Old Republic Home Protection and 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty are the two institutions in this comparison — companies built inside the real-estate transaction that learned to sell to homeowners directly. Old Republic Home Protection, founded in 1974 in San Ramon, California, and a subsidiary of Old Republic International since 1982, sells homeowner plans in just 25 states plus DC: three tiers — Basic, Deluxe and Elite — quoted between $45 and $90/mo, a service fee of $100 or $125 charged per trade, and published appliance caps of $3,500 on its lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite. 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty, founded in 1980 in Colorado and built on structural warranties for new construction, has been owned by Frontdoor, Inc. since December 2024 and sells in 48 states at prices anyone can read: a Systems plan at $39.99/mo covering 19 systems and no appliances, and a Pinnacle plan at $59.99/mo covering 28 items — the same price regardless of the home’s size, age or location — with published claim caps of $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance and $50,000 per term. One company quotes you a bracket inside a small footprint. The other prints two flat prices almost everywhere — then leaves its service fee unpublished and adds a reported 9.5% processing markup to monthly billing.
That contrast decides most of this comparison before the details start, and it is also why neither company finishes first here. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall in our 2026 home warranty comparison: published full-home plans — Silver, Supreme and Titanium — from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, a 30-day waiting period, and a fully digital claims process where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes, with people available 24/7. Those terms come from its published Comprehensive sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824, administered by Aegis Administration, LLC, with Assurance Express, LLC as obligor backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims (855) 203-9876) and vary by plan, administrator and state. No rating or review count is published for Empire Home Protect here, because no verified count exists — and no rating is invented for any brand in this comparison.
Our #1 Pick: Empire Home Protect
Published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit and same-day digital claims approval. Check your price before you compare another quote.
Get My Empire Home QuoteOr call +1-888-462-3382
The Short Answer
Between the two named companies, 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty wins for most homeowners buying a plan for their own home. It wins on published price (two flat premiums anyone can read — $39.99/mo for systems only and $59.99/mo for the whole home — against a quoted $45–$90/mo bracket whose tier price you learn only in your own quote), on claim limits where failures cost most ($5,000 per HVAC system and $50,000 per term, against appliance caps of $3,500 and $7,000), and on availability (48 states against 25 plus DC). Old Republic keeps real strengths, and the rounds below give them full credit: it publishes its service fee ($100 or $125 per trade) where 2-10 publishes no single figure, its $7,000 Elite appliance cap is more than three times 2-10’s $2,000 per-appliance cap, and its record runs six years longer, to 1974. A homeowner with high-end appliances inside Old Republic’s footprint can reasonably land there. Most homeowners, on published facts, land on 2-10.
Empire Home Protect beats both on the combination shoppers actually pay for: one published starting price below 2-10’s whole-home tier, one flat $75 fee instead of a per-trade menu or an unpublished election, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit stated as a single number, and same-day digital claims approval instead of a traditional phone queue. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.
How We Scored This Comparison
Eight rounds, each scored on published facts only: price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims process and speed, standout strength, company record and availability, and the two-claim year — what a household with two ordinary breakdowns actually pays. Where a company does not publish a term, we say so and score the gap, because a term you cannot read before you buy is a term you cannot compare. Figures for Old Republic and 2-10 come from each company’s own published material as carried in our provider reviews; Empire Home Protect figures come from its public sample booklet. No rating or review count is invented for any brand.
Old Republic Home Protection at a Glance
Founded 1974, San Ramon, California; part of Old Republic International since 1982. Homeowner plans in 25 states plus DC, in three tiers — Basic, Deluxe and Elite — quoted between $45 and $90/mo. The service fee is $100 or $125 per claim, charged per trade. Basic excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer, so this comparison prices Old Republic as a Deluxe-or-Elite product. Published appliance caps are $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite. Its published Texas real-estate example prices a single-family home under 5,000 square feet at $525, $730 and $935 per year with a $100 trade fee. Coverage starts 30 days after payment, and covered repairs are guaranteed for 30 days.
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty at a Glance
Founded 1980 in Colorado; owned by Frontdoor, Inc. since December 2024. Sold in 48 states, excluding Alaska and Hawaii. Two homeowner plans at flat prices, the same regardless of home size, age or location: Systems at $39.99/mo covering 19 systems and no appliances, and Pinnacle at $59.99/mo covering 28 items, systems plus kitchen and laundry appliances. A reported 9.5% processing markup rides on monthly payments. The service fee is chosen at purchase, with no single published figure — published menus vary by source and year. Published claim caps are $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance and $50,000 per term. Reviewers single out a workmanship guarantee longer than the industry’s usual 30 days. Separate seller coverage runs up to 180 days, and the company’s original business — builder structural warranties — remains its specialty. Coverage starts 30 days after purchase.
