support@comparebestwarranties.com

Cinch Home Services vs Select Home Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 20, 2026 • 16 min read

Cinch Home Services and Select Home Warranty sit at opposite ends of the same old question: how much of a home warranty can you read before you buy it? Cinch Home Services is the current brand of a home-service-contract business with roots in the Sears home-services operation, one of the original names in American home warranties, sold in 48 states: three tiers in most states — Repair Only, Repair + Replace, and Repair + Replace Premier — with no single published national price, but with its fine print in the open: a service fee you choose at $100, $125, or $150 per visit, published per-item caps of $1,000 on Repair Only and $2,000 on the replacement tiers, category caps of $1,500 for HVAC and $1,000 for plumbing, and a 180-day workmanship guarantee on covered repairs. Select Home Warranty is the quote shoppers collect on purpose: a national brand that sells directly to homeowners in the industry’s standard three-part structure — a systems plan, an appliances plan, and a combined plan that covers both — priced entirely by quote, with no published starting price, no published service fee, and no published claim caps, so every number that decides its value exists only inside its quote and its contract. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Cinch Home Services review and Select Home Warranty review.

The short version: this pairing is decided by publication, and it is not close. Cinch publishes its fine print and hides its price: its caps, its fee menu, and its category limits are all in print for anyone to read, but there is no single national price — published samples for the same tiers swing from $24.99/mo for Repair Only to $131.99/mo for Premier in a high-cost ZIP code, so the number that decides what you pay still exists only inside your own quote. Select publishes neither: no price, no fee, and no caps — a shopper cannot verify a single term of a Select plan before starting the sales process, and cannot total its cost even in principle. Behind both habits sits the same old model: a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a dispatch cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo — with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder of full-home plans, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. The booklet is administered by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims are filed on (855) 203-9876, and people are available 24/7. Terms vary by plan, administrator, and state, and the sample booklet is public precisely so you can read them before you buy. No other company on this page publishes its whole deal — price, fee, and limit — in one place, and no other company on this page approves claims the same day.

Between the two challengers, Cinch Home Services wins the head-to-head clearly for a homeowner choosing coverage for the home they live in: it is the only one of the two whose terms can be checked before the sales process starts. Its fee menu is published ($100, $125, or $150), its per-item and category caps are published ($2,000 per item on the replacement tiers, $1,500 for HVAC, $1,000 for plumbing, $10,000 in aggregate per term), it publishes a claims response window running up to 48 hours, and it carries the longest workmanship guarantee we compare, 180 days, plus coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions. Select Home Warranty keeps one genuine strength, and the rounds below give it full credit: it is the reference quote of this industry, the familiar three-part shelf shoppers collect to learn what the market charges, and its public record was written by homeowners who chose it directly. A homeowner who simply wants that familiar benchmark quote will still collect one. But familiarity is not a term you can verify, and a comparison site exists to compare: on every checkable term in this pairing, Cinch puts something in print and Select puts nothing. Both, on the evidence below, land behind the #1 pick.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Cinch Home Services vs Select Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims on (855) 203-9876; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7.

Cinch Home Services: roots in the Sears home-services operation; sold in 48 states, excluding Alaska and Hawaii; plans in most states are Repair Only, Repair + Replace, and Repair + Replace Premier (in California: Appliances, Built-In Systems, Complete Home); no single published national price — a published March 2026 sample for a 2,500 sq ft home in Fairfax, Virginia, at a $150 service fee, started at $24.99/mo for Repair Only, $49.99/mo for Repair + Replace, and $72.99/mo for Premier, with other published samples running to $131.99/mo for Premier in high-cost ZIP codes; service fee chosen at purchase at $100, $125, or $150 per visit, with a lower fee raising the monthly price by roughly $10–$12/mo in published samples; published caps of $1,000 per item on Repair Only and $2,000 per item on the replacement tiers, with category caps of $1,500 for HVAC, $1,000 for plumbing, and $2,000 for kitchen and laundry appliances, refrigerant covered at $10 per pound, and a $10,000 aggregate limit per agreement term; 180-day workmanship guarantee on covered repairs; coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions and rust and corrosion; up to $500 a year of homeowners insurance deductible reimbursement on the replacement tiers; traditional claims with published response windows running up to 48 hours; 30-day waiting period.

