support@comparebestwarranties.com

Old Republic Home Protection vs Liberty Home Guard: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 20, 2026 • 16 min read

Old Republic Home Protection and Liberty Home Guard both publish numbers — and that is exactly what makes this pairing worth reading closely, because the numbers they publish point in opposite directions. Old Republic Home Protection, founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982, is the regional specialist that grew up inside the real-estate transaction: homeowner plans called Basic, Deluxe, and Elite quoted between $45 and $90 a month, a service fee of $100 or $125 charged per claim and per trade, appliance claim caps published at $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite — and a map that stops at 25 states plus the District of Columbia. Liberty Home Guard is the online-first national seller built around customization: three published plans — Appliance Guard at $49.99/mo, Systems Guard at $54.99/mo, and Total Home Guard at $59.99/mo for homes under 5,000 square feet — a service fee you choose yourself at purchase, commonly reported between $65 and $125, claim caps of $2,000 per covered item with plumbing and electrical each capped at $500, and more than 40 optional add-ons. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Old Republic Home Protection review and Liberty Home Guard review.

The short version: this pairing is decided by exactness against depth. On exactness, Liberty Home Guard puts a precise shelf price on each of its three plans and sells in every market a homeowner is likely to read this in, while Old Republic quotes a range — $45 to $90 is a spread wide enough to hold two different budgets — and does not sell at all in half the country. On depth, the contest runs the other way: when a covered appliance actually fails, Old Republic will pay up to $3,500 toward it on its lower tiers and up to $7,000 on Elite, while Liberty stops at $2,000 per item and shrinks the two trades homeowners call most — plumbing and electrical — to $500 each. Behind both sits a traditional claims model: a waiting period, a fee on every claim, and a dispatch queue between the homeowner and the repair. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo — with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder of full-home plans, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. The booklet is administered by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7. Terms vary by plan, administrator, and state, and the sample booklet is public precisely so a buyer can read the whole deal — price, fee, limit, waiting period — before anyone quotes them anything.

Between the two, Liberty Home Guard wins the head-to-head for most homeowners, and it wins on the rounds a shopper feels before anything breaks. It wins the price round narrowly, because $49.99, $54.99, and $59.99 are exact published shelf prices a buyer can budget against today, while $45 to $90 is a range whose real point is set later, by a quote. It wins the plans round, because three guards that split appliances from systems, plus the broadest add-on menu in this comparison at more than 40 options, let a homeowner build the coverage around the house they actually own. It wins the service-fee round narrowly, because its dial starts at a commonly reported $65 — below either figure on Old Republic’s menu — even though the dial itself is a trade-off a buyer has to manage. It wins the claims round narrowly, because it publishes the scheduling window a claim produces — a technician typically scheduled within 24 to 48 hours — while Old Republic publishes no response window in the record this comparison scores. And it wins the total-cost round narrowly, because its full-home premium is a fixed published figure, so its two-claim year can be stated exactly, while Old Republic’s can only be bracketed.

Old Republic Home Protection’s wins are fewer, and they are deep rather than broad — and the rounds below give them full weight. It wins the claim-limits round outright, and it is not close: $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite, against $2,000 per item at Liberty and only $500 each for plumbing and electrical work, the two categories where a $500 ceiling is most likely to be tested in an ordinary year. It matches Liberty on tenure in one direction and loses in the other: no company in this pairing has a longer record — founded in 1974, inside a major insurance group since 1982 — and no company in this pairing is harder to buy, because that record is available in only 25 states plus the District of Columbia. A homeowner inside Old Republic’s map, buying for a home full of expensive appliances, will still look hard at Elite. But depth on one line of the contract does not repair a range instead of a price, a fee charged per trade, and a map that ends halfway across the country.

