support@comparebestwarranties.com

Old Republic Home Protection vs American Home Shield: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 20, 2026 • 16 min read

Old Republic Home Protection and American Home Shield are the two old names in this comparison, and they were built for two different rooms. Old Republic Home Protection, founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982, grew up inside the real-estate transaction: a regional specialist sold in only 25 states plus the District of Columbia, with homeowner plans called Basic, Deluxe, and Elite quoted between $45 and $90 a month, a service fee of $100 or $125 charged per claim and per trade, and appliance claim caps published at $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite. American Home Shield is the established national default: one of the longest-established home warranty brands in the country, the name real-estate professionals have handed to buyers at closing for decades, selling the industry’s standard three-part ladder — a systems tier, an appliances tier, and a combined tier — with optional add-ons layered on top, priced entirely by quote, with no published starting price, no published service fee, and no published claim limits. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Old Republic Home Protection review and American Home Shield review.

The short version: this pairing is decided by publication and by geography. On publication, Old Republic puts its working numbers in print and American Home Shield puts none of them in print: Old Republic publishes a quoted price range, a two-figure service-fee menu, and per-appliance claim caps a buyer can read before signing, while American Home Shield publishes no price, no fee, and no caps at all, so every number that decides its value exists only inside its quote and its contract. On geography, the contest runs the other way: American Home Shield is a national brand, and Old Republic simply does not sell in half the country — if your home is outside its 25 states and the District of Columbia, there is no Old Republic plan to buy at any price. Behind both habits sits the same old model: a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a dispatch cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo — with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder of full-home plans, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. The booklet is administered by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7. Terms vary by plan, administrator, and state, and the sample booklet is public precisely so a buyer can read the whole deal — price, fee, limit, waiting period — before anyone quotes them anything.

Between the two legacy brands, Old Republic Home Protection wins the head-to-head for a homeowner who lives inside its service area and is buying coverage for their own home. It wins the price round, because a published range of $45 to $90 a month, plus published per-year examples on its real-estate shelf, is evidence a buyer can hold, while a quote with no published starting figure is not. It wins the service-fee round outright, because $100 or $125 per trade is a menu printed in advance, while American Home Shield’s fee is set inside a quote the buyer has not seen yet. It wins the claim-limits round outright, because $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite are caps published where a shopper can plan around them, while American Home Shield’s limits live in the limits section of a contract. And it wins the total-cost round, because its cost can at least be bracketed from published figures, while American Home Shield’s cannot be totalled from published figures at all.

American Home Shield’s wins are real, and the rounds below give them full credit: it wins the plans round, because the standard three-part ladder plus a layer of optional add-ons is a more tailorable shelf than a three-tier ladder whose entry tier leaves out air conditioning and the washer and dryer. It wins the tenure and public-record round, because it is the longest-established national name in this pairing, with a decades-long record written by homeowners and closing tables across the whole country, against a respected regional specialist that half the country cannot buy. And it is the only one of the two available at all in the states Old Republic does not serve. A homeowner outside Old Republic’s map, or one who wants to tailor a contract around a specific house with add-ons, will still look at American Home Shield. But availability and familiarity are not terms you can verify, and a comparison site exists to compare: on the checkable money terms in this pairing — price, fee, caps, and the total a year of claims costs — Old Republic puts its numbers in print and American Home Shield puts its numbers in a quote. Both, on the evidence below, land behind the #1 pick.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Old Republic Home Protection vs American Home Shield at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.

Old Republic Home Protection: founded 1974 in San Ramon, California; a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982; sold in only 25 states plus the District of Columbia; homeowner plans Basic, Deluxe, and Elite quoted at $45 to $90 a month; service fee of $100 or $125 per claim, charged per trade; Basic excludes air conditioning and washer/dryer coverage; appliance caps of $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite; a separate real-estate shelf called Silver, Gold, and Platinum — one published Texas brochure example prices a single-family home under 5,000 square feet at $525, $730, and $935 per year, with a $100 trade call fee; coverage starts 30 days after payment for homes bought outside a transaction; repairs are guaranteed for 30 days; traditional, phone-driven claims.