R1 — Price: 2-10 Wins on Publication
2-10 publishes the cleanest price evidence in this head-to-head: two flat premiums, readable in seconds, identical for a small starter house and a large older property in any state it serves. The honest catch is what the cheaper premium buys — Systems at $39.99/mo covers no appliances at all, so the like-for-like whole-home price is Pinnacle at $59.99/mo. Old Republic publishes a bracket instead of a price: $45–$90/mo across Basic, Deluxe and Elite, with your tier’s number settled in your quote, and its floor tier excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer. A bracket is better than a quote wall, but it is not a price. Empire Home Protect publishes the strongest figure on this page for comparable coverage: full-home plans from $49/mo — $10.99/mo below Pinnacle, about $132 a year — checkable before you share a single detail about your home. Round to 2-10 between the two named companies.
R2 — Plans and Coverage Structure: Split
Both companies sell a ladder with a deliberately thin first rung. Old Republic’s Basic excludes air conditioning and the washer and dryer — the most expensive system in most homes and the hardest-working appliance pair — so its real product starts at Deluxe, and its three resident tiers give a homeowner more shelf to climb. 2-10’s Systems covers no appliances at all, so its real product is Pinnacle — but 2-10’s shelf extends where Old Republic’s does not: builder structural warranties and seller coverage up to 180 days, machinery built for the transaction itself. For a resident homeowner comparing tiers, Old Republic’s structure is richer; for anyone buying or selling, 2-10’s is purpose-built. Empire Home Protect’s Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder is built as full-home plans from the first tier, with no structural sideline. Round split.
R3 — Service Fees: Old Republic Wins on Transparency
Old Republic charges $100 or $125 per claim, and the fee is charged per trade: a breakdown needing a plumber and an electrician is two fees on one bad day. The per-trade unit is the harsher structure — but the amount is published, in advance, as one of two numbers. 2-10 asks the buyer to choose the fee level at purchase and publishes no single figure: menus reported in current comparisons differ ($65 / $85 / $100 in some, $75 / $100 / $125 in others), so the exact fee in your contract cannot be verified from anything the company puts in front of shoppers generally. A fee you elect blind is worse than a fee you dislike in print. Both lose to one flat number: Empire Home Protect charges $75 per trade service call, published in advance, with no menu and no election to regret. Round to Old Republic on transparency.
R4 — Claim Limits: 2-10 Wins Where Failures Cost Most
2-10 publishes the strongest ceilings in this pairing where the money is: $5,000 per HVAC system — the single most expensive failure in most homes — inside a $50,000 aggregate per term. Old Republic publishes no comparable HVAC figure in its homeowner material; its published caps are appliance caps, $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite. That Elite figure deserves direct credit: at $7,000 per appliance it is more than three times 2-10’s $2,000 per-appliance cap, and for a kitchen full of premium refrigeration it is the better number. But a warranty is bought against the whole house, and the HVAC system plus a $50,000 term ceiling outweigh one appliance line. Empire Home Protect states its protection as one $10,000 annual aggregate limit — the simplest structure here to track, with no per-item arithmetic. Round to 2-10.
R5 — Claims Process and Speed: A Tie Between the Two
Both named companies run the traditional model: a service request, a queue, a dispatch cycle, a contractor assigned from a network. Neither publishes a same-day approval standard, and neither runs its claims digitally end to end. 2-10’s covered repairs carry a workmanship guarantee reviewers describe as longer than the usual 30 days — scored in R6 — but the front-end process a homeowner experiences is the same phone-driven sequence at both companies. That shared old-school process is the largest single reason both finish behind the top pick: Empire Home Protect approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform, with people available 24/7. Round tied between the two named companies — and decisive for the #1 ranking.
R6 — Standout Strength: 2-10 Wins Its Round
2-10’s standout is a specialty no pure home-warranty seller on this page attempts: the builder structural warranty, the product its name comes from — two-year and ten-year structural terms on new construction — backed by seller coverage that runs up to 180 days while a home is listed, and a workmanship guarantee on covered repairs that runs longer than the industry’s usual 30 days. If you are building, buying new, or selling, that machinery is genuinely purpose-built for you. Old Republic’s counterweights are real but narrower: the $7,000 Elite appliance cap scored in R4 and a published Texas real-estate pricing example. Neither matches a whole second product line. Round to 2-10, clearly.
