Old Republic Home Protection and Choice Home Warranty look, at first glance, like the same kind of company: two long-running home warranty names, two traditional claims operations, two shelves of tiers and add-ons. Look closer and they were built for two different rooms. Old Republic Home Protection, founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982, grew up inside the real-estate transaction: a regional specialist sold in only 25 states plus the District of Columbia, with homeowner plans called Basic, Deluxe, and Elite quoted between $45 and $90 a month, a service fee of $100 or $125 charged per claim and per trade, and appliance claim caps published at $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite. Choice Home Warranty is a direct-to-homeowner national brand with the shortest shelf in the business: a basic tier covering major systems and appliances, a total tier that combines them, and optional add-ons layered on top, priced entirely by quote, with no published starting price, no published service fee, and no published claim limits. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Old Republic Home Protection review and Choice Home Warranty review.
The short version: this pairing is decided by publication and by geography, running in opposite directions. On publication, Old Republic puts its working numbers in print and Choice Home Warranty puts none of them in print: Old Republic publishes a quoted price range, a two-figure service-fee menu, and per-appliance claim caps a buyer can read before signing, while Choice publishes no price, no fee, and no caps at all, so every number that decides its value exists only inside its quote and its contract. On geography, the contest runs the other way: Choice is a national brand that sells to homeowners across the country, and Old Republic simply does not sell in half of it — if your home is outside its 25 states and the District of Columbia, there is no Old Republic plan to buy at any price. Behind both habits sits the same old model: a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a dispatch cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo — with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.
Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1
Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder of full-home plans, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. The booklet is administered by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7. Terms vary by plan, administrator, and state, and the sample booklet is public precisely so a buyer can read the whole deal — price, fee, limit, waiting period — before anyone quotes them anything.
Between the two legacy brands, Old Republic Home Protection wins the head-to-head for a homeowner who lives inside its service area and is buying coverage for their own home. It wins the price round, because a published range of $45 to $90 a month, plus published per-year examples on its real-estate shelf, is evidence a buyer can hold, while a quote with no published starting figure is not. It wins the service-fee round outright, because $100 or $125 per trade is a menu printed in advance, while Choice Home Warranty’s fee is set inside a quote the buyer has not seen yet. It wins the claim-limits round outright, because $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite are caps published where a shopper can plan around them, while Choice’s limits live in the limits section of a contract. And it wins the total-cost round, because its cost can at least be bracketed from published figures, while Choice’s cannot be totalled from published figures at all.
Choice Home Warranty’s wins are real, and the rounds below give them full credit: it wins the plans round narrowly, because a two-tier shelf — basic, total, add-ons — is the shortest first decision in the field, with no entry tier that quietly leaves out air conditioning and the washer and dryer. It wins the tenure, record, and availability round, because it is a long-running national name with a public record written by homeowners in every market it serves, against a respected regional specialist that half the country cannot buy. And it is the only one of the two available at all in the states Old Republic does not serve. A homeowner outside Old Republic’s map, or one who wants the simplest possible first choice, will still look at Choice. But availability and simplicity are not terms you can verify, and a comparison site exists to compare: on the checkable money terms in this pairing — price, fee, caps, and the total a year of claims costs — Old Republic puts its numbers in print and Choice puts its numbers in a quote. Both, on the evidence below, land behind the #1 pick.
See Your Empire Home Protect Price
Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteOld Republic Home Protection vs Choice Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick
Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; sample contract booklet public (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), administered by Aegis Administration, obligor Assurance Express, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.
Old Republic Home Protection: Founded 1974, San Ramon, California; subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982; sold in 25 states plus the District of Columbia only; homeowner plans Basic / Deluxe / Elite quoted at $45–$90/mo; service fee $100 or $125 per claim, charged per trade; appliance caps $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite; Basic excludes air conditioning and washer/dryer; real-estate plans Silver / Gold / Platinum, with a published Texas example of $525 / $730 / $935 per year for a single-family home under 5,000 square feet and a $100 trade call fee; coverage starts 30 days after payment; repairs guaranteed 30 days; traditional phone-driven claims.
Choice Home Warranty: Long-running national brand selling directly to homeowners; two tiers — a basic tier and a total (combined) tier — plus optional add-ons; pricing entirely by quote, varying by home, state, and tier, with no published starting price; service fee and claim limits set in the quote and contract, with no published figures; traditional phone-driven claims, with no published response window in the record this comparison scores.