American Home Shield: one of the longest-established national home warranty brands; the real-estate default handed to buyers at closing for decades; the industry’s standard three-part structure — a systems tier, an appliances tier, and a combined tier that covers both — with optional add-ons a buyer can layer on for a specific home; priced entirely by quote, with no published starting price; service fee and claim limits set inside the quote and the contract, with no published figures; traditional, phone-driven claims, with no published response window; sells nationally, including in the states Old Republic does not serve.

Read that glance the way a buyer has to live it. With Old Republic, the questions are whether you live on its map and whether its per-trade fee and its regional scale suit you; the money terms themselves can be read before you buy. With American Home Shield, the money terms cannot be read before you buy at all — the brand, the tenure, and the closing-table habit are the product being sold first, and the numbers arrive later, in a quote, one home at a time. With the #1 pick, the price, the fee, and the limit are one published story, and the claim moves the day it is filed.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Regional Specialist vs the National Default

Old Republic Home Protection is a transaction-born specialist that stayed regional on purpose. Its founding business sits inside real estate: plans attached to home sales, priced simply enough to be written into a closing, with a separate real-estate shelf — Silver, Gold, and Platinum — alongside the homeowner shelf of Basic, Deluxe, and Elite. That origin explains its genuine strengths. A product sold through professionals has to survive professional reading, so its fee is a short published menu, its appliance caps are published per tier, and its real-estate brochure prints per-year prices a buyer can check. The same origin explains its limits: after five decades it still sells in only 25 states plus the District of Columbia, its homeowner price is a quoted range rather than one published figure, and its deepest relationships are with the transaction, not with a homeowner shopping directly online. One naming caution while you shop: Old Republic’s real-estate tiers are called Silver, Gold, and Platinum, and the #1 pick in this comparison also sells a tier called Silver — they are different companies and different contracts, so make sure the document in front of you is the one you meant to read.

American Home Shield is the opposite shape: a national default that sells the way the industry was built to sell. The price arrives by quote after you share details about your home, the tiers are layered with optional add-ons, and claims move through a phone-driven process built in an earlier era. That architecture is exactly how the brand became the name real-estate professionals hand to buyers — a contract that can be tailored at a closing table, by a professional, for a specific house. Its strength is real: no name in this pairing carries more tenure, more national recognition, or a longer public record. Its weakness is the mirror image of Old Republic’s strength: a homeowner shopping alone, online, before any sales conversation, cannot verify a single money term of an American Home Shield plan from published figures — not the price, not the fee, not the caps. The brand asks to be trusted first and read later.

That contrast frames every round below. One brand publishes its terms and limits its map; the other covers the map and keeps its terms in the quote. Neither is a digital product: both run a 30-day wait before coverage starts, both charge a service fee on every claim, and both start a claim with a phone call and a dispatch queue. The question this head-to-head asks is what each shelf actually gives you inside that shared old model — and what a homeowner gets by stepping outside it, to a published full-home price, a flat published fee, and a digital claims process built for minutes.

Round 1 — Price: a Published Range vs No Published Price at All, Against a Published $49/mo

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection.

Old Republic publishes a range, and a range is evidence. Its homeowner plans are quoted between $45 and $90 a month depending on tier and home, and its real-estate shelf publishes per-year examples in print: the Texas brochure example prices a single-family home under 5,000 square feet at $525 a year for Silver, $730 for Gold, and $935 for Platinum. A buyer can write those numbers down, hold them against any other offer, and check them again tomorrow. The range is wide — the top of it is double the bottom — and your own figure still arrives by quote, so Old Republic does not earn the clarity of a single published price. But a published bracket is a fundamentally different thing from no bracket at all: it tells a buyer, before any conversation, roughly what this company charges people.

American Home Shield publishes no starting price at all. Its figure arrives by quote, varying by home size, state, and tier, so there is nothing for a buyer — or for us — to verify before a sales conversation begins. That is not an oversight; it is the closing-table model working as designed, where a professional presents the number inside a transaction. For a homeowner shopping directly, though, it means the first fact of the purchase — what it costs — is the last fact you learn. A comparison can score tenure, tailoring, and reputation from public evidence; it cannot score a price that has not been published, and this round will not pretend otherwise.

