are more granular. We score the shapes as different, not as one beating the other, and we say plainly what we said in the 2-10 head-to-head: on published per-item caps specifically, 2-10’s transparency is genuine and rare. Round 4 to 2-10 outright between the two.
Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Dispatch Models vs Same-Day Digital Approval
On the worst day — no heat in January, no cold air in August, water where water should not be — claims speed is the product. Everything else in this comparison is paperwork until that day arrives. And on that day, neither company in this head-to-head separates from the other.
Select runs the traditional process: file by phone, enter the queue, move through the paperwork cycle, wait for dispatch. 2-10 runs the same architecture from inside a large legacy parent: a service request, a contractor dispatched through its network, a service fee collected on the visit. Both companies also start coverage 30 days after purchase, the industry’s standard wait, so neither protects you in the first month either. The processes differ in branding and in the size of the machine behind them; from the homeowner’s side of the phone, they feel the same, because they are the same model.
Empire Home Protect was built to break exactly this tie. Its platform is fully digital: claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, with people available 24/7 when you want a human instead of a screen. That is the Tesla-and-Apple difference applied to a service contract — the technology does the queuing, the routing, and the approval work that the old-school model does by phone tag. Round 5 is a tie between the two, and it is the round the #1 pick wins against the whole field.
Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote
Full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, and claims approved the same day. See your price online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteRound 6 — Standout Features: the Third Quote Everyone Collects vs a Builder Specialty Nobody Else Has
Every company in this guide has one thing it does that the others do not, and this round scores those honestly. Select’s standout is its place in the shopping process itself: it is the familiar third quote. Because its shelf uses the standard systems / appliances / combined structure, a Select quote slots cleanly next to any two quotes a homeowner has already gathered and settles the comparison — same doors, same vocabulary, one more price to weigh. That familiarity is a real service to a shopper, even if it is a service to the process rather than to the home.
2-10’s standout is bigger and genuinely unmatched in this pairing: builder structural warranties. The multi-year structural coverage it writes for builders is a specialty no pure home-warranty seller in our guide offers, and its workmanship guarantee is singled out by reviewers as longer than the industry’s usual 30 days. For a buyer of a newly built home, or a homeowner whose house came with 2-10 structural coverage already in place, keeping the service relationship in one house has real logic to it. The caveat is audience: this specialty serves the builder channel first. A homeowner buying a retail plan for an existing house is buying next to the specialty, not inside it.
Round 6 to 2-10 between the two — a category nobody else here contests beats a shopping convenience several rivals share. Empire Home Protect’s standout remains the one from Round 5: same-day digital approval is a feature the homeowner feels on the worst day, not a specialty that serves a different customer.
Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: Two Different Kinds of History
This round needs care, because both companies can honestly claim a long history — of different things. 2-10 was founded in 1980. Forty-five years of operating history is longer than almost anyone in this guide, and its claim of more than 5.5 million homes covered across that history reflects real scale. If the only question were which company has existed longest, 2-10 would win the round walking away.
But a homeowner does not buy a founding date; they buy a record they can read. 2-10’s history runs through builders, agents, and closing tables — channels where the person who chose the plan is usually not the person who later files the claim. Select’s history runs directly through homeowners: it sells these contracts to the people who use them, in the standard structure shoppers already know, and its public record is correspondingly readable — written by the customer who paid, about the doors and the claims process a new buyer is actually weighing. That is the record a buyer researching this head-to-head can actually learn from, and it is why Select’s familiarity has always been scored as its lead in our guide.
Round 7 to Select between the two, on the homeowner-facing record — with 2-10’s longer corporate history, and the builder-channel shape of it, stated in full. Empire Home Protect is the newer name in this comparison and publishes no rating or review count, by design; it wins this guide on printed terms and claims speed, and this round is the honest price of that position.
Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check
How you buy decides how much of the math you can check before money moves. With 2-10, the premium math starts in the open: flat prices, printed caps, a fee you choose at checkout. With Select, the math starts in a sales conversation: the quote assembles the premium, the fee, and the caps together, and checking any one of them means engaging the whole process. Empire Home Protect sells the way the #1 pick should: a published starting price, a printed fee and limit, and an online quote you can complete on your own schedule.
Now the two-claim year, computed only from figures each company itself publishes. Empire Home Protect: $49/mo across twelve months is $588 in premiums, plus two claims at the flat $75 fee is $150 — $738 for the year, fully checkable before you buy. 2-10 Pinnacle, the comparable whole-home plan: $59.99/mo across twelve months is $719.88, and the reported 9.5% processing markup on monthly billing adds roughly $68.39, bringing the premium side to about $788.27 — before a single service fee, and the fee cannot be added from published figures because it is chosen at checkout from a menu no single published number represents. The cheaper Systems plan computes to $479.88 plus roughly $45.59 of markup, about $525.47 before fees — a lower number that buys no appliance coverage at all. Select: the year cannot be computed. No published premium, no published fee, no published caps — the total exists only inside a quote.
Read that math the way a buyer should. 2-10 lets you compute most of your year and hides the last line at checkout. Select hides the whole page until the conversation. Empire publishes every line. Round 8 to Empire Home Protect outright; between the two, 2-10’s partial math beats Select’s none.
Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand
Choose 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty if printed numbers are your first filter and you will buy the right tier on purpose: you want flat pricing that ignores your home’s size and age, published per-item caps you can check against your own systems, and a fee you select yourself — and you will step up to Pinnacle at $59.99/mo knowingly, because you understand the $39.99 Systems plan covers no appliances. Buyers of newly built homes with 2-10 structural coverage already in place have the strongest version of this case.
Choose Select Home Warranty if the standard shelf is your first filter: you want the familiar systems / appliances / combined structure, including an appliances-only door for a home whose systems are already handled, and you are collecting the third quote that settles a comparison you have already started — and you are willing to work that quote hard, with premium, service fee, and caps all extracted and compared in writing before you sign, because none of those numbers is published for you in advance.
Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the comparison settled before the sales conversation starts: full-home plans from a published $49/mo — below 2-10’s comparable tier and checkable against any Select quote the moment it arrives — a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in a sample booklet you can read first, and a claims process built to approve the same day and approve service in minutes, with people available 24/7. For most homeowners reading a head-to-head like this one, that combination is why Empire ranks #1 here.
See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home
Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteThe Bottom Line
Select Home Warranty vs 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is a choice between two kinds of trust. 2-10 asks you to trust its printed numbers — flat prices, published caps, a chosen fee — and earns real credit for printing them, so long as you read past the systems-only headline price to the $59.99 whole-home tier and the monthly markup behind it. Select asks you to trust its familiarity — the standard three-door shelf, the appliances-only option, the quote every shortlist already includes — and earns real credit there, so long as you accept that every number that decides value waits inside its quote. Between the two, 2-10 wins more rounds on transparency; Select wins the shelf and the record a homeowner can read.
Empire Home Protect ranks #1 in this comparison because it refuses the choice between those two kinds of trust. It prints the numbers — from $49/mo, a flat $75 fee, a $10,000 annual limit, all in a sample contract you can read before you buy — and it replaces the traditional claims queue both of these companies run with a fully digital process that approves claims the same day and service in minutes, handled with integrity and respect. Start with your Empire quote, then hold every other number in this comparison up against it.