Read that glance carefully and the shape of the whole comparison is already visible. One company in this pairing publishes a price range, a fee menu, and its caps, and sells in barely half the country. The other sells everywhere and publishes nothing. The #1 pick publishes a single starting price, a single flat fee, and a single annual limit, in a contract anyone can read before buying. The eight rounds below score each of those claims in turn.
What Each Company Actually Is: the Regional Specialist vs the Two-Tier National
Old Republic Home Protection is a transaction-born specialist that stayed regional on purpose. Its founding business was the warranty handed over at closing, and that heritage still shows in everything about it: a separate real-estate shelf with its own tier names, brochures priced by the year and by the size of the house, and a service area drawn around the markets where its closing-table relationships run deepest. Fifty years after its founding, and more than four decades inside a large insurance group, it remains a company a homeowner in half the country simply cannot choose. That narrowness is not an accident or a failure; it is the footprint of a business built around transactions rather than around homeowners shopping for themselves. Its homeowner shelf — Basic, Deluxe, Elite — exists, and is quoted in a published range, but the company’s center of gravity is still the deal table.
Choice Home Warranty is the opposite construction: a national brand built to sell directly to homeowners, with no closing table in its story at all. Everything about its presentation is aimed at a shopper comparing options at a kitchen table or on a phone: a shelf short enough to explain in one sentence, add-ons for the extras, and a quote process that collects the details of your home before it names any number. That directness is genuinely appealing, and its two-tier shelf is the easiest first decision in this pairing. But the same model that makes the shelf simple makes the terms invisible: because every price is built per home, no price is published for any home, and the fee and the caps travel with the price into the quote. A shopper can learn what Choice is in a minute, and cannot learn what Choice costs until the sales process has their details.
Empire Home Protect was built on the third model, the technology model: publish the whole deal first, then let the shopper decide. The sample contract is public. The starting price is public. The fee and the annual limit are public. The claims process is digital, approved the same day, with service approved in minutes and people available around the clock when a human is what the situation needs. That is the standard the two legacy brands are scored against in every round below — not because this site favors it in the abstract, but because a buyer can verify it without asking anyone’s permission.
Round 1 — Price: a Published Range vs No Published Price at All, Against a Published $49/mo
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection.
Old Republic publishes a range, and a range is a real thing. A homeowner quoted $45 to $90 a month for Basic, Deluxe, or Elite can place their own quote inside or outside that bracket, can see what the top of the shelf costs before they climb it, and can compare the bracket against a rival’s published starting price without making a single phone call. Its real-estate shelf goes further and publishes whole numbers: the Texas brochure example prices a single-family home under 5,000 square feet at $525, $730, and $935 for the year across its three transaction tiers. None of that is a personalized price, and this comparison does not pretend otherwise. It is, however, evidence — printed, checkable, and available before the sales process begins.
Choice publishes no price evidence at all. There is no starting figure, no range, and no worked example in the record this comparison scores: the price of a basic plan and the price of a total plan both exist only inside a quote built from your home, your state, and your tier. Quote-based pricing is not dishonest, and it can reflect real differences between homes. But it has one unavoidable consequence for a comparison: it cannot be compared. A shopper holding three browser tabs open can line up Old Republic’s published range and Empire Home Protect’s published starting price side by side, and the third tab simply has a form on it. The number that matters most is the one number that is not there.
Empire Home Protect publishes the cleanest price story in the pairing: full-home plans from $49/mo, one starting figure for the whole Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, readable in seconds. Set the three side by side and the round scores itself. A published starting price beats a published range, because it tells a buyer where the shelf begins rather than merely where it might end. A published range beats no published price, because a bracket can be checked and nothing cannot. Round 1 verdict: Empire Home Protect. Between the two, Old Republic Home Protection, on the only published price evidence either legacy brand offers.
Round 2 — Plans: a Three-Tier Ladder With a Thin First Rung vs the Shortest Shelf in the Field
Winner: Empire Home Protect overall. Between the two: Choice Home Warranty, narrowly.
Choice’s shelf is two decisions long. The basic tier covers the major systems and appliances a warranty exists for; the total tier combines them into the whole-home choice; optional add-ons cover the extras a particular house needs. That is the entire first decision, and for a first-time warranty buyer it is a genuine virtue: there is no third tier to decode, no matrix of exclusions to map before the ladder makes sense, and no wrong first rung that looks like full coverage and is not. Simplicity is the thing Choice sells best, and this round gives it full credit.
