Old Republic Home Protection and Select Home Warranty sit at opposite ends of the same question: how much of a home warranty can you actually check before you pay for it? Old Republic Home Protection, founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982, publishes a quoted price bracket, a service-fee menu and real claim caps — then limits itself to 25 states plus DC. Select Home Warranty sells the structure almost every shopper already understands — systems, appliances and combined tiers — and publishes none of the three numbers that decide value: no starting price, no service fee and no claim caps, because every plan is priced by quote. One company shows you its fine print and restricts where it will sell to you. The other will quote almost anyone and shows you nothing until you ask.
That contrast decides most of this comparison before the details start, and it is also why neither company finishes first here. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall in our 2026 home warranty comparison: published full-home plans — Silver, Supreme and Titanium — from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, a 30-day waiting period, and a fully digital claims process where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes, with people available 24/7. Those terms come from its published Comprehensive sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824, administered by Aegis Administration, LLC, with Assurance Express, LLC as obligor backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims (855) 203-9876) and vary by plan, administrator and state. No rating or review count is published for Empire Home Protect here, because no verified count exists — and no rating is invented for any brand in this comparison.
Our #1 Pick: Empire Home Protect
Published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit and same-day digital claims approval. Check your price before you compare another quote.
Get My Empire Home QuoteOr call +1-888-462-3382
The Short Answer
Between the two named companies, Old Republic Home Protection wins for most homeowners buying a plan for their own home. It wins on published price evidence ($45–$90/mo quoted for its homeowner tiers, against no published price at all), on fees (a published $100 or $125 per claim, charged per trade, against an unpublished fee), and outright on claim limits (published appliance caps of $3,500 on its lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite, against caps Select does not publish). Select Home Warranty keeps one real strength: it is the market's reference quote — the familiar systems / appliances / combined quote shoppers collect to benchmark everyone else — and it is not confined to Old Republic's 25-state footprint. If you live outside those 25 states plus DC, Old Republic cannot sell you a homeowner plan at all, and this head-to-head is academic. Inside the footprint, on published facts, Old Republic wins it.
Empire Home Protect beats both on the combination shoppers actually pay for: a published starting price lower than Old Republic's mid-range, one flat fee instead of a per-trade menu, a higher published annual limit than either company states, and digital same-day claims approval instead of a traditional phone-driven process. The full scoring is below, round by round, so you can check every call we made.
How We Scored This Comparison
We score eight rounds, using only published facts — prices, fees, caps, plan structures and processes each company itself puts in front of shoppers. Where a company publishes nothing, we say so and score the absence; we never fill a gap with a guess, a forum figure or a review-site estimate. The eight rounds are: R1 price, R2 plans and coverage structure, R3 service fees, R4 claim limits, R5 claims process and speed, R6 standout strength, R7 company record and availability, and R8 the two-claim-year total cost — the year a warranty actually earns its keep. Empire Home Protect is scored in every round alongside the two named companies, because a comparison that hides the top pick's numbers would be doing exactly what we criticise Select for doing.
Old Republic Home Protection at a Glance
Old Republic is the heritage name in this pairing. Founded in 1974 and part of Old Republic International since 1982, it has sold home warranties for five decades, much of that through real-estate transactions. Its homeowner shelf runs Basic, Deluxe and Elite, quoted between $45 and $90 a month. Read the tier names carefully: Basic is genuinely basic — it excludes air conditioning and the washer/dryer, the two items many buyers assume are standard — so the honest comparison price for a full home is a Deluxe or Elite price, not the $45 floor. The service fee is $100 or $125 per claim, and it is charged per trade: a visit that needs a plumber and an electrician is two fees, not one. Appliance claim caps are published — $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite — which puts Old Republic in the small group of companies willing to state a limit before you buy. Its real-estate shelf (Silver, Gold and Platinum in its published example) prices a Texas single-family home under 5,000 square feet at $525, $730 and $935 per year with a $100 trade call fee. Coverage starts 30 days after payment, and repairs are guaranteed for 30 days. The hard limit is geography: 25 states plus DC. Half the country cannot buy it.