Select Home Warranty: systems plan, appliances plan, and combined plan in the industry’s standard three-part structure; no published starting price — every plan priced by quote; service fee and claim caps set inside the quote and contract, with no published figures; traditional phone-driven claims and dispatch, with no published response or scheduling window; sells directly to homeowners, and is the quote shoppers most often collect as their comparison point.

Read that glance carefully, because it contains the whole story of this pairing. One company prints every ceiling in its contract and then prices the contract behind a quote wall, ZIP by ZIP. One company prints nothing at all — not the price, not the fee, not a single cap — and asks you to learn all three inside a sales conversation. And one company prints a full-home price lower than either legacy brand’s checkable whole-home numbers, a single flat fee, and one annual limit, in a sample contract anyone can read before buying. Everything below is the working-out of those differences, round by round.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Sears Heir vs the Reference Quote

Cinch Home Services is best understood as the heir to the original home warranty business. Its roots sit in the Sears home-services operation — the department-store service empire that taught American homeowners to buy protection for appliances and systems alongside the appliances themselves — and that heritage shows in the shape of the modern company: a real national contractor network across 48 states, published plan documents, and a shelf built for the real-estate transaction as much as for the direct shopper. The strengths are genuinely Sears-like in the good sense: substance features a careful buyer can verify, above all a 180-day workmanship guarantee on covered repairs that no rival we compare matches, coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions and for rust and corrosion that many contracts exclude, and up to $500 a year of homeowners insurance deductible reimbursement on its two replacement tiers. The costs are Sears-like in the other sense: the model is the legacy one, priced by quote, with a fee on every visit, a cap on every category, and a dispatch queue between the homeowner and the repair. Cinch is the old-school model done competently — and the old-school model is still the thing being scored.

Select Home Warranty is best understood as the market’s reference quote. Its shelf is the structure the whole industry teaches shoppers to expect: one plan for the home’s systems — heating, cooling, electrical, plumbing and the other built-in machinery a house runs on; one plan for the appliances — the refrigerator, oven, dishwasher, washer and dryer class of equipment; and one combined plan that covers both. A homeowner who has done even an hour of research has usually seen that three-part shape, and Select is the name most likely to be holding it when the quotes come back. That familiarity is a genuine asset: when you collect a Select quote, you know exactly which door you are standing in front of, and you can line its systems-only and appliances-only doors up against the rest of the field. What familiarity does not give you is a number. Select publishes no starting price, so the reference quote still has to be collected home by home, and the fee and the caps that decide what the plan is worth wait inside the paperwork the quote produces. Select shows you the shape of the market. It does not show you its own deal.

Empire Home Protect was built the other way around: a technology platform first, with the paperwork published to match. Where Cinch asks you to request a quote to learn your price and Select asks you to request a quote to learn anything at all, Empire publishes three full-home tiers from $49/mo, one flat $75 fee, and one $10,000 annual limit, then runs claims digitally so approval comes the same day and service is approved in minutes instead of joining a phone queue. The Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder starts at $49/mo for full-home coverage, the trade service call fee is $75 every time, and the aggregate limit is $10,000 a year, all from the Comprehensive sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), with terms that vary by plan, administrator and state. That is the standard this head-to-head is scored against: not which legacy brand has the better brochure, but which company lets you verify the deal before you are in it.

Round 1 — Price: Published Samples vs No Published Price at All, Against a Published $49/mo

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Cinch Home Services.