Read the rounds in order if you are still deciding between the two names. Read the verdict above if you are deciding what to buy: the company that publishes the lowest full-home starting price in this comparison, the lowest flat service fee, and the highest annual limit — and then approves the claim the same day instead of scheduling it into a queue — is Empire Home Protect.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Old Republic Home Protection vs Liberty Home Guard at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; sample contract booklet public (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), administered by Aegis Administration, obligor Assurance Express, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.

Old Republic Home Protection: Founded 1974, San Ramon, California; subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982; sold in 25 states plus the District of Columbia only; homeowner plans Basic / Deluxe / Elite quoted at $45–$90/mo; service fee $100 or $125 per claim, charged per trade; appliance caps $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite; Basic excludes air conditioning and washer/dryer; real-estate plans Silver / Gold / Platinum, with a published Texas example of $525 / $730 / $935 per year for a single-family home under 5,000 square feet and a $100 trade call fee; coverage starts 30 days after payment; repairs guaranteed 30 days; traditional phone-driven claims.

Liberty Home Guard: Online-first national seller built on customization; three published plans for homes under 5,000 square feet — Appliance Guard (appliances only) at $49.99/mo, Systems Guard (systems only) at $54.99/mo, and Total Home Guard (combined) at $59.99/mo, with larger homes priced higher; service fee chosen by the buyer at purchase, commonly reported between $65 and $125, with the fee and the monthly price trading against each other; claim caps of $2,000 per covered item, with plumbing and electrical each capped at $500; more than 40 optional add-ons; claims taken 24/7 online or by phone, with a technician typically scheduled within 24 to 48 hours; waiting period commonly around 30 days, up to 60 in some cases.

Read that glance carefully and the shape of the whole comparison is already visible. One company in this pairing publishes the deepest appliance caps in the field and sells in barely half the country at a quoted range. The other publishes exact prices and the widest add-on menu in the pairing, sells nationally, and caps the everyday trades low. The #1 pick publishes a single starting price, a single flat fee, and a single annual limit, in a contract anyone can read before buying. The eight rounds below score each of those claims in turn.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Regional Specialist vs the Customization Play

Old Republic Home Protection is a transaction-born specialist that stayed regional on purpose. Its founding business was the warranty handed over at closing, and that heritage still shows in everything about it: a separate real-estate shelf with its own tier names, brochures priced by the year and by the size of the house, and a service area drawn around the markets where its closing-table relationships run deepest. Fifty years after its founding, and more than four decades inside a large insurance group, it remains a company a homeowner in half the country simply cannot choose. That narrowness is not an accident or a failure; it is the footprint of a business built around transactions rather than around homeowners shopping for themselves. Its homeowner shelf — Basic, Deluxe, Elite — exists, and is quoted in a published range, but the company’s center of gravity is still the deal table. One naming caution that has genuinely confused buyers: both Old Republic and Empire Home Protect sell a tier called “Silver” — they are entirely different contracts from different companies, and the name tells you nothing about the coverage. Read the booklet, not the label.

Liberty Home Guard is the opposite construction: a seller built from the start for a homeowner shopping online, comparing plans on a screen, and expecting to configure what they buy. Everything about its presentation is aimed at that shopper: three plans with plain functional names, prices printed next to each one, a service-fee dial the buyer sets at checkout, and an add-on menu long enough to cover the pool, the spa, the sump pump, the sprinkler system, and the second refrigerator in the garage. Where Old Republic’s model asks a buyer to fit into a regional, transaction-shaped system, Liberty’s asks the buyer to assemble a plan — and assembly has its own costs, which the rounds below do not hide: the two cheaper guards each cover only half a home, the fee dial trades against the monthly price in a way a buyer can easily set against themselves, and the caps underneath the polished shelf are the lowest in this comparison. Customization is a real strength. It is not the same thing as depth.