R7 — Company Record and Availability: Split
On tenure, Old Republic holds the cleaner line: founded in 1974, held by a major insurance group since 1982 — six years older than 2-10’s 1980 founding, under one corporate roof for more than four decades. 2-10’s record is long too, and its company materials describe coverage touching more than 5.5 million homes over its history — a figure we print as the company’s own claim, not an audited count — but it changed hands in December 2024, acquired by Frontdoor, Inc. in a reported $585 million transaction. On availability there is no contest: 2-10 sells in 48 states, Old Republic in 25 states plus DC — which means roughly half the country’s homeowners cannot buy Old Republic at any price. Tenure to Old Republic, availability to 2-10 by a wide margin. Round split.
R8 — The Two-Claim Year: Split, Because Neither Total Is Clean
Total a normal unlucky year — premiums plus two service fees. Empire Home Protect: $49 × 12 = $588, plus two $75 fees, is $738, computable exactly, before you buy. 2-10 Pinnacle: $59.99 × 12 = $719.88 in premiums — the lowest premium line of the two named companies at whole-home level — but the reported 9.5% processing markup on monthly billing lifts the billed premium to roughly $788, and the two service fees sit at an amount chosen at purchase and not published as a single figure, so the honest total cannot be completed from published figures. (Systems totals $479.88 before the markup, but buys no appliance coverage.) Old Republic: premiums of $540–$1,080 across its bracket, plus two fees of $100–$125 (more if a claim needs two trades), totals $740–$1,330 — a wide range, but every input is published. One company gives you a range you can total; the other gives you a lower premium you cannot finish totalling. Round split.
Scorecard
R1 Price — 2-10. R2 Plans — split. R3 Service fees — Old Republic. R4 Claim limits — 2-10. R5 Claims speed — tie. R6 Standout strength — 2-10. R7 Record and availability — split. R8 Two-claim year — split. Head-to-head: 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty wins, three rounds to one, with four split or tied — and Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall, ahead of both, on a published $49/mo starting price, a flat $75 fee, a $10,000 annual limit and same-day digital claims approval.
Who Should Buy Which?
Buy Empire Home Protect if you want the whole deal published before you share a single detail about your home — price, fee and limit in one public booklet — and claims approved the same day instead of queued. 2-10 fits a homeowner in the 48 states it serves who wants a flat premium that ignores the home’s size and age, strong HVAC and term ceilings, or anyone whose purchase involves a builder, a listing or a closing. Old Republic fits a homeowner inside its 25-state footprint with high-end appliances worth protecting at the $7,000 Elite cap, who will buy Deluxe or Elite and accepts a per-trade fee and a 30-day repair guarantee.
How to Compare Any Home Warranty Quote
Five lines decide every quote in this industry. The monthly price for your exact tier and home. The service fee, its amount and its unit — per visit or per trade. The claim limits, per item and in aggregate, as numbers. The waiting period. And the repair guarantee, in days. 2-10 publishes four of the five and leaves the fee to your checkout; Old Republic publishes most of the five inside a quoted bracket; Empire Home Protect publishes all five in its sample booklet. Refuse to compare a quote with a missing line: ask for it in the document, then compare again.
Verdict
Empire Home Protect is our #1 pick overall. Between the two named companies, 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty beats Old Republic Home Protection for most homeowners: flat published premiums, the strongest HVAC and term ceilings, a structural specialty and near-national availability beat Old Republic’s published fee and superior Elite appliance cap. Old Republic is the more transparent company on the fee line and the older one; 2-10 is the more complete one on the numbers both publish. Both run a traditional phone-driven claims process, and both publish less of the total deal than the top pick.
Coverage, Item by Item: Where the Two Contracts Differ
Plan names hide the real differences; item lists and cap tables reveal them. On the systems side — heating, air conditioning, plumbing, electrical, water heater and ductwork — 2-10’s Pinnacle covers 28 items and its published ceiling does the heavy lifting: $5,000 per HVAC system. Old Republic’s warning is its Basic tier: no air conditioning. In most of its 25 states, air conditioning is the most expensive system in the house and the likeliest source of a four-figure repair, so a Basic buyer is uncovered on exactly the failure the product exists for; Deluxe and Elite restore it. On the appliances side — refrigerator, oven and range, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage disposal, washer and dryer — the warnings and the caps trade places: 2-10’s Systems tier covers no appliances at all, while Old Republic’s caps do the stronger work, $3,500 on the lower tiers and $7,000 on Elite against 2-10’s $2,000 per appliance. Empire Home Protect states its protection as one $10,000 annual aggregate limit across covered items — the simplest of the three structures to track: one number, one year, no per-item arithmetic at the kitchen table.