Price is the round shoppers want decided first, and in this pairing it can only be half-decided between the two legacy brands, because only one of them lets a price be checked at all. Cinch publishes no single national price — that limit is real, and this comparison does not soften it. What Cinch does publish is samples a shopper can work from: for a 2,500 sq ft home in Fairfax, Virginia, at a $150 service fee, a published March 2026 sample started at $24.99/mo for Repair Only, $49.99/mo for Repair + Replace, and $72.99/mo for Repair + Replace Premier, while other published samples for the same company run to $131.99/mo for Premier in a high-cost ZIP code. That is a wide, ZIP-dependent range, and your own quote can land anywhere inside it. But it is a range in print: a shopper can see the shape of Cinch pricing, can see that the cheapest tier is repair-only, and can see what the replacement tiers cost in a real sample home before speaking to anyone.

Select publishes no range, no sample, and no starting price. Its systems, appliances, and combined plans are priced by quote: the number for your home depends on the home, the state, and the plan shape, and it exists only after you ask. A published sample range against no published price is not a close round between the two — any article that declares Select “cheaper” than Cinch is inventing the Select figure it is standing on, and we do not print invented figures. What can be said honestly is what the checkable numbers actually buy. Cinch’s lowest sampled number, $24.99/mo, buys repair only — if the item cannot be repaired, that tier does not replace it. The sampled Cinch tier that matches whole-home replacement coverage, Repair + Replace, starts at $49.99/mo in the Fairfax sample. Empire Home Protect publishes full-home plans from $49/mo: its starting price is a whole-home price, at or below the sampled replacement-tier starting point, and it is a single national starting point rather than a sample that moves by ZIP code. That is what a published price does to the shopping itself: it turns the first question — what does this cost? — from a sales conversation into a fact you already have.

Round 1 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins the round outright, with the only single published full-home starting price on the page. Between the two legacy brands, Cinch wins on evidence: samples in print, however ZIP-dependent, beat no price in print at all. Select cannot win a price round it declines to enter.

Round 2 — Plans: a Repair-vs-Replace Ladder vs the Standard Three-Part Shelf

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Cinch Home Services.

Both legacy shelves have three doors, but the doors mean different things. Cinch’s ladder is organised by what happens when something breaks. Repair Only is the narrow door: the plan pays to repair covered items, with a $1,000 per-item cap, and does not replace them. Repair + Replace is the standard whole-home door most buyers mean when they say home warranty. Repair + Replace Premier is the wide door, adding extras that include outside water, sewer, and gas lines. In California the same company sells the shelf under different names — Appliances, Built-In Systems, and Complete Home — which is worth knowing before comparing a California quote against a national sample. The ladder forces a real decision at purchase, and the decision matters: a homeowner who buys the cheap repair-only door and later needs a replacement owns the difference.

Select’s shelf is organised by what breaks, not by what happens next: a systems plan, an appliances plan, and a combined plan covering both. That is the industry’s standard three-part structure, and its virtue is legibility — a shopper who has seen any home warranty shelf recognises it instantly, which is exactly why Select functions as the market’s reference quote. Its limit is that the structure is all a shopper can see: the three doors are labelled, but nothing behind any of them — not the price, not the fee, not the caps — is published. Cinch’s shelf asks more of the buyer and tells the buyer more: the repair-versus-replace distinction is printed on the door itself, with the caps that enforce it published alongside. For a resident homeowner choosing coverage to live under, the ladder that shows its own consequences is the stronger shelf. Empire’s Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder is simpler than both: three full-home tiers, differentiated by coverage level rather than by a repair-only trap door or a systems-versus-appliances split, starting from a published $49/mo.

Round 2 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins on simplicity and publication — three full-home tiers, one published starting price. Between the two, Cinch wins narrowly: its tiers differ in a way that is printed and consequential, while Select’s familiar three-part shape is a label without published terms behind it.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Published Fee Menu vs a Fee With No Published Figure, Against a Flat $75

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Cinch Home Services, outright.