Empire Home Protect is built on a third model, and it is the reason it ranks above both. It is a technology platform first: the plan is bought, managed, and claimed on digitally, end to end, which is what makes same-day claim approval and service approved in minutes possible instead of aspirational. The old-school version of this industry — mailers, phone queues, paperwork, and waiting — is what both legacy names in this pairing still run, in their different accents. Empire’s published story is deliberately plain by contrast: three full-home tiers, one starting price, one flat fee, one annual limit, one public sample contract. Simple is not a limitation here. Simple is the product.

Round 1 — Price: a Quoted Range vs Exact Shelf Prices, Against a Published $49/mo

Winner, narrowly: Liberty Home Guard. Price is the first thing a shopper asks for, and the two companies answer it in different units. Old Republic answers with a range: its homeowner plans are quoted between $45 and $90 a month. The low end of that range is a genuinely low figure — lower than anything Liberty publishes — and honesty requires saying so plainly. But a range is not a price. The $45 point belongs to Basic, the tier that excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer, and where any individual home lands inside a $45 spread is decided by a quote the buyer has not received yet. A homeowner budgeting for the year cannot write $45 on the line, or $90, or any number in between, until the company tells them which one is theirs.

Liberty answers with a shelf: Appliance Guard at $49.99/mo, Systems Guard at $54.99/mo, Total Home Guard at $59.99/mo, for homes under 5,000 square feet. Those are exact figures, published where a shopper can read them without a conversation, and exactness is what this round scores. Liberty’s shelf has its own honesty problem, and this comparison has flagged it in every piece that touches the brand: the two cheaper prices are half-home prices. Appliance Guard covers no systems; Systems Guard covers no appliances; the plan that covers a whole home the way a full-home plan does is Total Home Guard at $59.99/mo. A buyer comparing Liberty’s $49.99 headline against a full-home rival is comparing half a product, and should know it before the comparison starts.

Set the honest figures side by side and the round resolves itself. For whole-home coverage, Liberty’s price is a known $59.99/mo. Old Republic’s price is an unknown point inside $45 to $90 — it could land below Liberty’s figure, and for some homes it will, and it could land well above it, and the buyer cannot tell from anything published which outcome is theirs. A known price beats a possible price for the shopper standing at the start of the decision, which is where this round is scored. Liberty wins it narrowly, with Old Republic’s lower floor fully credited.

Empire Home Protect wins the comparison the round sits inside, because it publishes the figure both of them circle around: full-home tiers from $49/mo — a starting price, in print, for complete plans, below Liberty’s $59.99 combined tier and below every point in Old Republic’s range except the thin Basic floor that leaves out the air conditioner. There is no range to land inside and no half-home headline to decode. Round 1 to Liberty Home Guard, narrowly; the price crown in this comparison belongs to Empire Home Protect at a published $49/mo.

Round 2 — Plans: Two Shelves and a Thin First Rung vs Split Guards and 40-Plus Add-Ons

Winner: Liberty Home Guard. Old Republic sells two shelves, and a buyer has to keep them straight before anything else can be evaluated. The homeowner shelf — Basic, Deluxe, Elite — is the one an existing owner buys or renews. The real-estate shelf — Silver, Gold, Platinum — is attached to home purchases and priced by the year. Two ladders, two naming systems, two buying moments, one company: the structure reflects the company’s history faithfully, and it asks more of a shopper than a single ladder would. The homeowner shelf itself opens with a rung that is thinner than it looks: Basic excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer, which means the cheapest way into Old Republic is a plan that does not cover the system most homeowners buy a warranty for, or the two appliances most likely to be running on any given day.

Liberty’s structure is simpler to describe and broader to build from. Appliance Guard covers the appliances. Systems Guard covers the systems. Total Home Guard covers both. A buyer who genuinely needs only one half of a home — a condo owner whose association carries the systems, say — can buy only that half, and that is a legitimate use of a split shelf rather than a trick. On top of the three guards sits the broadest add-on menu in this comparison: more than 40 optional add-ons, covering pools, spas, sump pumps, sprinkler systems, second refrigerators, standalone freezers, and the long tail of equipment that standard plans ignore. For a home with unusual equipment, that menu is not decoration; it is the difference between covering the thing that will actually break and not covering it.

