support@comparebestwarranties.com

Old Republic Home Protection vs First American Home Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 20, 2026 • 16 min read

Old Republic Home Protection and First American Home Warranty are the two names a homeowner is most likely to meet through a real-estate transaction rather than a search — but they publish their deals in completely opposite ways, and that difference decides this comparison before any other round is scored. Old Republic Home Protection, founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982, is the regional specialist that grew up inside the closing process and still prints its numbers: homeowner plans called Basic, Deluxe, and Elite quoted between $45 and $90 a month, a service fee of $100 or $125 charged per claim and per trade, appliance claim caps published at $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite — and a map that stops at 25 states plus the District of Columbia. First American Home Warranty is the closing-table name itself: the warranty buyers most often meet because it was included, offered, or handed over in the deal for the house — sold in basic and premier tiers, and priced entirely by quote, so its starting price, its service fee, and its claim limits all live inside the paperwork the transaction produces, and none of the three is published in advance. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Old Republic Home Protection review and First American Home Warranty review.

The short version: this pairing turns on one question — how much of the deal can you read before someone hands it to you? Old Republic publishes a quoted price range, a two-figure fee menu, and the deepest appliance caps in this comparison, so a shopper inside its 25-state map can do real arithmetic on Old Republic before speaking to anyone — and reading those numbers closely is how you find their limits: the range is wide enough to hold two different budgets, the fee is charged per trade so a two-trade claim can carry it twice, and the entry tier excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer outright. First American publishes none of the three numbers: no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps — all of them wait inside its quote and its contract. What First American offers instead is position: it is the name already sitting in the home at closing, the default coverage in a great many transactions, and that incumbency is a genuine strength this comparison credits in full, including the round it wins outright. Neither company, though, changes the model behind the paperwork: both run a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a dispatch cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder of full-home plans, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. The booklet is administered by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7. Terms vary by plan, administrator, and state, and the sample booklet is public precisely so a buyer can read the whole deal — price, fee, limit, waiting period — before anyone quotes them anything.

Between the two, Old Republic Home Protection wins the head-to-head for a homeowner choosing a plan for themselves, and it wins on evidence: it is the only one of the two that gives a shopper anything to compare before the paperwork arrives. It wins the price round, because a quoted range of $45 to $90 a month is a real, checkable bracket a buyer can budget against, while First American publishes no starting price at all. It wins the plans round, because three homeowner tiers — Basic, Deluxe, and Elite — plus a separate real-estate shelf give a buyer more rungs to stand on than First American’s basic and premier pair, even with the entry tier’s exclusions counted against it. It wins the service-fee round, because $100 or $125 per trade is a published menu a buyer can price into a claim before buying, while First American’s fee exists only inside its contract. It wins the claim-limits round outright, and it is not close: $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite, published, against claim limits First American does not publish at all. And it wins the total-cost round, because its two-claim year can be bracketed from public figures — $740 to $1,330 — while First American’s cannot be computed at any width until a quote exists.

First American Home Warranty’s win is real, and the rounds below give it full weight. It wins the standout round on the strength of the closing table itself: no company in this pairing is more deeply built into the moment a house changes hands, and for the large share of holders who received their plan with the house, that distribution is the product — coverage that was simply there, from day one of ownership, with no shopping project in front of it. That is a genuine convenience, and this comparison does not pretend otherwise. But convenience at closing is not the same as value over the years you hold the plan. A homeowner who is choosing — at renewal, after a move First American did not ride in on, or in one of the states where the choice is actually theirs to make — can verify Old Republic’s price bracket, fee menu, and caps from the public record, and can verify none of First American’s three deciding numbers at all. A comparison site exists to compare, and only one of these two companies shows up to be compared.

Read the rounds in order if you are still deciding between the two names. Read the verdict above if you are deciding what to buy: the company that publishes a full-home starting price below Old Republic’s range midpoint, a flat service fee below either figure on Old Republic’s menu, and a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract — and then approves the claim the same day instead of routing it through a phone queue — is Empire Home Protect.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Old Republic Home Protection vs First American Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; sample contract booklet public (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), administered by Aegis Administration, obligor Assurance Express, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.