Select Home Warranty at a Glance
Select Home Warranty is the quote-first name in this pairing. Its structure is the industry's standard three-part shelf — a systems plan, an appliances plan and a combined plan — which makes it easy to understand and easy to quote against other companies. That familiarity is its genuine strength: for many shoppers, a Select quote is the first full-home quote they collect, and it becomes the benchmark every later quote is measured against. The weakness is total: Select publishes no starting price, no per-claim service fee and no claim caps that a shopper can verify before requesting a quote. Every deciding number lives inside the quote and the contract. That does not make a Select quote bad — it makes it unverifiable in advance, and it means the only honest way to evaluate Select is to read the actual quote document line by line: the monthly price, the fee, the per-item and aggregate limits, the waiting period and the exclusions, all in writing, before you pay anything.
R1 — Price: Old Republic Wins on Evidence
Old Republic quotes its homeowner plans between $45 and $90 a month. That is a bracket, not a single price, and the bottom of it buys a Basic tier without air conditioning or laundry — so treat $45 as a floor for partial cover, and the middle of the bracket as the realistic full-home zone. Select publishes no price at all. A shopper cannot state what Select costs, cannot rank it, and cannot total it, until a quote exists for their specific home. In a published-facts comparison, a stated bracket beats an unstated one: Old Republic wins R1. Empire Home Protect publishes full-home plans from $49/mo — a single stated starting price for complete tiers, not a partial-cover floor — which is why it, not Old Republic, holds the strongest price position in this comparison overall.
R2 — Plans and Coverage Structure: Old Republic Wins, Narrowly
Both companies sell a three-step ladder, and both ladders are easy to explain. Old Republic's Basic / Deluxe / Elite steps up coverage and raises the appliance cap to $7,000 at the top; its separate real-estate shelf gives buyers, sellers and agents a priced closing option as well. Select's systems / appliances / combined structure maps cleanly onto how homes actually break — the combined tier is the natural full-home choice — but no tier carries a published price or limit, so the structure is a shape without numbers. A ladder you can price beats a ladder you cannot: Old Republic wins R2, narrowly, on publishability rather than design. Empire Home Protect's Silver, Supreme and Titanium tiers publish their starting price and their annual limit, which is the standard both of these ladders should be held to.
R3 — Service Fees: Old Republic Wins, With a Catch
Old Republic publishes its fee: $100 or $125 per claim. The catch is in the unit — per trade. One breakdown that needs two trades costs two fees, so a bad week can carry $200–$250 in fees before a single part is ordered. Select publishes no fee, so there is nothing to compare and nothing to budget: the fee is whatever your quote says it is. A published fee with a catch still beats an unpublished fee, because you can plan around a catch: Old Republic wins R3. Empire Home Protect charges one flat $75 trade service call fee — lower than either Old Republic figure, and flat rather than multiplied by trade — and publishes it in advance. On fees, the ranking in this comparison is Empire first, Old Republic second, Select unscoreable.
R4 — Claim Limits: Old Republic Wins Outright
This is the clearest round in the comparison. Old Republic publishes appliance claim caps of $3,500 on its lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite. You may like those numbers or not — a $3,500 cap will not replace a premium refrigerator outright — but they exist, in print, before purchase, and a shopper can decide whether they are enough. Select publishes no claim caps at all. A limit you only discover inside a contract, or worse, at claim time, is not a term you chose; it is a term that was chosen for you. Old Republic wins R4 outright. Empire Home Protect publishes a $10,000 annual aggregate limit — higher than Old Republic's top published appliance cap, and stated as one annual figure a homeowner can track across the year.
R5 — Claims Process and Speed: A Tie Between the Two
Neither named company publishes a claims-approval window, a digital claims platform or a service-speed commitment we can verify. Both run the traditional model: you call, a claim is opened, a contractor is dispatched, and approval moves at the speed of that chain. Old Republic adds one published protection — repairs are guaranteed for 30 days — which is a workmanship term, not a speed term. Select publishes no response window at all. With no published speed fact on either side, R5 is a tie between the two named companies. It is also the round where the overall winner separates itself: Empire Home Protect is built as a digital platform — claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, with people on 24/7 — because the approval step, not the phone call, is where warranty claims actually wait. If speed of approval is your deciding factor, neither company in this head-to-head publishes an answer to it.