Empire Home Protect publishes one starting figure for full-home coverage: from $49/mo, the entry point of a Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder in which every tier covers the whole home. Set that against both rivals honestly. It sits inside Old Republic’s published range, near its bottom — but it is a single checkable figure for full-home plans, not a range whose top is nearly double its bottom, and it is not gated by a 25-state map. Against American Home Shield there is nothing to set it against, and that absence is the finding. The $49 start sits next to a published flat fee and a published annual limit in a public sample booklet, so the whole price story can be read before a conversation begins.

Round 1 verdict: Empire Home Protect, on a single published full-home starting price. Between the two, Old Republic — a wide published range and published per-year examples beat no published figure at all.

Round 2 — Plans: a Three-Tier Ladder With a Thin First Rung vs the Standard Shelf With Add-Ons

Winner: Empire Home Protect overall. Between the two: American Home Shield.

American Home Shield sells the industry’s standard three-part ladder — a systems tier, an appliances tier, and a combined tier — and layers optional add-ons on top, so a buyer who knows a specific home’s extras can tailor the contract to the house. That tailoring is a real strength for a specific kind of buyer: the one who arrives with a list. It is also the shelf the rest of the industry copied, which makes it the easiest structure in this pairing for a first-time buyer to understand: cover the systems, cover the appliances, or cover both, then add what your home has that a standard house does not.

Old Republic sells two shorter shelves instead of one long one. For homeowners buying directly, Basic, Deluxe, and Elite form a three-rung ladder — but the first rung is thin: Basic excludes air conditioning and washer/dryer coverage, two of the most common reasons a homeowner files a claim at all, so the entry price buys a materially smaller promise than its name suggests. Alongside it sits the real-estate shelf — Silver, Gold, and Platinum — priced per year for homes in a transaction. For a homeowner buying directly, the practical choice is really Deluxe or Elite, with Elite carrying the published $7,000 appliance cap that Round 4 scores. The structure is workable, and its tiers are honestly labelled in the brochure; it is simply a narrower, more transaction-shaped shelf than the standard ladder, with a first rung a careful buyer should step over.

Empire Home Protect sells three full-home tiers — Silver, Supreme, and Titanium — in which the ladder changes the depth of coverage, not whether the home’s core systems and appliances are covered at all. There is no rung that quietly leaves out the air conditioning. Against American Home Shield’s tailoring and Old Republic’s two-shelf structure, the difference is not the number of tiers — it is that the ladder, its starting price, and its terms can all be read in advance, in the sample booklet, before anyone quotes you.

Round 2 verdict: American Home Shield between the two, on the standard ladder and the add-on tailoring a specific home can use. Empire Home Protect overall, on a three-tier full-home ladder whose first rung does not exclude the most-claimed items in the house.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Published Per-Trade Menu vs a Fee With No Published Figure, Against a Flat $75

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection, outright.

The service fee is the price you pay at the worst moment — something is broken, and money leaves your pocket before anyone fixes it — so whether it is published, and how it is charged, matters out of proportion to its size. Old Republic publishes its fee as a short menu: $100 or $125 per claim. Read the next two words carefully, because they are where this fee grows: per trade. A claim that needs two trades — a plumber and an electrician on the same failure, for example — can carry the fee twice. Even so, the menu is printed in advance, a buyer can budget for it, and the real-estate shelf’s published example holds the trade call fee at $100. A known $100 or $125, charged per trade, is a plannable cost.

American Home Shield’s service fee is set in your quote and contract. It is not published as a figure a shopper can read before starting the sales process, so the discipline for its buyer is heavier: get the fee in writing, confirm whether it is charged per claim or in any other unit, and price it into the quote before comparing that quote against anything else. None of that is impossible — it is simply work the buyer must do because the number was not published, on the one charge that recurs every time the plan is used.