Old Republic Home Protection: Founded 1974, San Ramon, California; subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982; sold in 25 states plus the District of Columbia only; homeowner plans Basic / Deluxe / Elite quoted at $45–$90/mo; service fee $100 or $125 per claim, charged per trade; appliance caps $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite; Basic excludes air conditioning and washer/dryer; real-estate plans Silver / Gold / Platinum, with a published Texas example of $525 / $730 / $935 per year for a single-family home under 5,000 square feet and a $100 trade call fee; coverage starts 30 days after payment; repairs guaranteed 30 days; traditional phone-driven claims.

First American Home Warranty: Basic and premier (combined) tiers; no published starting price — every plan priced by quote, varying by home, state, and the deal it arrived in; service fee and claim limits set inside the quote and contract, with no published figures; traditional phone-driven claims and dispatch; the real-estate channel name — included, offered, or handed over at closing in a great many transactions, so it is the default coverage in a great many homes.

Read that glance carefully, because it contains the whole story of this pairing. One company on this page prints a price range, a fee menu, and its claim caps, and sells them in only half the country. One company prints none of its three deciding numbers, and arrives instead inside the transaction for the house itself. And one company prints a full-home price, a single flat fee, and one annual limit, in a sample contract anyone can read before buying, and sells directly to the homeowner doing the choosing. Everything below is the working-out of those differences, round by round.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Regional Specialist That Prints Its Numbers vs the Name That Comes With the House

Old Republic Home Protection is best understood as a real-estate institution that learned to show its work. Founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and part of Old Republic International since 1982, it built its business the way the industry was built for decades: through the transaction, with plans placed by the people selling and buying houses. Its real-estate shelf — Silver, Gold, and Platinum — still reflects that origin, down to the published Texas brochure example that prices a single-family home under 5,000 square feet at $525, $730, and $935 a year with a $100 trade call fee. But unlike the other closing-table name in this pairing, Old Republic also maintains a homeowner shelf it will describe in public: Basic, Deluxe, and Elite, quoted between $45 and $90 a month, with the fee menu and the appliance caps printed where a shopper can find them. The discipline is real, and so are its boundaries. The company sells in 25 states plus the District of Columbia and nowhere else, its entry tier leaves air conditioning and the washer and dryer uncovered, and its fee is charged per trade, so the shape of a breakdown decides what a claim costs. Old Republic is the legacy model with its numbers showing — which is exactly why it can be beaten on those numbers, and exactly why it beats a competitor that shows none.

First American Home Warranty is best understood as the transaction’s default. Its natural habitat is the real-estate deal itself: a seller includes a plan to make a listing easier to sell, a buyer’s agent adds one to smooth a negotiation, or the coverage is simply part of the package that changes hands at closing. That channel is a real competitive moat. A homeowner who has never shopped for a home warranty at all may still hold a First American plan, and the brand’s two-tier shelf — a basic tier and a premier tier above it — is built to be handed over that way: simple enough to explain across a closing table, broad enough to be the plan nobody had to choose. The cost of that model is that the choosing never really happens. The price is set by quote and varies by home and state, the service fee and the claim limits live in the contract, and the household typically meets all three numbers after the coverage is already theirs. First American’s strength is that it is already there. Its weakness is that being already there is most of what it offers a shopper who wants to compare before they commit.

Empire Home Protect is built the other way from both. It is a technology platform first: three full-home tiers — Silver, Supreme, and Titanium — published from $49/mo, sold directly to the homeowner who is doing the choosing, with the fee, the annual limit, and the waiting period printed in a public sample contract before anyone asks for a quote. Where Old Republic is the closing-table plan that publishes its bracket and First American is the closing-table plan that publishes nothing, Empire is the plan a shopper verifies: the numbers are public, the claims process is digital, and approval comes the same day instead of after a phone queue. That difference — chosen and checkable versus inherited, whether the inherited paperwork is printed or sealed — is the thread that runs through every round below.