The service fee is the price of using the plan, and it is charged on every claim, so it deserves the same scrutiny as the premium. Cinch publishes its menu: at purchase, the buyer chooses a fee of $100, $125, or $150 per visit, and published samples show the trade-off plainly — choosing a lower fee raises the monthly price by roughly $10–$12/mo. That is a real dial, honestly labelled: pay more per month to pay less per visit, or the reverse. A shopper can price both ends of the dial before buying, and can see that even Cinch’s lowest fee, $100, is a three-figure charge on every single claim.

Select publishes no fee figure at all. Its service fee is set inside the quote and the contract, so a homeowner cannot learn what a claim will cost to open until the sales process produces paperwork — and cannot compare Select’s fee against any rival’s fee before that moment. In a round scored on published facts, a published menu beats an unpublished fee outright; there is nothing on the Select side of the scale to weigh. Empire Home Protect publishes a flat $75 trade service call fee in its sample booklet: one figure, the same on every claim, with no dial to set and no premium trade-off attached — and $25 below Cinch’s lowest menu option. On a two-claim year, that difference alone is $50 against Cinch’s cheapest fee setting and $150 against its most expensive, before premiums are counted at all.

Round 3 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins outright — a flat, published $75, lower than every option on the only other published menu in the pairing. Between the two, Cinch wins outright: a $100–$150 menu in print beats a fee that exists only inside a quote.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: Published Caps, Read Closely, vs Caps With No Published Figures, Against a $10,000 Annual Limit

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Cinch Home Services, outright.

Caps decide what a plan is worth on its worst day, and Cinch is the only legacy brand in this pairing that publishes its own. Read them closely, because reading them is the point. Repair Only caps each item at $1,000. The replacement tiers cap each item at $2,000. Category caps sit underneath: $1,500 for HVAC, $1,000 for plumbing, $2,000 for kitchen and laundry appliances, with refrigerant covered at $10 per pound, and a $10,000 aggregate limit per agreement term over everything. Those are thin ceilings where failures cost most — a full HVAC replacement runs well past a $1,500 category cap in most markets, so the homeowner owns the difference — and this comparison prints them at full strength, because a published thin cap is still more useful to a buyer than no cap information at all: you can plan around a ceiling you can see.

Select publishes no caps. Its claim limits live inside its quote and its contract, so there is no published per-item figure, no published category figure, and no published aggregate for a shopper to weigh before buying. Select’s caps may be generous or thin; on the public record, there is no honest way to say, and any comparison that assigns Select a cap figure is inventing it. A round about limits can only be won with limits that exist in print. Empire Home Protect publishes one clear figure in its sample booklet: a $10,000 annual aggregate limit. It is a different shape from Cinch’s per-item maze — one annual ceiling a homeowner can track, rather than a stack of per-item and per-category ceilings that can exhaust a claim long before the aggregate is reached — and it is published in the same public document as the price and the fee.

Round 4 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins on clarity: one published $10,000 annual limit, readable in the sample contract before purchase. Between the two, Cinch wins outright — its caps are thin, above all the $1,500 HVAC ceiling, but they are published and therefore plannable; Select publishes no limit a buyer can plan around at all.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Already holding a quote from one of these companies? Set it next to a published price: Empire Home Protect full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit. Prefer to talk it through? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 5 — Claims Speed: a Published Response Window vs a Traditional Queue, Against Same-Day Digital Approval

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Cinch Home Services, narrowly.

Both legacy brands run the traditional model: you file by phone, the claim joins a queue, a contractor is dispatched, and the repair waits on that cycle. Within that shared model, Cinch publishes one thing Select does not: a response window, with published response times running up to 48 hours. A published window is not speed — 48 hours is the outer edge of a promise to respond, not a promise to repair — but it is a commitment a homeowner can hold the company to, printed before purchase. Select publishes no equivalent response or scheduling window, so its claims timeline exists only as whatever the queue produces on the day. Between two traditional processes, the one that prints its window wins the round, narrowly, on evidence rather than performance.