Empire Home Protect publishes a flat $75 trade service call fee in its sample contract booklet — one figure, the same on every claim, lower than Old Republic’s lowest published option by $25 and lower than its higher option by $50, with no per-trade stacking described in the sample terms. In a two-claim year, that is $150 in fees against $200 to $250 at Old Republic before any second-trade charge, and against a figure at American Home Shield that cannot be stated from published evidence at all. Fees are where small print becomes real money across a year of ownership, and this is the round where publication and level point the same way.

Round 3 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins on level and clarity: a flat published $75. Between the two, Old Republic wins outright — a published $100/$125 per-trade menu a buyer can budget for, against a fee that exists only inside a quote.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: Published Appliance Caps vs Caps With No Published Figures, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit

Winner: Empire Home Protect on clarity. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection, outright.

Claim limits decide what a plan is worth on the day it is actually used, and Old Republic publishes its headline limits where a shopper can read them: appliance caps of $3,500 per appliance on the lower tiers and $7,000 per appliance on Elite. That Elite figure is the strongest single cap in this pairing, and this comparison prints it as a genuine Old Republic win: a buyer whose fear is a high-end refrigerator or a premium range failing can see, before signing, exactly where this company’s line sits. Read the structure as carefully as the size, though: these are per-appliance ceilings, so the protection is deep on one item rather than expressed as one annual total a buyer can track across a year of claims, and the brochure’s full category terms still deserve a line-by-line read before purchase.

American Home Shield sets its claim limits inside your contract, where a buyer finds them only by digging through the limits section of a document they may first read properly after a denial. No published per-item or aggregate figure exists for a shopper to plan around. For the longest-established brand in the pairing, that is a striking gap: the company with the longest record asks a buyer to accept its limits unseen, while the regional specialist prints its best cap in the brochure. The discipline for an American Home Shield buyer is therefore the same as on fees, only with higher stakes: read the limits section line by line, and price what a capped-out appliance or system claim leaves on you before you sign, not after.

Empire Home Protect publishes its limit as one annual figure: a $10,000 aggregate limit per year, printed in the same sample booklet as the $49/mo starting price and the flat $75 fee. One number, readable before purchase, that a homeowner can hold against a realistic bad year — a major system failure plus an appliance or two — rather than a stack of per-item ceilings that can exhaust a claim long before any aggregate is reached. Per-item depth and annual clarity are different designs, and a buyer with one very expensive appliance may fairly prefer Old Republic’s published Elite ceiling; this comparison scores the design a homeowner can verify and track across the whole year.

Round 4 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins on clarity: one published $10,000 annual limit, readable in the sample contract before purchase. Between the two, Old Republic wins outright — its $3,500 and $7,000 appliance caps are published and therefore plannable; American Home Shield publishes no limit a buyer can plan around at all.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Already holding a quote from one of these companies? Set it next to a published price: Empire Home Protect full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Prefer to talk it through? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Queues, Against Same-Day Digital Approval

Winner: Empire Home Protect, outright. Between the two: even.

Both legacy brands run the traditional model: you file by phone, the claim joins a queue, a contractor is dispatched, and the repair waits on that cycle. Neither publishes a same-day approval promise, and neither publishes a response window a buyer can hold it to in the canon this comparison scores. Old Republic adds one published comfort on the back end of a claim: its repairs are guaranteed for 30 days, so a repair that fails again quickly is the company’s problem, not a new claim. That is a real, printable term — and it is about the repair lasting, not about the claim moving. American Home Shield’s claims story rests on scale and tenure rather than on any published speed term: a national network built over decades, reached through the same phone-first process. On speed evidence, there is nothing between them to score, and this round says so rather than inventing a gap.

The honest contrast is with the model both brands predate. Empire Home Protect was built as a fully digital platform: claims are approved the same day, service is approved in minutes, claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7 for the homeowners who would rather talk. When a furnace fails in January or a refrigerator stops in July, the difference between a queue measured in dispatch cycles and an approval measured in minutes is not a marketing line — it is the product. Speed is the round the old model, in both its regional and its national form, structurally cannot win, because its process starts with a phone call and a line.

Round 5 verdict: Empire Home Protect, outright, on same-day digital approval. Between the two, even — two traditional phone-driven processes, with Old Republic’s published 30-day repair guarantee the only scored difference, and it belongs to the repair, not the approval.