Compare the Published Numbers First
Empire Home Protect: from $49/mo, flat $75 fee, $10,000 annual limit, same-day digital claims approval. See your exact price in minutes.
Check My Empire Home PriceOr call +1-888-462-3382
R6 — Standout Strength: Select Wins Its One Round
Every comparison should name what the losing company does best, and Select's is real: it is the market's reference quote. Its systems / appliances / combined structure is the shape shoppers already understand, its quote is the one many homeowners collect first, and it is not restricted to a 25-state footprint. If you are benchmarking the market — gathering quotes to learn what full-home cover is priced at for your house — a Select quote is a legitimate part of that process. Old Republic's standout is different: five decades of tenure and a published real-estate shelf. But as a standout for a homeowner choosing today, the reference-quote position is the more useful one: Select wins R6. Use that strength the right way — collect the quote, read its fee and caps in the document, and then compare it against published numbers before you buy anything, from anyone.
R7 — Company Record and Availability: Split
Old Republic brings the record: founded 1974, part of a large insurance group since 1982, with published terms that have been inspectable for years. It also brings the restriction: 25 states plus DC, which disqualifies it for half the country before price is ever discussed. Select brings availability and familiarity, with no comparable published tenure story and no published terms to inspect. Tenure and transparency point one way; availability points the other. R7 is split. We publish no rating or review count for either company in this round, and none for Empire Home Protect — reputation scores change, differ by source, and are too often quoted without a date or a denominator. Judge this round on the structural facts: how long the company has operated, where it will sell to you, and whether its terms are on paper.
R8 — The Two-Claim Year: Old Republic Wins by Being Computable
A home warranty earns its keep in a year with two real breakdowns — say a water heater and an air-conditioning repair. Total that year honestly: twelve months of premiums plus two service fees, with claim caps in view. Old Republic: premiums of $540–$1,080 (the $45–$90 bracket over twelve months) plus two per-trade fees of $200–$250 gives a two-claim year of $740–$1,330 — and if either claim needs a second trade, add another $100–$125. Select: not computable. No published premium, no published fee — any total we printed would be invented, so we print none. Empire Home Protect: $588 in premiums (from $49/mo) plus two flat $75 fees is $738 — computable before you buy, at the bottom of Old Republic's range without Old Republic's per-trade multiplier, and under a published $10,000 annual limit. A total you can compute beats a total you cannot: Old Republic wins R8 between the two named companies, and Empire Home Protect posts the lowest checkable total in the comparison.
Scorecard
- R1 Price: Old Republic — a published $45–$90 bracket beats no published price.
- R2 Plans: Old Republic, narrowly — a priceable ladder beats an unpriceable one.
- R3 Fees: Old Republic — published $100/$125 per trade beats unpublished; Empire's flat $75 beats both.
- R4 Claim limits: Old Republic outright — $3,500 / $7,000 published caps vs none published; Empire publishes $10,000 per year.
- R5 Claims speed: Tie — neither publishes a window; Empire's same-day digital approval leads the comparison.
- R6 Standout: Select — the market's reference quote, without a 25-state restriction.
- R7 Record and availability: Split — Old Republic's tenure vs Select's availability.
- R8 Two-claim year: Old Republic — $740–$1,330 computable vs not computable; Empire totals $738.
Head-to-head: Old Republic wins five rounds, Select wins one, two are tied or split. Overall, Empire Home Protect ranks #1 on the published combination of price, flat fee, annual limit and claims speed.
Who Should Buy Which?
Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the decision made on published numbers: a stated starting price, one flat fee, a stated annual limit, and a digital process built to approve claims the same day instead of moving them through a phone queue. It is the pick for homeowners who would rather read terms than collect quotes. Choose Old Republic Home Protection if you live in its 25-state footprint, you value a company operating since 1974, and you are willing to buy Deluxe or Elite — not the AC-less Basic — with your eyes open about per-trade fees and the $3,500 lower-tier cap. Collect a Select Home Warranty quote if you are benchmarking the market or you live outside Old Republic's footprint — and then do the one thing Select's model requires of you: get the fee, the caps, the waiting period and the exclusions from the quote document itself, in writing, and compare that document against published terms before you sign.