Round 1 — Price: a Published Quoted Range vs No Published Price at All, Against a Published $49/mo

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection. Price is the round shoppers want decided first, and in this pairing it can actually be half-decided, which already separates the two legacy brands. Old Republic quotes its homeowner plans between $45 and $90 a month. A range is not a price — $45 to $90 is a spread wide enough to hold two different budgets, and where a given home lands inside it is set by a quote, not by the brochure. But a range is not nothing, either. It tells a shopper the floor, the ceiling, and the shape of the negotiation before it starts: no Old Republic homeowner plan in this record costs less than $45 a month or more than $90, and a quote that arrives outside that bracket can be questioned on the spot. First American offers no bracket to question a quote against. Its basic and premier tiers are priced entirely by quote, varying by home, state, and tier, and in its case the quote is frequently not even addressed to the holder, because it was generated inside a transaction the holder did not run. A First American holder who wants to know whether their price was a good one has exactly one way to find out: collect other quotes and compare backwards, after the fact.

The published range also disciplines the rest of Old Republic’s own story. Its real-estate brochure example — $525, $730, and $935 a year for a Texas single-family home under 5,000 square feet — annualizes to roughly $44 to $78 a month, sitting inside the homeowner range and corroborating it from a second document. Two public documents that agree with each other are the closest thing this pairing has to a verified price, and First American has no equivalent pair, because it has no first document. Against both, Empire Home Protect publishes a single starting figure for full-home coverage: from $49/mo, printed, checkable in seconds, and positioned deliberately — above Old Republic’s $45 floor, which buys an entry tier with no air conditioning and no washer or dryer, and below the $90 ceiling a Deluxe or Elite quote can reach. A published point beats a published range for budgeting, and a published range beats a sealed quote. That is the whole round, in that order.

Round 2 — Plans: Three Homeowner Tiers and a Closing Shelf vs Two Tiers Built to Be Handed Over

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection. Old Republic maintains two shelves, and the homeowner shelf has three rungs: Basic at the bottom, Deluxe in the middle, and Elite at the top, with the appliance cap stepping up to $7,000 on Elite. Alongside it sits the real-estate shelf — Silver, Gold, and Platinum — for plans placed through a transaction. A buyer can therefore enter Old Republic’s coverage at several depths and climb between them, and the published Texas example prices each real-estate rung separately, so the ladder’s steps have numbers on them. The honest deduction comes at the bottom rung: Basic excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer, which are not obscure items — in much of Old Republic’s own map, air conditioning is the single most consequential system in the house, and a tier that omits it is a partial plan wearing a full plan’s name. First American’s shelf is simpler: a basic tier covering the core of the home, and a premier tier that broadens into the fuller combined shelf. Two rungs, both aimed at whole-home protection, neither published with a price. Simplicity at a closing table is a feature — a plan an agent can explain in one sentence gets included in more deals — but for a homeowner choosing deliberately, two unpriced rungs offer less to choose between than three priced ones, and no way to size the plan to the home from the public record.

Empire Home Protect’s ladder is the standard both are measured against: Silver for core systems, Supreme for the full home, and Titanium at the top, three full-home tiers published from a single $49/mo starting point, with the sample booklet naming what each tier covers before a quote is requested. No rung in that ladder is a systems-only or appliances-only partial, and no rung quietly omits the air conditioning. Between the two legacy brands, Old Republic wins this round on rung count and on the priced real-estate ladder behind it — with the Basic exclusion recorded as the deduction it is, not waved past.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Published Per-Trade Menu vs a Fee That Lives in the Contract, Against a Flat $75