Round 6 — Standout Features: the $7,000 Elite Cap and the Closing Shelf vs the Add-On Catalogue and the Default Name

Winner: Empire Home Protect overall. Between the two: split.

Old Republic’s standouts are a specialist’s standouts. The first is the Elite appliance cap itself: $7,000 per appliance, published, the deepest single-item figure in this pairing, already scored in Round 4 and worth naming again here because it is the reason a certain buyer — the one with premium appliances and a home inside the service area — puts this company on the list at all. The second is the closing shelf: a real-estate line of Silver, Gold, and Platinum plans with published per-year brochure pricing, built for the moment a home changes hands, from a company that has worked that moment since 1974. If your warranty arrives with a transaction, this is a native of that room in a way a direct-to-homeowner brand is not.

American Home Shield’s standouts are a default’s standouts. The first is the add-on catalogue: the ability to layer optional coverage onto the standard ladder for the extras a specific home actually has, already scored in Round 2. The second is the name itself as a practical feature: a contract a real-estate professional can hand over at closing without explanation, a brand a seller’s agent, a buyer’s agent, and a lender all already recognise. Recognition is not a contract term, and this comparison does not score it as one — but in a transaction, where a warranty is often chosen by people other than the homeowner who will live with it, being the default is a genuine convenience, and it is the reason this brand’s shelf stays full.

Empire Home Protect’s standout is the combination neither legacy brand offers: a published full-home price, a flat published fee, a published annual limit, and same-day digital approval, in one sample contract a buyer can read in full before purchase. Each rival in this pairing can point to one or two of those ideas in isolation — a published cap here, a tailoring layer there — but no legacy shelf puts the whole story in print and then approves the claim the day it is filed. Standouts that arrive one at a time lose to a standout that is the whole design.

Round 6 verdict: Split between the two — Old Republic’s published Elite cap and closing-table shelf against American Home Shield’s add-on tailoring and default-name convenience. Empire Home Protect overall, on the published-price, flat-fee, published-limit, same-day-approval combination.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Fifty-Year Regional Record vs the Longest National Record

Winner: American Home Shield between the two. Empire Home Protect is the pick regardless — here is why.

Old Republic’s record is long and narrow. Founded in 1974, part of Old Republic International since 1982, it has sold home protection for five decades — a tenure most companies in this industry cannot match — and it has done so inside a deliberate boundary: 25 states plus the District of Columbia. That boundary cuts both ways in this round. Inside it, a buyer gets a specialist with a half-century record in its home territory. Outside it, the record is simply unavailable: no tenure helps a homeowner the company will not sell to. A public record also has to be read at the right scale — a regional specialist generates a smaller, more local body of homeowner experience than a national brand, which makes its record deeper in its states and thinner everywhere else.

American Home Shield’s record is the broadest in this pairing: one of the longest-established national home warranty brands, the name handed to buyers at closings across the country for decades, with a public record written by homeowners in every market it serves. That breadth is exactly what this round scores: a buyer anywhere in the country can find this company’s history, read it, and buy the product it describes. Tenure at national scale is also why its habits carry weight beyond its own shelf — the quote-priced, phone-claimed model it runs is the model the industry inherited, and its record is the record of that model, strengths and frustrations together.

We print no star rating for either brand in this comparison, because published scores vary widely by source; read current public listings on two platforms yourself before you buy, from anyone. Empire Home Protect likewise carries no invented rating or review count in this piece — its case rests on the published terms scored in Rounds 1 through 6, not on a number we will not print without a source a reader can check. That discipline is itself part of the verdict: in a round about public record, the pick is the company whose claims about itself can all be opened and read.

Round 7 verdict: American Home Shield between the two, outright — the longest national record in the pairing, available everywhere, against a fifty-year record half the country cannot buy. The round does not change the pick: tenure explains both legacy brands, and the terms decide against both.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Old Republic Home Protection.