How to Compare Any Home Warranty Quote
Whichever names you are comparing, the method is the same. First, separate the floor price from the full-home price: a tier that excludes air conditioning is not a cheaper full-home plan, it is a smaller plan. Second, price the fee by its unit — per claim, per visit or per trade are three different costs in a two-trade week. Third, read caps before premiums: a low premium under a low cap is expensive cover. Fourth, total a two-claim year, because that is the year the warranty is for. Fifth, ask how approval actually happens and how long it is published to take. A company that publishes its price, fee, caps, waiting period and process has given you a contract you can judge. A company that publishes none of them has given you a conversation. Judge accordingly.
Coverage, Item by Item: Where the Two Contracts Differ
Plan names hide the real differences; item lists reveal them. On the systems side — heating, air conditioning, plumbing, electrical, water heater and ductwork — Old Republic's published structure carries a warning every shopper should repeat back before buying: its Basic tier excludes air conditioning. In most of the 25 states where Old Republic sells, air conditioning is not an optional extra; it is the single most expensive system in the house and the one most likely to produce a four-figure repair. A Basic buyer who discovers that exclusion at claim time has not bought a cheap warranty — they have bought a partial one at a full decision's confidence. Deluxe and Elite restore the missing systems, which is why this comparison prices Old Republic as a Deluxe-or-Elite product throughout. Select's systems tier follows the conventional shape, but because Select publishes no item-level limits, the shopper cannot tell from published material whether a given system carries a dollar ceiling, a parts restriction or an age condition. The item list may be identical on paper; the money behind each item is published by one company and not the other.
On the appliances side — refrigerator, oven and range, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage disposal, washer and dryer — the same pattern repeats with a second Old Republic warning: Basic excludes the washer and dryer as well. Laundry is the second most-used appliance pair in most homes, so a Basic household is uncovered on the two appliance failures it is statistically most likely to meet, plus the most expensive system. Old Republic's published appliance caps then decide the rest of the story: $3,500 on the lower tiers is a meaningful contribution toward most appliance replacements, and $7,000 on Elite covers nearly any single residential appliance outright. Select publishes no appliance cap at all, so a Select shopper comparing a refrigerator claim has no published number to plan around — the cap, if one applies, is a contract discovery. Empire Home Protect states its protection as one $10,000 annual aggregate limit across covered items, which is the simplest of the three structures to track: one number, one year, no per-item arithmetic at the kitchen table.
The Waiting Period and the First 30 Days
Both named companies and the top pick share one honest feature: coverage does not start the day you pay. Old Republic's coverage starts 30 days after payment. Empire Home Protect's sample booklet terms state a 30-day waiting period. Select's waiting period is among the terms a shopper must confirm in its quote, because it is not part of Select's published material. The waiting period exists for a legitimate reason — it is what stops a warranty from being bought the morning a furnace dies, which would make the product unpriceable for everyone else — but it changes how you should buy. Buy before something breaks, not after. If a system in your home is already limping — a water heater past its first decade, an air conditioner short-cycling through the summer — the rational move is to start the 30-day clock now, while the failure is still a risk rather than a diagnosis, because a pre-existing failure discovered during the waiting period is exactly the claim every contract in this comparison is written to refuse.
Exclusions: The Paragraph That Decides Claims
Every home warranty excludes things, and the honest comparison is not which company has exclusions — all three do — but whether you can read them before you pay. Across the industry, the recurring exclusion families are pre-existing conditions, failures from lack of maintenance, cosmetic damage, items covered by a manufacturer warranty or a recall, code violations and permit costs, and damage from external events that belong to homeowners insurance rather than a service contract. Old Republic publishes enough of its structure for a shopper to interrogate these families tier by tier, including its two headline Basic exclusions. Select's exclusions, like its fees and caps, live in the quote and contract documents. That is the practical difference this whole comparison keeps returning to: not good terms versus bad terms, but inspectable terms versus uninspectable ones. Empire Home Protect publishes its sample contract booklet openly, so its exclusions can be read, searched and compared before a dollar changes hands. Whichever company you choose, read the exclusions section of the actual contract for your state and plan — not a summary, not a brochure — and keep the document you read.