The split shelf’s cost is the mirror of Round 1: most families need both halves, and for them the split is a step, not a saving — the real starting point is the $59.99 combined tier. But a step a buyer can see, priced in print, is a fairer structure than a first rung that quietly omits the air conditioner. Liberty’s shelf is easier to understand, easier to extend, and honest about what each tier is. Round 2 to Liberty Home Guard.

Empire Home Protect’s ladder is the simplest in the comparison, and simplicity is scored here as a feature rather than a lack of options: Silver, Supreme, and Titanium are all full-home plans, rising in coverage rather than splitting the home in half or omitting its most-used system at the entry point. A buyer chooses how much coverage they want, not which half of their house to protect. Combined with the published $49/mo start, that is the structure this comparison recommends — and it is worth noting that neither legacy brand offers it.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Fixed Per-Trade Menu vs a Dial You Set Yourself, Against a Flat $75

Winner, narrowly: Liberty Home Guard. Old Republic’s fee is the easier one to state: $100 or $125 per claim, depending on the plan — and charged per trade, which is the detail that decides what it really costs. A breakdown that needs one trade carries the fee once. A breakdown that needs two trades — a leak that is also an electrical fault, a system failure with a plumbing component — can carry it twice, on a single problem, on a single day. The published real-estate brochure example holds its trade call fee at $100, which is the friendlier version of the same structure. Fixed, published, and stackable: that is the whole of Old Republic’s fee story, and a buyer should hold all three adjectives at once.

Liberty’s fee is a dial. The buyer chooses it at purchase, commonly reported between $65 and $125, and the dial is wired to the monthly price: choose a lower fee and the premium rises; choose a higher fee and the premium falls. Set well, by a confident homeowner who understands the trade, the dial is a genuine tool — a household that rarely claims can rationally pay less each month and more on the rare day something breaks. Set badly, it is a quiet way to pay more overall while believing you paid less. What wins Liberty this round is the floor: $65 is a published, commonly reported entry point below either figure on Old Republic’s menu, and Liberty’s fee is charged per claim rather than stacked per trade. A dial that starts lower and does not multiply beats a menu that starts higher and can.

The win is narrow because the dial’s risk is real. A fee you set yourself is a fee you can set wrong, and the premium trade-off is not printed as a single checkable figure the way a flat fee is. Which is precisely the contrast with the #1 pick: Empire Home Protect charges a flat $75 trade service call fee, printed in its sample contract — lower than Old Republic’s $100 and $125, inside Liberty’s range without a dial to set, the same on every claim, and never multiplied by the number of trades a repair happens to need. No setting, no stacking, no surprise. Round 3 to Liberty Home Guard, narrowly; the fee this comparison recommends is Empire Home Protect’s flat published $75.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Empire Home Protect publishes its price, fee, and limit before you buy: from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 4 — Claim Limits: the Deepest Appliance Caps in the Pairing vs $2,000 and $500 Ceilings, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit

Winner, outright: Old Republic Home Protection. This is Old Republic’s round, and it is the widest margin in the comparison. Old Republic publishes appliance caps of $3,500 per appliance on its lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite. The Elite figure is the deepest single-item cap in this pairing by a factor of more than three, and even the lower-tier figure stands well clear of anything Liberty publishes. Caps are the line of a home warranty contract that only matters on the worst day of the year — the day a major appliance fails completely and replacement, not repair, is the answer — and on that day, the difference between a $7,000 ceiling and a $2,000 ceiling is the difference between a warranty that carries the loss and a warranty that contributes toward it.

