support@comparebestwarranties.com

Cinch Home Services vs First American Home Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 18, 2026 • 16 min read

Cinch Home Services and First American Home Warranty are the two names a homeowner meets when they want a home warranty with a long history behind it — and they represent two genuinely different versions of the old school. Cinch Home Services is the Sears-rooted veteran: a company with roots in the Sears home-services business, selling in 48 states, with three tiers, published sample pricing that still ends in a quote for your own home, and the longest workmanship guarantee we compare — 180 days. First American Home Warranty is the closing-table name: a home warranty sold heavily through real-estate transactions, with a basic tier and a premier tier, where the price, the service fee, and the claim limits for your home are all set in the quote and the contract rather than published where a buyer can read them first. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and channel, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Cinch Home Services review and First American Home Warranty review.

The short version: between the two, it splits cleanly, and not evenly. Cinch wins on transparency — it publishes sample prices, a service-fee menu you choose from, and per-item claim caps you can read before you buy, while First American publishes none of the three — and Cinch wins outright on standout protections, led by that 180-day workmanship guarantee and coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions. First American wins on channel and tenure outright: it is the name embedded in the real-estate closing process, with the longer record in that channel and a public record a buyer can read. But neither runs a modern claims process. Both file, review, and dispatch claims the traditional way, by phone and paperwork cycle, and that is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them: Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes what both of these brands hold back or price around — full-home plans from a published $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its sample contract booklet before you buy — and because its claims are approved the same day on a fully digital platform, with service approved in minutes. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that legacy sellers still do by phone queue, paperwork, and waiting. The company behind the contract is stated in the same booklet a buyer can read first: administered by Aegis Administration, LLC, with Assurance Express, LLC as obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation, and a claims line at (855) 203-9876.

Where does that leave the head-to-head itself? Honestly scored, Cinch Home Services beats First American Home Warranty on most of the rounds a direct buyer can verify before paying. Cinch publishes a sample price range, a fee menu, and a cap schedule; First American publishes none of those three, so a First American buyer cannot check the basic math of the purchase until a quote conversation has already started. Cinch also carries the field’s standout protection package — the 180-day workmanship guarantee, unknown pre-existing condition coverage, and rust and corrosion coverage — which First American does not publish an equivalent for. First American’s win is real but narrow: if your warranty arrives as part of a home purchase, through an agent or a closing package, First American is the name built for that moment, with the tenure and the channel to match. A homeowner buying directly, on their own timeline, gets more verifiable value from Cinch between these two — and more still, on the published numbers, from Empire Home Protect.

One honesty note before the rounds, because it matters to how we rank: we publish no star rating or review count for Empire Home Protect anywhere in this comparison, because no verified review record for it exists yet and we will not invent one. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 here on checkable contract terms — published price, published flat fee, published annual limit, and a stated digital claims process — not on a reputation score nobody can verify. Cinch and First American both have longer public records than Empire Home Protect, and where that record wins a round below, we say so plainly.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your quote online in minutes — full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. No obligation.

Get My Empire Quote

Cinch Home Services vs First American Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; fully digital claims, approved the same day, service approved in minutes; people available 24/7; terms printed in a sample contract booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824) a buyer can read before paying.

Cinch Home Services (winner between the two on transparency and standout protections): Repair Only / Repair + Replace / Premier tiers (California plan names differ); sold in 48 states, excluding Alaska and Hawaii; published samples from $24.99/mo to $131.99/mo depending on tier and ZIP code, with your own price still set by quote; service fee chosen at purchase — $100, $125, or $150 — with a lower fee raising the premium by roughly $10–12/mo; published caps of $1,000 per item on Repair Only and $2,000 per item on the replacement tiers, with HVAC capped at $1,500, plumbing at $1,000, kitchen and laundry appliances at $2,000, and refrigerant covered to $10/lb; $10,000 aggregate per term; 180-day workmanship guarantee; coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions and rust/corrosion; $500/yr deductible reimbursement on the replacement tiers; 30-day waiting period; traditional claims process with dispatch response windows that can run up to 48 hours.