The larger fact of this round is the gap between both legacy processes and the #1 pick. Empire Home Protect approves claims the same day on a fully digital platform, with service approved in minutes: the claim is filed digitally, on (855) 203-9876 with people available 24/7, and approval does not wait on a phone queue and a dispatch cycle to begin. Same-day approval against a published window of up to 48 hours just to respond is not a marginal difference in process — it is the difference between the technology platform and the legacy model both of these brands still run, one of them with its window in print and one of them without.

Round 5 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins outright — same-day digital approval, service in minutes. Between the two, Cinch wins narrowly: a published response window running up to 48 hours is a checkable commitment, and Select publishes no window at all.

Round 6 — Standout Features: the 180-Day Guarantee and the Open Door vs the Reference Quote

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Cinch Home Services.

Cinch’s standouts are aimed at the resident homeowner, and they are substantial. The first is the 180-day workmanship guarantee on covered repairs — the longest we compare, six times the industry’s usual 30 days — which means a repair that fails again inside half a year comes back on the plan, not on the homeowner. The second is the open door on condition: coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions and for rust and corrosion, two of the most common reasons traditional contracts give for denying a claim. The third sits on the replacement tiers: up to $500 a year of homeowners insurance deductible reimbursement, and, on Premier, coverage reaching outside the house to water, sewer, and gas lines. For a homeowner buying coverage on an older home whose history they do not fully know, that package is worth real money, and every element of it is published.

Select’s standout is of a different kind: not a guarantee, a coverage door, or a reimbursement, but a position. Select is the quote the market collects — the familiar three-part shelf in the familiar shape, sold directly to homeowners, against which shoppers measure the rest of the field. That position has genuine utility while you are shopping: a Select quote teaches you what questions the industry asks about your home. It has no utility after you buy: it does not lengthen a guarantee, open a coverage door, or reimburse a dollar. A standout that helps you shop is worth less than standouts that help you claim, and on published features this round is one-sided. Empire Home Protect’s standout is neither a guarantee nor a market position — it is the platform itself: published terms in a public sample contract and same-day digital approval, which serves the resident at the exact moment every other feature on this page has already done its work or failed to.

Round 6 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins on the platform. Between the two, Cinch wins clearly: a 180-day guarantee, pre-existing-condition coverage, and deductible reimbursement are features a homeowner can use; being the market’s reference quote is a feature a shopper can use once, before buying something else.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Heritage Brand Under a New Name vs the Homeowner’s Own Record

Winner: Empire Home Protect. Between the two: Select Home Warranty.

This is the one round Select wins between the two, and it wins it on the nature of its record rather than its length. Cinch’s lineage is longer: its roots run back into the Sears home-services operation, one of the founding businesses of this industry. But lineage is not the same as a record under one name, held by homeowners who chose the company for their own homes. Much of Cinch’s history was written inside other people’s transactions — plans placed through real-estate deals and retail channels, under predecessor branding — and the modern Cinch name itself is the newest layer on that history. A homeowner reading Cinch’s record is reading an inheritance as much as a track record.

Select’s record was written the other way: by homeowners who sought the company out, collected its quote on purpose, and bought directly. That is the record a direct buyer is actually joining, and it matches how Select is used across the market — as the homeowner-facing benchmark, the name whose quote sits on the kitchen table while the field is compared. Empire Home Protect does not win this round on tenure, and this comparison does not pretend otherwise; it wins the comparison on published terms and claims speed, the things a buyer can verify today rather than inherit from yesterday. But between the two legacy brands, the record that belongs to homeowners themselves outweighs the longer lineage that arrived through transactions and predecessor names.

Round 7 verdict: Select Home Warranty wins the round between the two — its public record was written by homeowners who chose it directly, which is the record a new direct buyer joins. Cinch’s Sears-rooted lineage is older, but older is not the same as clearer, and neither legacy record changes the #1 pick, which is decided on terms a buyer can check now.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

Winner: Empire Home Protect, outright.

