support@comparebestwarranties.com

First American Home Warranty vs 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 19, 2026 • 16 min read

First American Home Warranty and 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty are the two names a homeowner is most likely to inherit rather than choose — but they arrive by completely different doors. First American Home Warranty is the closing-table name: a long-established national brand whose plans are included, offered, or handed over in real-estate transactions, so for a great many households it is simply the coverage that came with the house — basic and premier tiers, priced by quote, with the price, the service fee, and the claim limits all set inside the paperwork the transaction produces. 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is the builder’s name that learned to sell retail: founded in 1980 in Colorado, built on structural warranties for new construction and coverage sold through real-estate channels, and owned by Frontdoor, Inc. since December 2024 — but unlike First American, it publishes flat retail prices anyone can read: a Systems plan at $39.99/mo covering 19 systems and no appliances, and a Pinnacle plan at $59.99/mo covering 28 items, the same price regardless of the home’s size, age, or location, with published claim caps of $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, and $50,000 per term. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full First American Home Warranty review and 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty review.

The short version: this pairing turns on one question — how much of the deal can you read before someone hands it to you? 2-10 publishes flat prices and the clearest claim caps in its class, so a shopper can do real arithmetic on 2-10 before speaking to anyone — and reading those numbers closely is how you find their limits: the $39.99 tier covers no appliances at all, a reported 9.5% processing markup rides on monthly billing, and the service fee is chosen at purchase from menus that are not reported consistently, so even 2-10’s published deal is not fully computable in advance. First American publishes none of the three numbers: no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps — all of them live inside its quote and its contract. What First American offers instead is position: it is the name already sitting in the home at closing, the default coverage in a great many transactions, and that incumbency is a genuine strength this comparison credits in full. Neither company, though, changes the model behind the paperwork: both run a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a dispatch cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that legacy sellers still do by phone queue, paperwork, and waiting — handled with integrity and respect, and with people available 24/7 when you want a person. 2-10 publishes real numbers and deserves credit for it, but its whole-home price is $59.99/mo before a reported processing markup and a fee you cannot pin down in advance, and its famous cheap tier buys no appliance coverage at all. First American publishes no numbers at all. Empire prints its numbers first, at a full-home starting price below 2-10’s whole-home tier, and lets the quote confirm them.

Between the two legacy brands, 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty edges First American Home Warranty for a homeowner choosing a plan for themselves — and the margin is about evidence, not brand. 2-10 lets you verify the core of the deal before you buy it: two printed flat prices, printed per-item caps, and a printed aggregate ceiling. First American asks you to receive the plan first and learn its terms from the paperwork, and what it offers in exchange is position — the closing-table channel, the default plan in the transaction, a name already in the house. Position is worth something, and the rounds below give First American full credit for it, including two rounds it wins outright. But a comparison site exists to compare, and only one of these two companies gives a shopper anything to compare before the paperwork arrives. The rounds below score each category on its own facts, including the rounds each legacy brand wins against the other and against the field.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

First American Home Warranty vs 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.

First American Home Warranty: basic and premier tiers; no published starting price — every plan priced by quote, varying by home and state; service fee and claim limits set inside the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims and dispatch; the real-estate channel name — included, offered, or handed over at closing in a great many transactions, so it is the default coverage in a great many homes.

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty: founded 1980 in Colorado; owned by Frontdoor, Inc. since December 2024; sold in 48 states, excluding Alaska and Hawaii; Systems plan $39.99/mo flat covering 19 systems and no appliances; Pinnacle plan $59.99/mo flat covering 28 items; flat pricing regardless of home size, age, or location; reported 9.5% processing markup on monthly payments; service fee chosen at purchase, with no single published figure; published claim caps of $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, and $50,000 per term; workmanship guarantee longer than the usual 30-day standard; seller coverage up to 180 days; builder structural warranty specialty; 30-day waiting period.