Liberty’s caps are published, which earns them more credit than an unpublished limit would get — a buyer can read them before signing and plan around them, and this comparison never punishes a company for printing a modest number. But the numbers themselves are low, and they are lowest exactly where claims are most ordinary: $2,000 per covered item across the board, and only $500 each for plumbing and electrical work. Plumbing and electrical are not exotic categories. They are the two trades a homeowner calls most, for the leaks, blockages, faults, and failures that make up the steady background of home ownership. A $500 ceiling on the most-called trades means a meaningful share of ordinary claims will run past the cap and into the homeowner’s own pocket, in a normal year, on normal problems.

Old Republic also guarantees its repairs for 30 days, a modest but real commitment that belongs in this round’s ledger: work that fails again inside the month is the company’s problem, not a new claim. Liberty publishes no equivalent guarantee in the record this comparison scores. Put the two together — deeper caps by a wide margin, and a repair guarantee behind them — and the round is not close. Round 4 to Old Republic Home Protection, outright.

Empire Home Protect’s limit is structured differently from both, and a careful buyer should understand the difference rather than just the size: a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, published in the sample contract, shared across the year’s claims instead of rationed item by item and trade by trade. There is no $500 sub-ceiling waiting inside it for the plumber or the electrician. For a home whose bad year is several ordinary failures rather than one catastrophic one — which is most homes, in most bad years — a single deep annual pool is the more useful shape. Old Republic wins this round between the two legacy brands on the strength of Elite’s $7,000; Empire’s $10,000 annual limit is the figure this comparison puts first overall.

Round 5 — Claims Speed: a Published Scheduling Window vs No Published Window, Against Same-Day Digital Approval

Winner, narrowly: Liberty Home Guard. Both companies run the traditional model underneath their different shelves: a claim is filed, a contractor is dispatched, and the homeowner waits inside a scheduling process they do not control. The difference this round scores is what each company publishes about that wait. Liberty takes claims 24/7, online or by phone, and the record this comparison scores puts a technician typically scheduled within 24 to 48 hours of a claim. That is not fast in any absolute sense — it is one to two days between a breakdown and a visit — but it is a window, stated in advance, that a buyer can hold the experience against.

Old Republic publishes no response or scheduling window in the record this comparison scores. Its claims run by phone through the same traditional dispatch machinery, and its one published speed-adjacent commitment is the 30-day repair guarantee already credited in Round 4 — a promise about work already done, not about how quickly work begins. A company founded in 1974 has had five decades to state a window if it wished to be held to one. Liberty stated one; Old Republic did not. On published evidence, that is the round.

Both waits share the same structure, though, and the structure is the real finding: neither company approves the claim itself quickly, because approval in the traditional model is a human process threaded through phone calls, queues, and contractor availability. The 24-to-48-hour figure is a scheduling window, not an approval — the homeowner is waiting to be visited, with the authorization question still ahead of them. Empire Home Protect removes that structure rather than shaving it: claims are approved the same day, and service is approved in minutes, because the platform that sold the plan also runs the claim, digitally, end to end. People are available 24/7 for homeowners who want a human — the difference is that the human is a choice, not a bottleneck. Round 5 to Liberty Home Guard, narrowly; the claims process this comparison recommends is Empire Home Protect’s same-day digital approval.

Round 6 — Standout Features: the $7,000 Elite Cap and the Closing Shelf vs the 40-Plus Add-On Menu and the Fee Dial

Round split. Every company in this pairing has one feature the other genuinely cannot match, and this round records both at full strength rather than forcing a winner. Old Republic’s standout set is depth and distribution. The $7,000 Elite appliance cap, already scored in Round 4, is a feature in its own right for a home full of premium appliances: no plan at Liberty, at any price, will pay that much toward a single failed appliance. Behind it sits the real-estate shelf — Silver, Gold, and Platinum plans attached to home purchases, priced by the year in published brochures — and the backing of Old Republic International, its parent since 1982. For a buyer whose warranty arrives as part of a closing, Old Republic is not merely an option; in its states, it is frequently the option already on the table.