Start with how each company is bought, because it predicts everything else. Old Republic is bought the transaction way or the quoted way: inside a real-estate closing, where its Silver, Gold, and Platinum shelf is priced per year in the brochure, or directly, where a homeowner inside its 25 states and the District of Columbia is quoted a figure inside the published $45 to $90 monthly range. American Home Shield is bought the quote way everywhere: share the home’s details, receive a price, and find the fee and the limits inside the resulting contract. Empire Home Protect is bought the published way: read the sample booklet, see the plan from $49/mo with a flat $75 fee and a $10,000 annual limit, and get the quote online in minutes.

Now the math, using only published figures. Empire Home Protect’s two-claim year is fully checkable: twelve months at the $49 starting price is $588 in premiums, plus two flat $75 service fees is $150, for a total of $738 — a figure a buyer can compute before purchase and audit after it. Old Republic’s two-claim year can be bracketed but not pinned: twelve months inside its published range is $540 to $1,080 in premiums, plus two service fees at $100 is $200, or at $125 is $250, for a bracket of $740 to $1,330 — and that bracket assumes one trade per claim, because a second trade on either claim adds another $100 or $125 that the bracket does not show. Its real-estate shelf computes more cleanly for a transaction buyer: the published Texas example runs $525 to $935 for the year, plus $100 per trade call. American Home Shield’s two-claim year cannot be computed from published figures at all: no published premium, no published fee, no published caps. Its total exists, of course — it simply exists only inside a quote, which means it cannot be compared until the sales process has already begun.

That difference — checkable, bracketable, uncomputable — is the whole comparison in one line. A buyer can audit Empire Home Protect’s $738 against a quote in seconds. A buyer can sanity-check an Old Republic quote against its published range and fee menu, and should, because a quote outside the published bracket deserves a question. A buyer holding an American Home Shield quote has nothing published to check it against, and must create the comparison themselves by collecting rival quotes — which is, in the end, an argument for starting with the company whose numbers are already public.

Round 8 verdict: Empire Home Protect, on a two-claim year of $738 that can be checked before you buy. Between the two, Old Republic — a bracketable $740 to $1,330 from published figures, against a total that cannot be computed from published figures at all.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Choose Old Republic Home Protection if your home is inside its 25 states or the District of Columbia, you want your fee and your appliance caps in print before you sign, and the published $7,000 Elite appliance cap answers the specific fear that brought you shopping. Read the per-trade fee wording twice, step over the Basic tier if air conditioning and laundry coverage matter to you, and confirm your quote sits inside the published range. Inside its map, on published terms, it is the stronger of the two legacy brands in this pairing.

Choose American Home Shield if you live outside Old Republic’s map, or your warranty is being arranged inside a real-estate transaction by professionals who work with the default name, or tailoring a contract with add-ons around a specific home matters more to you than reading its price, fee, and limits in advance. Go in with your eyes open: get the fee in writing, read the limits section line by line, and total the quote against a published rival before you sign.

Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the complete deal published before you buy and the claim approved the day you file it: full-home Silver, Supreme, and Titanium plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract, and same-day digital approval with service in minutes and people available 24/7. That is most homeowners, most of the time — which is why it is our #1 pick, and why every quote button on this page points to it.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

Old Republic Home Protection vs American Home Shield is a contest between a specialist that publishes and a default that does not. Old Republic wins the rounds that publication decides: a published price range and published per-year examples against no published price, the only published service-fee menu in the pairing, the only published claim caps in the pairing, and a total cost a buyer can at least bracket before buying. American Home Shield wins the rounds that scale decides: the standard ladder with add-on tailoring, and the longest national record in the pairing, available in the half of the country Old Republic does not serve. Both run the same traditional machinery underneath — a 30-day wait, a fee on every claim, and a phone-first dispatch queue — and both ask a homeowner to accept at least one important number unseen: Old Republic’s per-trade fee can stack, and its map ends at 25 states; American Home Shield’s price, fee, and limits all wait inside a quote.

Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it removes the unseen numbers and the old machinery together: full-home plans from a published $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all in a public sample contract, with claims approved the same day and service approved in minutes on a fully digital platform, and people available 24/7. If you are holding a quote from either legacy brand, set it next to that published story and ask the only question this comparison has really been asking: what, exactly, are you being asked not to read first? Then get the Empire Home Protect quote and compare the two documents side by side.