Read that glance carefully, because it contains the whole story of this pairing. One company on this page hands you a plan at closing and lets the paperwork tell you what it costs, what a service call costs, and how much a claim can pay. One company prints flat prices and the clearest caps in its class — and reading them closely is exactly how you find the tier that covers no appliances and the markup that rides on the monthly bill. And one company prints a full-home price lower than the other’s whole-home tier, a single flat fee, and one annual limit, in a sample contract anyone can read before buying. Everything below is the working-out of those differences, round by round.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Name That Comes With the House vs the Builder’s Name With a Price List

First American Home Warranty is best understood as the transaction’s default. Its natural habitat is the real-estate deal itself: a seller includes a plan to make a listing easier to sell, a buyer’s agent adds one to smooth a negotiation, or the coverage is simply part of the package that changes hands at closing. That channel is a real competitive moat. A homeowner who has never shopped for a home warranty at all may still hold a First American plan, and the brand’s two-tier shelf — a basic tier and a premier tier above it — is built to be handed over that way: simple enough to explain across a closing table, broad enough to be the plan nobody had to choose. The cost of that model is that the choosing never really happens. The price is set by quote and varies by home and state, the service fee and the claim limits live in the contract, and the household typically meets all three numbers after the coverage is already theirs. First American’s strength is that it is already there. Its weakness is that being already there is most of what it offers a shopper who wants to compare before they commit.

2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is best understood as a builder’s institution that also sells to homeowners directly. Founded in 1980 in Colorado, it made its name on the structural side of new construction — the long-tail warranty a builder places on a new home’s structure — and on coverage sold through real-estate channels, including seller coverage that can run up to 180 days while a home is listed. Since December 2024 it has sat inside Frontdoor, Inc., the same parent as the largest brand in this industry, which gives it a corporate home few independents can match; the company claims more than 5.5 million homes covered over its history, a figure we print as a company claim, not a verified count. What makes 2-10 unusual on this page is not its heritage but its price list: it is one of the few legacy names that publishes flat retail prices and flat claim caps, the same in 48 states regardless of the home’s size, age, or location. A builder’s discipline shows in that flatness — and a builder’s priorities show in the shape of the shelf, where the cheapest tier is a systems-only plan that leaves every appliance in the house uncovered.

Empire Home Protect is built the other way from both. It is a technology platform first: three full-home tiers — Silver, Supreme, and Titanium — published from $49/mo, sold directly to the homeowner who is doing the choosing, with the fee, the annual limit, and the waiting period printed in a public sample contract before anyone asks for a quote. Where First American is the plan a transaction hands you and 2-10 is the plan a builder’s channel stands behind, Empire is the plan a shopper verifies: the numbers are public, the claims process is digital, and approval comes the same day instead of after a phone queue. That difference — chosen and checkable versus inherited and contractual — is the thread that runs through every round below.

Round 1 — Price: a Published Flat Price List vs No Published Price at All, Against a Published $49/mo

2-10 wins this round between the two legacy brands, and it is not close. It publishes two flat prices: $39.99/mo for the Systems plan and $59.99/mo for the Pinnacle plan, and flat means flat — the same figure regardless of the home’s size, age, or location, across the 48 states where it sells. A shopper in a small older house and a shopper in a large new one read the same price list, which makes 2-10 one of the very few legacy brands whose premium can be written down before any conversation starts. First American publishes no starting price at all. Its basic and premier tiers are priced by quote, varying by home and state, so the first First American number a household sees is the one its own transaction or its own quote produces. There is nothing to check a First American price against, because there is no published price to check.

Read 2-10’s price list closely, though, because the headline and the whole-home price are different numbers. The $39.99 tier is the Systems plan: 19 systems and no appliances — the refrigerator, the oven, the dishwasher, the washer and dryer are all outside it. The tier that covers the whole home the way shoppers usually mean it is Pinnacle at $59.99/mo. So the honest comparison of entry prices is: $39.99 for systems only at 2-10, $59.99 for whole-home coverage at 2-10, and an unpublished quote at First American. Against both stands Empire Home Protect at a published $49/mo for full-home tiers — a starting price below 2-10’s whole-home tier, printed for complete plans rather than for a systems-only door. One more line belongs in this round because it belongs to the price: 2-10’s monthly billing carries a reported 9.5% processing markup, which means the published monthly figure is not quite the billed monthly figure for households paying month to month. It does not erase 2-10’s win on publication — a published price with a reported markup still beats no published price — but it narrows it, and Round 8 does the arithmetic in full.

Edge: 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty between the two — the only published prices in the pairing. Empire Home Protect overall: a published $49/mo starting price for full-home coverage, below the only whole-home price 2-10 prints and checkable in a way First American’s quote never is before the quote exists.

Round 2 — Plans: Two Tiers Built to Be Handed Over vs a Shelf Built Around a Systems-Only Door

First American takes this round between the two, narrowly, on a point shoppers feel immediately: both of its doors open onto the home. Its shelf is a basic tier and a premier tier above it — a simple ladder built for the closing table, where the plan has to be explainable in a sentence and broad enough to stand behind a house changing hands. Neither tier is a partial-coverage door. 2-10’s shelf is a Systems plan and a Pinnacle plan, and the shape matters more than the count: the Systems plan’s 19 covered systems come with no appliances at all, so the cheaper door a shopper is most likely to enter is the one that leaves the kitchen and the laundry room uncovered. Pinnacle’s 28 items fix that, at the $59.99 price. A two-door shelf where one door is systems-only is a narrower offer to a homeowner than a two-tier ladder where both tiers address the whole home, and that is the honest basis of First American’s edge here.