The Structural Difference: A Builder’s Warranty vs a Homeowner’s Plan
The deepest difference in this pairing is not a price or a cap; it is what each company was built to sell. 2-10’s name is its original product: structural warranties for builders, with coverage terms of two and ten years on new homes. That heritage runs through everything it does — seller coverage up to 180 days while a home is listed, a real-estate channel that has placed its plans at closings since 1980, and a workmanship guarantee on covered repairs that runs longer than the industry’s usual 30 days. Old Republic’s heritage is the transaction too — its published Texas example prices coverage through a real-estate sale at $525, $730 and $935 per year for a single-family home under 5,000 square feet — but its modern homeowner shelf is a conventional three-tier plan sold in a regional footprint. Neither heritage is a defect. The question is which one matches your situation: a purchase, a listing or a new build points at 2-10’s machinery; a settled homeowner protecting premium appliances inside the footprint points at Old Republic’s Elite tier; a settled homeowner who wants the deal published and the claim approved the same day points at the top pick.
The Waiting Period and the First 30 Days
Coverage does not start the day you pay, at any company here. Old Republic’s coverage starts 30 days after payment. 2-10’s coverage starts 30 days after purchase. Empire Home Protect’s sample booklet terms state a 30-day waiting period. The waiting period exists for a legitimate reason — it is what stops a warranty from being bought the morning a furnace dies, which would make the product unpriceable for everyone else — but it changes how you should buy. Buy before something breaks, not after. If a system in your home is already limping, the rational move is to start the 30-day clock now, while the failure is still a risk rather than a diagnosis — and to read each contract’s pre-existing-condition language before you pay, because that paragraph, not the waiting period, is where a failure discovered after the wait gets argued.
Exclusions: The Paragraph That Decides Claims
Every home warranty excludes things, and the honest comparison is not which company has exclusions — all three do — but whether you can read them before you pay. The recurring exclusion families are known pre-existing conditions, failures from lack of maintenance, cosmetic damage, items under a manufacturer warranty or recall, code violations and permit costs, and damage from external events that belong to homeowners insurance. Both named companies publish enough structure to interrogate these families before buying — 2-10’s caps are printed with a builder’s bluntness, and Old Republic’s tier exclusions are stated in its own material. Empire Home Protect publishes its sample contract booklet openly, so its exclusions can be read, searched and compared before a dollar changes hands. Whichever company you choose, read the exclusions section of the actual contract for your state and plan — not a summary, not a brochure — and keep the document you read.
Reading a 2-10 Quote: The Four Lines That Matter
2-10 publishes its premiums and its caps, so its quote has to be read for the lines it does not publish. Line one: the tier. A $39.99/mo Systems quote covers no appliances; the whole-home comparison price is Pinnacle at $59.99/mo, and any savings claimed against Systems is a coverage cut, not a discount. Line two: the service fee you elected. The amount is chosen at purchase and published nowhere as a single figure; get your exact amount in the contract, because you will pay it on every request. Line three: the billed premium, not the printed one. A reported 9.5% processing markup rides on monthly payments; ask for the all-in monthly figure in writing, or price the annual payment beside it. Line four: the caps as they apply to your two most expensive exposures — for most homes, the HVAC system ($5,000 per system) and the refrigerator ($2,000 per appliance). A 2-10 contract that states all four lines can be compared fairly against Old Republic’s published bracket and Empire Home Protect’s published booklet.
Reading an Old Republic Quote: The Three Traps
Old Republic publishes more, so its traps are narrower — but they are specific. Trap one: the Basic floor. A $45 quote is real, and it excludes air conditioning and the washer/dryer; price Deluxe or Elite before deciding the company is cheap or expensive. Trap two: the per-trade fee. Budget the fee multiplied by trades, not by breakdowns; a combined plumbing-and-electrical failure is two fees on the same day. Trap three: the lower-tier cap. $3,500 is a contribution, not a replacement guarantee, on premium appliances; if your kitchen carries high-end refrigeration, the Elite cap of $7,000 is the honest tier for your home, and its premium should be compared at that level. None of these traps is hidden — all three are visible in Old Republic’s own published material. Empire Home Protect’s published structure avoids the first two traps by design — full-home tiers rather than a stripped floor, and one flat fee rather than a per-trade menu — and states the third as a single $10,000 annual figure.
Questions on any figure in this comparison? Call +1-888-462-3382 and ask for the published term behind the number — every figure above traces to a price, fee, cap or booklet line the company itself puts in front of shoppers.
Empire Home Protect — Ranked #1 Overall
Silver / Supreme / Titanium plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit and claims approved the same day. Read the sample booklet, then decide.
Get My Empire Home QuoteOr call +1-888-462-3382