End every comparison with arithmetic, because arithmetic is where publication either pays or does not. Take a normal two-claim year — twelve months of premiums plus two service fees — and total each company as far as its published figures allow. Empire Home Protect is the only company on this page whose year can be totalled exactly before purchase: $49/mo across twelve months is $588 in premiums, plus two flat $75 service fees is $150, for a two-claim year of $738 — checkable in seconds, from published figures, in a public sample contract. Cinch can be totalled for a sample home, and only for a sample home: at the published Fairfax sample, Repair + Replace at $49.99/mo is $599.88 in premiums, plus two visits at the $150 fee setting used in that sample is $300, for a sampled two-claim year of $899.88; the Premier sample at $72.99/mo totals $875.88 in premiums plus $300 in fees, $1,175.88; and the Repair Only sample totals $599.88 all-in but buys no replacement if a repair fails. Choose Cinch’s $100 fee instead and the premium rises by roughly $10–$12/mo in published samples, which claws back most of the fee saving across a year — the dial gives with one hand and takes with the other.

Select cannot be totalled at all. No published premium, no published fee: the two-claim year for a Select plan is a blank until a quote fills it, home by home. That blank is the finding of this round, and in a way of the whole comparison. A homeowner can hold Empire’s $738 and Cinch’s sampled $899.88 side by side and argue about the difference; there is nothing to hold on the Select side. How you buy follows the same pattern. Both legacy brands sell through a quote process that produces their numbers privately; Empire publishes its starting price, its fee, and its limit first, and lets the online quote confirm them — no sales call required to learn what the deal is.

Round 8 verdict: Empire Home Protect wins outright — the only exactly computable two-claim year on the page, $738, from figures published before purchase. Between the two, Cinch’s sampled $899.88 replacement-tier year can at least be computed for a sample home; Select’s year cannot be computed at all, and a cost that cannot be checked cannot win a cost round.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Choose Cinch Home Services if you are set on choosing between these two legacy brands and you value published fine print over a published price: you want the fee menu, the per-item and category caps, and the response window in print before you buy, you want the 180-day workmanship guarantee and coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions on an older home, and you accept that your premium will be set by quote and ZIP code, that the HVAC category cap is $1,500, and that even the lowest fee setting costs $100 a visit. Go in having read the caps, not just the samples.

Choose Select Home Warranty if what you actually want is the market’s benchmark: the familiar systems / appliances / combined shelf, quoted for your home, from the name other shoppers collect first. Collect the quote — it is genuinely useful for learning your home’s price shape. But read the contract it produces for the fee and the caps before you sign, because nothing about Select’s deal can be verified before that paperwork exists, and the quote’s familiarity is not itself a term.

Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the complete deal published before you buy and the claim approved the day you file it: full-home Silver, Supreme, and Titanium plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit in a public sample contract, and same-day digital approval with service in minutes and people available 24/7. That is most homeowners, most of the time — which is why it is our #1 pick, and why every quote button on this page points to it.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Empire Home Protect: published plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and claims approved the same day. Get the quote online in minutes, or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

Cinch Home Services vs Select Home Warranty is a contest between fine print in the open and no print at all. Cinch wins the rounds that publication decides: sampled prices in print against no price in print, a differentiated repair-versus-replace ladder, the only published service-fee menu in the pairing, the only published claim caps in the pairing, the only published claims response window, and a standout package — 180-day guarantee, pre-existing-condition coverage, deductible reimbursement — that a resident homeowner can actually use. Select wins the one round publication cannot decide: its record was written by homeowners who chose it directly, and it remains the quote the market collects first. Neither publishes the complete deal — Cinch prices behind a quote wall that swings by ZIP code and caps the most expensive system in the house at $1,500, and Select publishes nothing a buyer can verify before the sales process starts. Both run the traditional phone-driven claims model the industry started with.

Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it is the only company on this page that publishes the complete deal and then approves claims the same day: Silver, Supreme, and Titanium full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, a 30-day waiting period, terms printed in a public sample booklet administered by Aegis Administration with Assurance Express as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation, and claims on (855) 203-9876 with service approved in minutes and people available 24/7. Read the two legacy brands against each other as long as you like — then read the one set of numbers that was published for you, and start there.