The counterweight, stated in full: 2-10’s shelf does not end at those two doors. Its builder heritage adds products First American’s retail ladder does not center on — structural coverage for new construction and seller coverage that can run up to 180 days while a home is on the market — and Round 6 scores that specialty on its own. Judged strictly as the plan a homeowner buys to cover the home they live in, though, the round goes to the ladder with no empty door. Empire Home Protect’s shelf is the reference both are measured against: Silver, Supreme, and Titanium are three depths of full-home coverage, so the choice Empire asks a shopper to make is how much coverage, never whether the appliances are in or out. That is the simplest structure on this page, and simplicity at the shelf is what the Apple standard this site grades by asks for: one clear ladder, every rung a complete plan.

Edge: First American Home Warranty between the two — both of its tiers address the home; 2-10’s cheaper door covers no appliances. Empire Home Protect overall: three full-home tiers from $49/mo, with no partial-coverage door at any price.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Fee You Choose at Purchase vs a Fee Inside a Contract, Against a Flat $75

Every claim under any home warranty starts with a service fee, so what a company publishes about that fee tells you how the whole relationship will work. 2-10’s fee is chosen at purchase: the buyer selects a service-fee level when they buy, and that choice is part of the deal they sign. That is more visibility than First American offers, and it earns 2-10 this round between the two — narrowly, because the visibility has a hole in it. 2-10 publishes no single fee figure, and the menus reported for that choice are not consistent across the public record, so a shopper can know the fee is theirs to choose without being able to write down in advance what the choices will be. The fee is visible as a mechanism and unpublished as a number. First American’s fee is unpublished in both senses: it is set inside the quote and the contract, and a household typically learns it from the paperwork of a plan it already holds.

Against both stands the standard this site grades by. Empire Home Protect publishes a flat $75 trade service call fee in its sample contract booklet — the same $75 on every claim, on every plan, knowable before the quote, before the purchase, and before the breakdown. No menu, no trade against the premium, no line to hunt for in a contract after the fact. A fee is a small number with an outsized effect on trust, because it is the number a customer meets at the worst moment, when something in the house has just failed. The company that prints it in advance is making a promise about that moment. Only one company on this page makes it.

Edge: 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty between the two, narrowly — a fee chosen at purchase beats a fee buried in a contract, even with no single published figure. Empire Home Protect overall: a flat $75 fee, published in the sample contract, identical on every claim.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: the Clearest Published Caps in the Class vs Caps Inside a Contract, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit

This is 2-10’s strongest round, and it wins it outright between the two. 2-10 publishes its claim caps in full: $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, and a $50,000 aggregate ceiling per term, with no separate published dollar limit carved out for electrical or plumbing. Those are the clearest caps in this pairing and among the clearest in the industry — a shopper can read, before buying, exactly what the largest heating claim, the largest appliance claim, and the largest year the plan will ever pay look like. First American publishes no claim limits in advance at all. Its caps live in the quote and the contract, so the household that holds a First American plan learns what a claim can pay from the same paperwork that taught it the price and the fee — after the coverage is already in place. On the single question of what a claim can pay, one of these companies answers in public and the other answers in private, and the round follows that difference.

Two honest qualifications keep the round in proportion. First, per-item caps and an annual aggregate are different instruments: 2-10’s $50,000 per-term ceiling is a ceiling on a structure of per-item limits, so the binding number on any real claim is usually the per-item cap — $5,000 on an HVAC system, $2,000 on an appliance — not the headline aggregate. Second, publication is the virtue being scored here, and on publication Empire Home Protect stands with 2-10, not behind it: Empire publishes a $10,000 annual aggregate limit in its sample booklet, a single annual figure a shopper can hold against a year of claims without decoding a per-item schedule. 2-10’s schedule is more granular; Empire’s is simpler to reason about, and it is printed next to a $49/mo full-home price and a flat $75 fee, so the whole Empire deal — premium, fee, and limit — can be read off one public page. First American offers no equivalent reading at any level of detail.