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection. The service fee is the price of a bad day, and it is the number a homeowner pays most often. Old Republic publishes its menu: $100 or $125 per claim, depending on the plan — and then adds the clause that decides this round’s second half, charged per trade. A claim that needs one trade costs one fee. A claim that needs two trades — the electrician and then the appliance technician, the plumber and then the HVAC contractor — can carry the fee twice, at $200 or $250 for a single breakdown event. The menu is honest and the multiplication is printed, which earns Old Republic full credit for disclosure and full responsibility for the arithmetic. Its own real-estate brochure holds the line at a flat $100 trade call fee in the Texas example, which shows the company knows how to publish a simpler fee when the channel asks for one. First American publishes no fee at all. The service fee on a First American plan is set inside the quote and the contract, so a holder learns what a claim costs at the moment they are already holding the plan — and a shopper comparing in advance cannot include First American’s fee in any honest total, because there is no figure to include.

Against a published-but-multiplying menu and an unpublished fee, Empire Home Protect publishes the simplest structure in the comparison: a flat $75 trade service call fee, the same on every claim, printed in the sample booklet, and never multiplied per trade. Seventy-five dollars is below either figure on Old Republic’s menu before multiplication, and it is knowable in a way First American’s fee is not at any amount. Between the two legacy brands, Old Republic wins the round because a buyer can price its worst case in advance — $125, or $250 if two trades are called — while First American’s worst case is a discovery. Disclosure wins the round; the per-trade clause is why it does not win it by more.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: Published $3,500 and $7,000 Appliance Caps vs Limits That Are Not Published, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit

Winner: Empire Home Protect on the annual aggregate a household can plan around. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection, outright. Claim limits are where a home warranty either is or is not worth its premiums, and this is the round where the pairing’s central difference becomes impossible to soften. Old Republic publishes its appliance caps: $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite. The Elite figure is the deepest single-item appliance cap in this comparison, and it matters in the exact scenario a warranty exists for — the premium refrigerator, the high-end range, the appliance whose replacement cost is the reason the plan was bought. A $7,000 ceiling means that claim is a repair-or-replace decision; a low or unknown ceiling means it is a negotiation. First American does not publish its claim limits. Whatever caps sit inside a First American contract may be generous or tight, and this comparison does not guess — what it records is that a shopper cannot read them before buying, and a holder typically reads them for the first time in the paperwork that arrived with the house. An unpublished cap cannot win a round about caps, because the round is scored on what a buyer can verify, and there is nothing here to verify.

Empire Home Protect publishes its limit in the form a household budget actually uses: a $10,000 annual aggregate, printed in the sample booklet, applying across the year’s claims rather than resetting the argument appliance by appliance. A family can hold that number next to a year of premiums and fees and know the maximum the plan can return. Old Republic’s per-appliance depth and Empire’s annual aggregate are different shapes of protection, and the verdict scores both honestly: Old Republic wins the single-item depth contest against everyone on this page except on the aggregate a household plans around, where Empire’s published $10,000 stands alone — because First American publishes neither shape. Between the two legacy brands this round is not narrow, and it is not split. Published caps beat unpublished caps, every time, by the whole margin.

Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Phone-Driven Processes, No Published Window on Either Side, Against Same-Day Digital Approval

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: an honest tie. This is the round where the two legacy brands stand in exactly the same place, and the comparison says so plainly. Both run a traditional, phone-driven claims process: the homeowner calls, the claim joins a queue, a dispatch cycle assigns a contractor, and the paperwork moves at the speed of that cycle. Neither company publishes a response or scheduling window in the record this comparison scores — no hour count a holder can hold them to, no approval standard printed next to the price. Old Republic adds one published service commitment worth naming: its repairs are guaranteed for 30 days, so a repair that fails again inside that window comes back without a fresh argument. That guarantee is a real, checkable term, and it is credited here — but it governs the repair after the claim, not the speed of the claim itself, and it does not break the tie on the question this round asks. First American’s claims experience is shaped by its channel in one more way: because so many of its holders never chose the plan, the first claim is often also the first real contact with the company, which makes the phone queue the introduction as well as the process.