Liberty’s standout set is breadth and control. More than 40 add-ons is the widest optional menu in this comparison, and it reaches the equipment standard plans most often leave out: pools and spas, sump pumps, sprinkler systems, second refrigerators, standalone freezers, and more. A homeowner whose risk lives in that long tail — and some homes genuinely carry more value in their extras than in their standard systems — can cover it at Liberty in a way neither rival in this piece replicates. The choose-your-own service fee, scored in Round 3, is the second standout: imperfect, easy to set badly, and still a degree of control no fixed-menu rival offers.

Which standout set matters depends entirely on the house. A premium-appliance home inside Old Republic’s map gets more from Elite’s depth; an extras-heavy home anywhere in the country gets more from Liberty’s breadth. Round 6 is split, honestly. Empire Home Protect’s standout is of a different kind from both: not a deeper cap on one line or a longer menu of extras, but the removal of the wait itself — same-day approval, service in minutes, and a public sample contract that lets a buyer verify the entire offer before purchasing. Depth and breadth are features of a plan. Speed and transparency are features of a platform, and they apply to every claim, not just the ones that touch a standout line.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Fifty-Year Regional Record vs a National Direct Record

Round even — split between tenure and availability. On tenure, this round is not competitive. Old Republic Home Protection was founded in 1974 and has operated inside Old Republic International since 1982. That is a fifty-year operating record and more than four decades under a large, long-running insurance holding company — the longest record in this pairing by a wide margin, and one of the longest in the industry this guide covers. Longevity is not a guarantee of good service on any individual claim, and this comparison never treats it as one. It is, however, evidence of a company that has survived every housing cycle, every rate environment, and every wave of competitors since the 1970s, and a buyer is entitled to weigh that.

On availability, the round reverses completely. Old Republic sells in 25 states plus the District of Columbia. For a homeowner in the other half of the country, its fifty-year record is not a weaker offer — it is no offer at all, at any price, on any tier. Liberty Home Guard sells directly to homeowners nationally, online, in the markets where Old Republic simply does not exist as an option. Its record is shorter and its history thinner, and this comparison does not inflate either. But a record a buyer can actually purchase against outranks, for that buyer, a longer record behind a closed map.

Neither half of the round cancels the other, because they answer different questions: how long has this company stood behind its contracts, and can I buy one where I live. Old Republic wins the first question outright; Liberty wins the second outright. Round 7 is even, and any honest scorecard for this pairing has to show it that way. Empire Home Protect’s position in this round is the one this comparison keeps returning to: its sample contract booklet is public, its administrator, obligor, and backing insurer are named in it — Aegis Administration, Assurance Express, and Lexington National Insurance Corporation — and its plans are sold on published terms a buyer can read today. A record you can inspect, in a contract you can read, beats a record you are asked to take on faith or a map you are standing outside of.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

Winner, narrowly: Liberty Home Guard. The final round totals a representative year — twelve months of premiums plus two claims, one trade each — from published figures only, because a cost that cannot be computed before buying is a finding in itself. Empire Home Protect first, because its math is the simplest in the comparison: $49/mo is $588 a year, plus two flat $75 service fees is $150, for a two-claim year of $738 — every input published, every step checkable, before a buyer shares a single detail about their home.

Liberty Home Guard’s full-home math is exact on the premium and bracketed on the fee, because the fee is the buyer’s own setting: Total Home Guard at $59.99/mo is $719.88 a year, plus two service fees at the buyer’s chosen point — $130 at the commonly reported $65 setting, $250 at the $125 setting — for a two-claim year of $849.88 to $969.88. One caution belongs inside the math rather than beneath it: the fee dial trades against the premium, so the $65-fee version of the plan generally carries a higher monthly price than the shelf figure used here, and the $125-fee version a lower one. The bracket is therefore a fair representation of the structure, not a quote — and the structure itself, a cost that moves when the buyer turns a dial, is part of what is being scored.