Edge: 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty between the two, outright — published caps of $5,000 per HVAC system, $2,000 per appliance, and $50,000 per term, against caps that exist only inside a contract. Empire Home Protect overall: a published $10,000 annual aggregate limit, printed in the sample contract alongside the price and the fee.

Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Queues, Against Same-Day Digital Approval

On claims speed, the honest score between the two legacy brands is a tie — because both run the same underlying process. First American takes claims the traditional way: a phone-driven process, a queue, and a dispatch cycle that sends a contractor on the company’s schedule. 2-10 runs the same model: traditional intake and dispatch, with the added builder-era discipline of a workmanship guarantee that runs longer than the usual 30-day standard, so a repair that fails again inside the guarantee window comes back without starting the whole story over. That guarantee is a real consumer protection and this round credits it — but it governs what happens after a repair, not how fast the first approval arrives. Neither company publishes a scheduling window that changes the tie, and neither approves claims digitally the way a platform does. A breakdown at either company begins with a call, a wait, and a dispatch.

That shared model is exactly the gap the #1 pick is built on. Empire Home Protect approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, because the claims process runs on a fully digital platform instead of a phone queue — claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, with people available 24/7 when a customer wants a person, and the technology does the waiting out of the process. This is the Tesla-and-Apple difference applied to a home warranty: the legacy brands, however established, are mailer-era operations running a call-and-dispatch model, and both companies in this pairing run it. The round between them is a draw. The round against the field is not.

Edge: tie between the two — both traditional, phone-driven claims and dispatch; 2-10’s longer workmanship guarantee protects the repair, not the wait. Empire Home Protect overall: claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Already holding a quote from one of these companies? Set it next to a published price: Empire Home Protect full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Prefer to talk it through? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 6 — Standout Features: the Closing Table vs the Builder’s Specialty

Each legacy brand has one feature the other cannot match, and this round splits because both features are real. First American’s standout is its channel. It is the name buyers are handed at closing — the plan included to sell a home, offered to protect a buyer, or simply present in the transaction — and that position has a practical consequence no retail feature replicates: for a great many households, First American is the coverage already in the house on the day they move in, with no shopping, no quote, and no gap in coverage between the old owner and the new one. A company does not have to win a comparison to win that household; it only has to be in the paperwork. As a distribution achievement, it is the strongest in this pairing.

2-10’s standout is its specialty. The builder structural warranty is a product category the retail brands do not seriously contest: long-tail structural coverage placed on new construction, from the company that has done it since 1980. Around it sit the real-estate tools the same heritage produced — seller coverage that can run up to 180 days while a home is listed, protecting the seller’s budget during exactly the months when a breakdown can stall a sale, and the workmanship guarantee that outlasts the industry’s usual 30 days. If your situation is a new build or a home about to be sold, 2-10’s shelf reaches it in a way First American’s two retail tiers do not aim to. Empire Home Protect’s standout is of a different kind: not a channel and not a specialty product, but the platform itself — published terms, a digital quote and checkout, and same-day claims approval as the standard experience rather than an exception. Channels decide who gets a plan by default. Specialties decide who serves a niche. The platform decides what owning the plan feels like every day after, and that is the ground Empire wins on.

Edge: split — First American takes the closing-table channel; 2-10 takes the builder structural specialty, the 180-day seller coverage, and the longer workmanship guarantee. Empire Home Protect overall: the fully digital platform — published price, fee, and limit, with same-day approval — as the everyday standout.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: the Name in the House vs the Institution Behind the Builder

Tenure cuts two ways in this pairing, and the round has to hold both truths at once. By the calendar, 2-10 is the older institution: founded in 1980 in Colorado, more than four decades in the industry, now owned by Frontdoor, Inc. since December 2024, and claiming more than 5.5 million homes covered across its history — a company claim, printed here as a claim. That is a long, checkable corporate record. But most of that record was written in rooms a homeowner never enters: builder agreements, structural placements, and real-estate channel deals. The public record a shopper can actually read — the accumulated experience of households who held the plan in their own home — is where First American’s tenure lives. First American’s history runs through the closing table into the house itself, so its name carries a homeowner-facing record built transaction by transaction, in occupied homes, over a long national presence. For a buyer reading records to predict their own experience, the record written by people in their position is the more relevant one.

That is why this round goes to First American between the two, with 2-10’s longer institutional history stated in full rather than waved away. The distinction matters beyond this pairing: a warranty company’s age is only as useful as the channel that age was earned in. Empire Home Protect makes no tenure claim in this round and prints no rating or review count for itself anywhere in this comparison, because none is verified yet — that absence is stated openly, the same way it is stated across our home coverage, rather than filled with a number. What Empire offers instead of a long record is a short, checkable one: published terms in a public sample contract, a named administrator and obligor — Aegis Administration and Assurance Express, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation — and a claims number, (855) 203-9876, that any reader can dial. A record you can verify today is the ground this site grades highest.