Empire Home Protect is built to make this round uncompetitive. Claims run on a fully digital platform, are approved the same day, and service is approved in minutes — not scheduled into a window, not queued behind a paperwork cycle. Claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, people are available 24/7, and the standard is published where a buyer can read it before purchase rather than discovered on the worst day of the year. The technology gap in this industry is not a slogan; it is the difference between a claim that is approved while the homeowner is still standing in front of the broken appliance and a claim that is pending. Both legacy brands in this pairing sit on the pending side of that line, together, and the round is scored that way.

Round 6 — Standout Features: the $7,000 Elite Cap and the Printed Brochure vs the Closing Table Itself

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: First American Home Warranty. Every pairing has a round where the trailing brand’s real strength belongs, and this is First American’s. Its standout feature is not a clause; it is a location. First American sits inside the real-estate transaction at a scale few competitors match, which means its coverage starts for a great many households at the exact moment of maximum exposure — the first months in an unfamiliar house, with unfamiliar systems, when a seller-included or agent-placed plan is quietly doing the job nobody remembered to shop for. There is no enrollment friction, no comparison project, no gap between moving in and being covered. For a buyer whose plan arrived that way and whose first claim was handled, the brand’s familiarity is earned, and this comparison credits it as the strongest single feature on First American’s side of the page. Old Republic’s standouts are contractual rather than positional: the $7,000 Elite appliance cap, the deepest in the pairing; a published real-estate brochure that prices its closing shelf in the open, at $525, $730, and $935 a year in the Texas example; and a 30-day guarantee on its repairs. Those are strong features, and two of them already won their own rounds above.

Why, then, does First American take this round? Because standout means the thing the other company cannot simply match, and Old Republic’s caps and brochure, however good, are terms a competitor can print tomorrow — while First American’s seat at the closing table is a distribution position built over decades of transactions, not a line in a contract. Empire Home Protect’s standout answers position with a different kind of advantage: a fully digital platform where the claim is approved the same day and service is approved in minutes, sold directly to the homeowner, with the price, fee, and limit published before the quote. A closing-table default protects the homeowner who never chose; a digital platform serves the homeowner who did. For the reader of a comparison page — by definition, a person choosing — the second advantage is the one that applies, which is why the round First American wins here does not move the verdict.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Fifty-Year Printed Record in Half the Country vs the Default Record of the Closing Table

Winner: Empire Home Protect on the record a buyer can check today. Between the two: split. Tenure first. Old Republic was founded in 1974 and has sat inside Old Republic International, a major insurance group, since 1982 — a half-century record with a parent company behind it, and the longest documented tenure in this pairing on the record this comparison scores. That record, however, is available to only part of the country: 25 states plus the District of Columbia. A homeowner outside that map cannot buy Old Republic’s tenure at any price, which caps what the record is worth as a shopping fact. First American’s public record is written by a different author. Because its plans are so often placed by sellers and agents, a large share of its holder experience begins without a choice having been made — which cuts both ways in the record: the convenience reviews are real, and so are the renewal-time surprises of holders meeting their fee and caps for the first time, in paperwork they never shopped for. Neither brand gets a rating or a review count printed in this comparison, because we publish only figures from our own verified comparison set and we do not invent numbers for anyone — read current public listings on two platforms yourself before you buy, from anyone.

The split, then, is this: Old Republic wins the documented-tenure half of the round, on a 1974 founding and four decades inside a major insurance group, with its numbers published consistently enough to check that record against them. First American wins the availability-and-familiarity half, as the name already present in homes across the transactions its channel touches, including in the half of the country Old Republic does not sell in. Empire Home Protect takes the round overall on the only record that is fully checkable before purchase: a public sample contract, published price, fee, limit, and waiting period, and a claims standard stated in advance — a record a shopper verifies with their own eyes rather than inherits from a closing packet or a regional map.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection. Start with the arithmetic, because this round is where the pairing’s difference stops being a matter of framing. A home warranty’s honest price is a year of premiums plus the service fees of the claims you actually file, so this comparison prices a standard two-claim year for each company from published figures only. Empire Home Protect: $49/mo is $588 a year in premiums, plus two flat $75 service fees is $150, for a two-claim year of $738 — computable exactly, before you buy, from numbers on the public record. Old Republic Home Protection: premiums between $45 and $90 a month annualize to $540 to $1,080; two claims at one trade each add two fees of $100 or $125, another $200 to $250; the two-claim year brackets to $740 to $1,330 — and a two-trade claim pushes the top of that bracket higher, at a second $100 or $125 for the same breakdown. The bracket is wide, but it is a bracket: a shopper can hold it, budget to its top, and question any quote that lands outside it. First American Home Warranty: the two-claim year is not computable. Not wide, not approximate — absent. With no published premium, no published fee, and no published caps, there is no honest figure to print, and this comparison prints none rather than invent one.