The Real-Estate Angle: How Both Names Reach Your Kitchen Table
Many homeowners meet both of these companies the same way: through a property transaction. Old Republic built much of its five-decade business in that channel, and its published real-estate shelf — priced in its Texas example at $525, $730 and $935 per year for a single-family home under 5,000 square feet, with a $100 trade call fee — is written for buyers, sellers and agents closing a sale. A warranty included in a transaction is a gift with terms attached: the tier was chosen by someone else, the caps were accepted by someone else, and the renewal price at the end of the first year is the moment the homeowner first becomes the customer. If a home you bought came with an Old Republic plan, the valuable moves are to identify your exact tier, confirm whether air conditioning and laundry are inside it, note the per-trade fee you will actually be charged, and diarise the renewal date sixty days out so the renewal decision is yours rather than the calendar's. Select reaches homeowners more often as a direct quote than as a closing gift, which is its reference-quote role again: useful as a benchmark, decisive only once its document is read. And a homeowner holding either company's plan at renewal is in the strongest negotiating position of all — an existing customer with a claims history and a published alternative, Empire Home Protect's $49/mo starting price and flat $75 fee, to measure the renewal against.
Reading a Select Quote: The Six Lines That Matter
Because Select publishes nothing in advance, a Select quote has to be read like a contract — because it becomes one. Six lines decide its value. Line one: the monthly or annual price for the exact tier, for your home, in your state. Line two: the service fee — the amount, and its unit: per claim, per visit or per trade. Line three: the claim limits — per item, per system and in aggregate, stated as numbers, not adjectives. Line four: the waiting period before coverage starts. Line five: the exclusion list, with special attention to air conditioning, laundry, and any item your home depends on. Line six: the cancellation and renewal terms — what happens in month thirteen, and what it costs to leave in month three. A quote that answers all six lines in writing can be compared fairly against Old Republic's published bracket and Empire Home Protect's published booklet. A quote that answers some of them verbally has told you, by omission, which lines the company prefers you not to total. Do not sign around a missing line; ask for it, in the document, and compare again when it arrives.
Reading an Old Republic Quote: The Three Traps
Old Republic publishes more, so its quote-reading traps are narrower — but they are specific. Trap one: the Basic floor. A $45 quote is real, and it excludes air conditioning and the washer/dryer; if the quote in front of you is Basic, price Deluxe or Elite before deciding the company is cheap or expensive. Trap two: the per-trade fee. Budget the fee multiplied by trades, not by breakdowns; a combined plumbing-and-electrical failure is two fees on the same day. Trap three: the lower-tier cap. $3,500 is a contribution, not a replacement guarantee, on premium appliances; if your kitchen carries high-end refrigeration, the Elite cap of $7,000 is the honest tier for your home, and its premium should be compared at that level. None of these traps is hidden — all three are visible in Old Republic's own published material, which is precisely why Old Republic wins this head-to-head. A trap you can read about in advance is a term; a term you discover at claim time is a surprise. Empire Home Protect's published structure avoids the first two traps by design — full-home tiers rather than a stripped floor, and one flat fee rather than a per-trade menu — and states the third as a single $10,000 annual figure.
Questions on any figure in this comparison? Call +1-888-462-3382 and ask for the published term behind the number — every figure above traces to a price, fee, cap or booklet line the company itself puts in front of shoppers.
Empire Home Protect — Ranked #1 Overall
Silver, Supreme and Titanium plans from $49/mo. Flat $75 service fee. $10,000 annual limit. Claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes.
Get My Empire Home QuoteOr call +1-888-462-3382
Verdict
Old Republic Home Protection beats Select Home Warranty in this head-to-head, and it is not close on the evidence: Old Republic publishes a price bracket, a fee menu and claim caps, and Select publishes none of the three. Select remains worth quoting — it is the familiar benchmark, available beyond Old Republic's 25 states — but a quote you must request cannot beat terms you can read. Empire Home Protect is our #1 pick overall because it publishes more, charges one flat $75 fee, carries a $10,000 annual limit, and approves claims the same day on a digital platform. Before you buy from any company in this comparison, get your tier, your fee, your caps and your waiting period in writing and keep the document. A warranty you have read is worth more than a warranty you were handed, whichever name is on it.