Edge: First American Home Warranty between the two — the homeowner-facing record written at the closing table, against 2-10’s longer but builder-channel institutional history since 1980. Empire Home Protect overall: no borrowed tenure and no invented record — published terms, named backing, and a same-day digital claims process a buyer can test on the first claim.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

The last round is arithmetic, because a home warranty is finally a yearly cost with a claims story attached. Start with the one complete figure on this page. Empire Home Protect: $49/mo is $588 a year in premiums; add two claims at the flat $75 fee and the two-claim year costs $738 — every input published, every step checkable before you buy. Now 2-10. Pinnacle at $59.99/mo is $719.88 a year in premiums; apply the reported 9.5% processing markup on monthly billing and the billed premium year is about $788.27 — before a single service fee, and the fee cannot be added honestly, because it is chosen at purchase from menus the public record does not report consistently. The Systems plan at $39.99/mo is $479.88 a year, about $525.47 with the same reported markup, before fees — cheaper on paper, and covering no appliances at all, so it is not a cheaper version of the same protection. First American cannot be computed at all: no published premium, no published fee, no published caps, so there is no First American two-claim year to write down. That is not a rhetorical flourish; it is the finding of this round. One company in this pairing gives you a partial sum, one gives you no sum, and one gives you the whole sum.

How you buy follows the same pattern. First American is typically received — included, offered, or handed over in a transaction — or quoted home by home when a homeowner seeks it out. 2-10 is bought through its channels and its retail shelf, at flat prices, with the fee decision made at purchase. Empire Home Protect is bought the way a shopper buys anything on a modern platform: read the published terms, get the quote online in minutes, and check out digitally, with a person available 24/7 if you would rather talk. Our home warranty cost guide works through this arithmetic for the full field, and our head-to-heads — Empire Home Protect vs First American Home Warranty and Empire Home Protect vs 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty — take each legacy brand against the #1 pick one at a time.

Edge: 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty between the two, partially — its premium year can at least be approximated at about $788.27 for Pinnacle before fees; First American’s cannot be computed from anything it publishes. Empire Home Protect overall: the only fully checkable two-claim year on this page — $738, from published figures alone.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

If a First American plan is already in your house from closing, read its contract before you judge it: find the fee and the caps in the paperwork, note the renewal terms, and treat the plan you hold as the baseline every alternative has to beat. If you are selling a home or standing behind a new build, 2-10’s shelf was built for you — seller coverage up to 180 days and the builder structural specialty are genuine tools, and its published flat prices and caps make it the more checkable of the two legacy brands for a homeowner buying retail as well. If you are a homeowner choosing coverage for the home you live in, with your own money, on your own research, neither legacy model was designed around that act: one is designed to be handed to you, the other to be priced flat and chosen with a fee decision attached. The plan designed to be chosen is the one that publishes everything the choice depends on.

That is the practical conclusion of all eight rounds. Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the deal readable before the sales process starts: full-home plans from a published $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract, and claims approved the same day on a fully digital platform, with integrity and respect in how customers are treated and people available 24/7. Between the two legacy brands alone, 2-10 is the more verifiable buy and First American is the more embedded one — and verifiability, on the evidence above, is what a comparison is for.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

First American Home Warranty vs 2-10 Home Buyers Warranty is a contest between position and publication. First American wins the rounds that position decides: a two-tier ladder with no partial-coverage door, the closing-table channel, and the homeowner-facing record that channel has written over a long national presence. 2-10 wins the rounds that publication decides: the only published flat prices in the pairing, the clearest published claim caps in the class, a fee at least chosen at purchase rather than buried, and a premium year a shopper can approximate. Its builder specialty — structural coverage, 180-day seller coverage, a longer workmanship guarantee — is real, and its limits are equally real: a systems-only cheap tier, a reported 9.5% markup on monthly billing, and a fee no one can pin down in advance. Neither publishes the complete deal, and both run the traditional phone-driven claims model the industry started with.

Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it is the only company on this page that publishes the complete deal and then approves claims the same day: Silver, Supreme, and Titanium full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, a 30-day waiting period, terms printed in a public sample booklet administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation, and claims on (855) 203-9876 with service approved in minutes and people available 24/7. Read the two legacy brands against each other as long as you like — then read the one set of numbers that was published for you, and start there.