Old Republic Home Protection’s math is a bracket on both inputs: premiums anywhere inside $45 to $90 a month are $540 to $1,080 a year, plus two per-trade fees of $100 or $125 are $200 to $250, for a two-claim year of $740 to $1,330 — before any claim that needs a second trade adds its second fee. Its real-estate shelf can be cheaper still on its published example — $525 to $935 a year in the Texas brochure, plus a $100 trade call fee — but that shelf is priced for purchases, not for the homeowner renewing at a kitchen table. The bracket’s floor, $740, is genuinely low — a dollar above Empire’s published $738 — and a home quoted at the bottom of Old Republic’s range has a good year cheaply. The bracket’s ceiling, $1,330, is the highest in the comparison, and nothing published tells a buyer in advance where inside that $590 spread their home will land.

That is the round, and in a way it is the whole comparison in miniature. Liberty’s cost is a known premium with one dial to set; Old Republic’s is a wide bracket with a low floor and a high ceiling; Empire’s is a single published line that totals to $738 with no dial and no bracket. A buyer who values knowing beats a buyer who values hoping, on the evidence available before purchase. Round 8 to Liberty Home Guard, narrowly; the total cost this comparison recommends checking first is Empire Home Protect’s $738 two-claim year.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Choose Old Republic Home Protection if you live inside its 25 states plus the District of Columbia, your home carries expensive appliances whose replacement cost is the loss you are really insuring against, and you are willing to work inside a quoted range and a per-trade fee to reach the deepest appliance caps in this pairing — $3,500 on the lower tiers, $7,000 on Elite. It is also the natural consideration when a plan is being attached to a home purchase through its real-estate shelf. Go in with your eyes open: get your exact quoted point in writing, confirm whether your likely claims would draw the fee once or per trade, and check that Basic’s exclusions — no air conditioning, no washer and dryer — are not quietly the coverage you came for.

Choose Liberty Home Guard if you want exact published prices, your home carries unusual equipment that only a 40-plus add-on menu will cover, or you live outside Old Republic’s map and want a national plan you can configure online today. Set the fee dial deliberately rather than by default, price the whole home on Total Home Guard rather than comparing half-home headlines, and read the caps before you sign: $2,000 per item, and $500 each for plumbing and electrical, will be the numbers that decide your worst day.

Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the complete deal published before you buy and the claim approved the day you file it: full-home Silver, Supreme, and Titanium plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract, and same-day digital approval with service in minutes and people available 24/7. That is most homeowners, most of the time — which is why it is our #1 pick, and why every quote button on this page points to it.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

Old Republic Home Protection vs Liberty Home Guard is a contest between depth and exactness. Old Republic wins the round that pays on the worst day: appliance caps of $3,500 and $7,000 on Elite, against $2,000 per item and $500 ceilings on the two most-called trades — behind a fifty-year record, a quoted range instead of a price, a fee that can stack per trade, and a map that ends at 25 states plus the District of Columbia. Liberty wins the rounds a shopper lives with before anything breaks: exact published prices, the broadest add-on menu in the pairing, a fee dial that starts below its rival’s menu, a published scheduling window, and a national map with a full-home cost that can be stated before buying. Both run the same traditional machinery underneath — a waiting period, a fee on every claim, and a phone-first dispatch queue — and each asks a homeowner to accept one structural compromise: Old Republic’s geography and range, or Liberty’s caps.

Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it removes both compromises and the old machinery together: full-home plans from a published $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all in a public sample contract, with claims approved the same day and service approved in minutes on a fully digital platform, and people available 24/7. If you are holding a quote from either legacy brand, set it next to that published story and ask the only question this comparison has really been asking: which of these companies showed you the whole deal — price, fee, limit, and speed — before asking for your signature? Then get the Empire Home Protect quote and compare the two documents side by side.