Old Republic’s homeowner shelf has three tiers, and its first rung carries a trap a buyer must be told about plainly: Basic excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer. In most of the country, air conditioning is not an optional extra; it is the single most likely reason a homeowner files a claim in a given summer. A tier that omits it is a tier priced to be chosen by people who have not read it closely, and the step up to Deluxe or Elite is where the real coverage begins. Above that first rung the ladder is respectable — Elite carries the deepest appliance cap in this pairing, scored in Round 4 — and the separate real-estate shelf serves transaction buyers with its own published examples. But a ladder whose entry tier leaves out the two most ordinary claims in the house starts the comparison a step behind a shelf with no such trap.
Empire Home Protect’s ladder is three full-home tiers — Silver, Supreme, Titanium — differentiated by depth of coverage rather than by which ordinary system has been removed from the bottom rung, starting from a published $49/mo. It matches Choice’s clarity with one more level of choice, and it avoids Old Republic’s thin first rung entirely. Round 2 verdict: Empire Home Protect overall. Between the two, Choice Home Warranty, narrowly, on the shortest and most honest first decision in the pairing.
Round 3 — Service Fees: a Published Per-Trade Menu vs a Fee With No Published Figure, Against a Flat $75
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection, outright.
The service fee is the price of using the product you already bought, and it is the figure homeowners feel most directly, because it is paid at the worst moment: something is broken. Old Republic publishes its fee as a two-figure menu, $100 or $125, and publishes the condition attached to it just as clearly: the fee is charged per claim and per trade. That condition matters. A breakdown that needs two trades — a plumber and an electrician on the same failure, for example — can carry the fee twice, so a single claim can cost $200 or $250 in fees before any repair begins. A buyer who has read the menu knows that in advance and can budget for it. A buyer who has not will learn it on the phone, at the worst moment, which is exactly when a published figure earns its keep.
Choice publishes no service-fee figure in the record this comparison scores. Its fee is set in the quote and fixed in the contract, which means a shopper comparing the two legacy brands today can write down Old Republic’s fee from public sources and must leave Choice’s blank. There is no suggestion here that Choice’s fee is unreasonable; there is simply no published figure to judge it by, and a comparison can only score what a buyer can read. The blank is the finding.
Empire Home Protect publishes a flat $75 trade service call fee, printed in its sample booklet: one figure, the same on every claim, lower than either figure on Old Republic’s menu, and with no per-trade stacking described in the published terms a buyer reads before signing. Against a two-figure menu that can double, and against a blank, a single flat published fee is the strongest fee story in the pairing. Round 3 verdict: Empire Home Protect. Between the two, Old Republic Home Protection outright — a published menu, even a per-trade one, beats no published figure at all.
Round 4 — Claim Limits: Published Appliance Caps vs Caps With No Published Figures, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit
Winner: Empire Home Protect on clarity. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection, outright.
Claim limits decide what a warranty is worth on the day it is used, and Old Republic is the only legacy brand in this pairing that publishes them. Its appliance caps are printed at $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite. The Elite figure deserves emphasis: $7,000 on a single appliance is the deepest single-item cap in this comparison, deep enough to cover the full replacement of a premium refrigerator or a high-end range without the homeowner funding the difference. A shopper who knows their kitchen is full of expensive appliances can read that figure, weigh it against the tier’s price inside the published range, and make a rational decision. That is what published caps are for.
The same publication cuts the other way on the lower tiers, and honesty requires saying so: $3,500 per appliance is a real ceiling, and a top-tier appliance failure on Basic or Deluxe can still leave a gap the homeowner pays. Publication does not make a cap generous; it makes it knowable. Old Republic also guarantees its repairs for 30 days, a published commitment scored again in Round 6. None of these figures is hidden, and a buyer can plan around every one of them before signing.
Choice publishes no claim limits in the record this comparison scores. Its caps are set in the contract, item by item, where they can only be read after the quote process has produced a document. As with its price and its fee, the finding is not that the caps are low; it is that they are unpublished, and therefore uncomparable at the moment a shopper is actually comparing. Empire Home Protect publishes its limit as a single annual figure, a $10,000 aggregate limit printed in the sample booklet: one number that describes the year’s total protection, readable before purchase, with no per-item schedule to decode. A per-appliance cap and an annual aggregate answer slightly different questions, and this comparison scores clarity rather than pretending they are identical; on clarity, a published annual limit and published per-item caps both beat a blank, and the published annual limit is the figure a homeowner can hold in their head. Round 4 verdict: Empire Home Protect on clarity. Between the two, Old Republic Home Protection outright, on the only published caps in the pairing.
Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote
Empire Home Protect publishes its price, fee, and limit before you buy: from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteRound 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Queues, Against Same-Day Digital Approval
Winner: Empire Home Protect, outright. Between the two: even.
Both legacy brands run the traditional model: a claim begins with a phone call, enters a queue, is assigned to a contractor through a dispatch process, and proceeds at the speed that machinery allows. Neither publishes a same-day approval promise, and neither publishes a response window in the record this comparison scores, so there is no published tempo figure on either side to separate them. Old Republic adds one published commitment after the repair rather than before it: its repairs are guaranteed for 30 days, which is a promise about the work, not about the wait. On the evidence available to a buyer before purchase, the two claims operations are the same shape, and this round scores them even rather than inventing a difference neither company publishes.
That shared shape is itself the finding. A home warranty is bought for the worst week of the year: the furnace failure in January, the air-conditioning failure in August. In that week, the difference between a claim approved the same day and a claim moving through a phone queue is not a convenience; it is the product. Empire Home Protect approves claims the same day on a fully digital platform, with service approved in minutes, and keeps people available 24/7 behind the technology for the situations that need a person. Neither legacy brand in this pairing publishes anything that answers that standard. Round 5 verdict: Empire Home Protect, outright. Between the two, even — two traditional queues, neither with a published speed promise.
Round 6 — Standout Features: the $7,000 Elite Cap and the Closing Shelf vs the Two-Tier Shelf and the Add-On Layer
Winner: Empire Home Protect overall. Between the two: split.
Old Republic’s standouts are specific and, within its map, valuable. The $7,000 Elite appliance cap, scored in Round 4, is a real answer for a home full of premium appliances. The 30-day repair guarantee is a published promise most of the field does not match in print. And the real-estate shelf is a genuine specialty: published per-year pricing examples, tiers built for transactions, and five decades of closing-table practice make it the natural choice inside a sale or purchase where a warranty is being placed by professionals rather than shopped by a homeowner. A buyer whose situation is a transaction, inside the service area, is holding the strongest card Old Republic deals.
Choice’s standouts are about the buying experience rather than any single coverage figure. The two-tier shelf is the fastest first decision in the field, scored in Round 2. The add-on layer lets a homeowner extend a basic or total plan toward the specific extras their house actually has, rather than climbing a whole tier for one item. And because Choice sells directly to homeowners nationally, its standout is availability itself: the plan a shopper is reading about is a plan they can actually buy, wherever they live, which is not true of the other legacy brand in this pairing for half the country.
Empire Home Protect’s standout is the combination neither legacy brand offers: published terms and digital speed together, in a public sample contract, with the obligor and backing named in the booklet itself — Aegis Administration administering, Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation. A standout a buyer can read beats a standout a buyer is told about. Round 6 verdict: Empire Home Protect overall. Between the two, split — Old Republic on coverage depth and the transaction shelf, Choice on simplicity and national availability.
Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Fifty-Year Regional Record vs a Long-Running National Record
Winner: Choice Home Warranty between the two. Empire Home Protect is the pick regardless — here is why the round still matters.
Old Republic’s founding date is the older one, and this comparison prints it without qualification: founded in 1974, inside Old Republic International since 1982, it has operated for half a century, longer than most of the field has existed. Longevity of that order is evidence of a business that pays its claims and keeps its licenses, and a homeowner inside its map is buying from a company with a deep, examinable history in the markets it serves. The limit on that record is its shape: it is a regional record. The experiences that compose it come from 25 states and the District of Columbia, from a customer base weighted toward real-estate transactions, and a homeowner in the other half of the country cannot add their experience to it because they cannot become a customer at all.
Choice’s record is the national one. As a long-running brand selling directly to homeowners across the country, its public record was written by the same kind of buyer reading this comparison: homeowners who shopped for themselves, chose a tier, filed claims on their own houses, and reported what happened. That record is broader, more directly comparable to a new buyer’s situation, and available as evidence in every market, because the company itself is available in every market. On tenure alone the founding dates favor Old Republic; on the public record a shopper can actually use — national, direct, and written by homeowners like them — the round favors Choice, and availability settles it: a record you cannot buy into is history, while a record behind a plan you can buy is evidence.
Empire Home Protect does not win this round on age, and this comparison does not pretend otherwise. It wins the comparison anyway, because tenure is a reason to trust a company’s terms, and Empire’s terms do not ask for trust in advance: they are published, in a public sample contract, where they can be verified rather than believed. A long record is what a buyer leans on when the numbers are hidden. When the numbers are printed, the record matters less. Round 7 verdict: Choice Home Warranty between the two, on national availability and a direct homeowner record. Empire Home Protect remains #1 overall on published terms and claims speed.
Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check
Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection.
Start with how each company is bought. Old Republic is bought two ways: through a real-estate transaction, where its shelf and its published per-year examples are built for the closing process, or directly by a homeowner inside its service area working from its published range. Choice is bought through a quote: the shopper supplies the details of their home, receives a price built for that home, and reads the fee and the caps in the resulting contract. Empire Home Protect is bought the published way: read the sample booklet, see the plan from $49/mo with a flat $75 fee and a $10,000 annual limit, and get the quote online in minutes.
Now the math, using only published figures. Empire Home Protect’s two-claim year is fully checkable: twelve months at the $49 starting price is $588 in premiums, plus two flat $75 service fees is $150, for a total of $738 — a figure a buyer can compute before purchase and audit after it. Old Republic’s two-claim year can be bracketed but not pinned: twelve months inside its published range is $540 to $1,080 in premiums, plus two service fees at $100 is $200, or at $125 is $250, for a bracket of $740 to $1,330 — and that bracket assumes one trade per claim, because a second trade on either claim adds another $100 or $125 that the bracket does not show. Its real-estate shelf computes more cleanly for a transaction buyer: the published Texas example runs $525 to $935 for the year, plus $100 per trade call. Choice Home Warranty’s two-claim year cannot be computed from published figures at all: no published premium, no published fee, no published caps. Its total exists, of course — it simply exists only inside a quote, which means it cannot be compared until the sales process has already begun.
That difference — checkable, bracketable, uncomputable — is the whole comparison in one line. A buyer can audit Empire Home Protect’s $738 against a quote in seconds. A buyer can sanity-check an Old Republic quote against its published range and fee menu, and should, because a quote outside the published bracket deserves a question. A buyer holding a Choice quote has nothing published to check it against, and must create the comparison themselves by collecting rival quotes — which is, in the end, an argument for starting with the company whose numbers are already public.
Round 8 verdict: Empire Home Protect, on a two-claim year of $738 that can be checked before you buy. Between the two, Old Republic Home Protection — a bracketable $740 to $1,330 from published figures, against a total that cannot be computed from published figures at all.
Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand
Choose Old Republic Home Protection if your home is inside its 25 states or the District of Columbia, you want your fee and your appliance caps in print before you sign, and the published $7,000 Elite appliance cap answers the specific fear that brought you shopping. Read the per-trade fee wording twice, step over the Basic tier if air conditioning and laundry coverage matter to you, and confirm your quote sits inside the published range. Inside its map, on published terms, it is the stronger of the two legacy brands in this pairing.
Choose Choice Home Warranty if you live outside Old Republic’s map, or the simplest possible first decision matters more to you than reading a price, a fee, and claim limits in advance, or you are building a plan from a basic or total tier plus add-ons around a specific home. Go in with your eyes open: get the fee in writing, read the limits section line by line, and total the quote against a published rival before you sign.
Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the complete deal published before you buy and the claim approved the day you file it: full-home Silver, Supreme, and Titanium plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract, and same-day digital approval with service in minutes and people available 24/7. That is most homeowners, most of the time — which is why it is our #1 pick, and why every quote button on this page points to it.
See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home
Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.
Get My Empire QuoteThe Bottom Line
Old Republic Home Protection vs Choice Home Warranty is a contest between a specialist that publishes and a national brand that does not. Old Republic wins the rounds that publication decides: a published price range and published per-year examples against no published price, the only published service-fee menu in the pairing, the only published claim caps in the pairing, and a total cost a buyer can at least bracket before buying. Choice wins the rounds that simplicity and scale decide: the shortest shelf in the field, with no thin first rung, and a long-running national record behind a plan any homeowner in the country can buy. Both run the same traditional machinery underneath — a 30-day wait, a fee on every claim, and a phone-first dispatch queue — and both ask a homeowner to accept at least one important number unseen: Old Republic’s per-trade fee can stack, and its map ends at 25 states; Choice’s price, fee, and limits all wait inside a quote.
Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it removes the unseen numbers and the old machinery together: full-home plans from a published $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all in a public sample contract, with claims approved the same day and service approved in minutes on a fully digital platform, and people available 24/7. If you are holding a quote from either legacy brand, set it next to that published story and ask the only question this comparison has really been asking: what, exactly, are you being asked not to read first? Then get the Empire Home Protect quote and compare the two documents side by side.