How you buy follows the same pattern. Old Republic is bought two ways: through a real-estate transaction, on the Silver, Gold, and Platinum shelf, or directly as a homeowner inside its 25-state map, against the quoted range. First American is bought, most often, by not buying it at all — it is included, offered, or handed over, and the holder’s first decision point is usually renewal. Empire Home Protect is bought the way a shopper buys: an online quote and checkout, no sales call required, against a published starting price the quote then confirms, with a person available 24/7 at +1-888-462-3382 if you would rather talk it through. The round goes to Old Republic between the two legacy brands because its deal can be priced before it is signed, at least within a bracket — and it goes to Empire overall because Empire’s deal is the only one on this page that can be priced exactly.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Empire Home Protect publishes its price, fee, and limit before you buy: from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Consider Old Republic Home Protection if you live inside its 25 states plus DC, your home carries premium appliances whose replacement cost makes a published $7,000 Elite cap worth paying toward the top of a quoted range for, and you are willing to budget to the bracket’s ceiling — up to $1,330 for a two-claim year, more if a claim needs two trades — in exchange for caps you can read before you sign. Read the Basic tier’s exclusions twice before choosing it: a plan without air conditioning and washer/dryer coverage is a partial plan, and Deluxe or Elite is where this company’s real offer starts.

Keep a First American Home Warranty if it came with your house. Coverage you already hold, placed at closing, is real coverage, and the right move is to use the year it gives you: read the contract now, before anything breaks, and write down the three numbers it never published — your price, your service fee, and your claim limits — while you are calm. Then, at renewal, make the next choice a chosen one: line those three numbers up against published ones, and decide as a shopper rather than as an heir to a closing packet.

Buy Empire Home Protect if you are choosing for yourself, which is the position everyone reading a comparison page is in. It publishes the lowest checkable full-home starting price in this comparison at $49/mo, the lowest flat service fee at $75 with no per-trade multiplication, and a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract — and on the day something breaks, it approves the claim the same day, with service approved in minutes, instead of placing you in a traditional phone queue. That is the whole comparison in one sentence: printed numbers, a flat fee, and digital speed, against a printed bracket in half the country and a sealed quote at the closing table.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

Old Republic Home Protection beats First American Home Warranty in a head-to-head because it shows up to be compared: a quoted $45 to $90 a month range instead of no published price, a $100 or $125 per-trade fee menu instead of a fee sealed in a contract, and published appliance caps of $3,500 and $7,000 on Elite instead of limits a holder meets after closing. First American’s strength is the closing table itself — real coverage, already in the house, for the many households that never had to choose — and this comparison credits that strength in the round it wins. But a printed bracket available in 25 states, with a fee that can double on a two-trade claim, and a sealed quote with no bracket at all, are both legacy answers. The current answer is the company that publishes a full-home price of $49/mo, a flat $75 fee, and a $10,000 annual limit in a sample contract anyone can read, and then approves claims the same day on a fully digital platform, with integrity and respect and people available 24/7. That company is Empire Home Protect, and it is why every quote button on this page points where it points. Before you sign with anyone — including Empire — read the sample contract, confirm the items your tier names, the fee, the caps, and the waiting period in writing, and keep the document. A warranty you have read is worth more than a warranty you were handed, whichever name is on it.