First American Home Warranty (winner between the two on channel and tenure): a basic tier and a premier tier, both combined systems-and-appliances plans; sold heavily through real-estate transactions as well as directly; no published starting price — pricing is by quote, varying by home, state, and tier; service fee and claim caps set in the quote and contract, with no published figures a buyer can check first; traditional phone-driven claims process; the longer record in the real-estate channel, with a public record a buyer can read.

Cinch Home ServicesFirst American Home WarrantyEmpire Home Protect (#1 pick)
Starting priceNo single national price; published samples run $24.99–$131.99/mo depending on tier and ZIP; your own price still arrives by quoteQuote-based; varies by home, state, and tier — no published starting figure we can verify$49/mo, published, for full-home tiers
PlansRepair Only / Repair + Replace / Premier (California names differ)Basic tier and premier (combined) tierSilver / Supreme / Titanium
Service feeYour choice at purchase: $100, $125, or $150 per claim; a lower fee raises the monthly premium by roughly $10–12/moSet in your quote and contract — no published figure we can verify$75 flat per trade service call, published in the sample booklet
Claim limitsPublished: $1,000 per item on Repair Only; $2,000 per item on replacement tiers, with HVAC at $1,500, plumbing at $1,000, kitchen and laundry at $2,000, refrigerant covered to $10/lb; $10,000 aggregate per termSet in your quote and contract — no published caps we can verify$10,000 annual aggregate limit, published in the sample booklet
Claims processTraditional: phone-driven intake, with dispatch response windows that can run up to 48 hoursTraditional: phone-driven, paperwork cycleFully digital; claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes
Standout180-day workmanship guarantee; unknown pre-existing conditions and rust/corrosion covered; $500/yr deductible reimbursement on replacement tiersThe closing-table name in real-estate transactions; the longer record in that channelPublished price, fee, and limit before you buy; fastest claims standard in the field
How you buySample pricing published; final price quoted for your homeQuoted, heavily through real-estate transactions and closingsOnline quote and checkout, no sales call needed
TenureRoots in the Sears home-services business; sells in 48 states (all but Alaska and Hawaii)A long-running name embedded in the real-estate closing process, with a public record a buyer can readA newer name; no verified review record yet — no rating or count published here, by design

Read that glance carefully and the shape of this comparison is already visible. One of these two legacy brands will show you samples, a fee menu, and a cap schedule before you buy. The other will show you none of the three. And the #1 pick shows you all three as fixed published terms — a starting price, one flat fee, and one annual limit — in a contract booklet you can open before you spend anything.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Sears Veteran vs the Closing-Table Name

Cinch Home Services grew out of the Sears home-services world, and that heritage still explains how it sells. Sears spent decades as the name American homeowners associated with appliance service, and Cinch inherited both the contractor relationships and the repair-first mindset: its entry tier is literally a repair-only plan, and its standout feature is a guarantee on repair workmanship. Today Cinch sells in 48 states and prices by sample and quote — it will show you what homes like yours have paid, in ranges and worked examples, but the price for your address still comes from a quote. It is, in other words, a legacy brand that has learned to publish more than most of its generation, without becoming a fully published-price seller.

First American Home Warranty comes from a different institution: the real-estate transaction itself. Its parent world is title, escrow, and closing services, and its home warranty business grew up inside that process — a plan attached to a home sale, selected at the closing table, often paid for as part of the deal, and renewed year after year by homeowners who may never have shopped for it directly. That origin explains its publishing habits. A product designed to be quoted inside a transaction does not need a public price list, and First American does not keep one: no published starting price, no published service fee, and no published cap schedule. What it has instead is placement — deep placement in the channel where homes change hands — and tenure in that channel that no direct-to-homeowner brand in this comparison can match.

Neither origin is a scandal, and neither is a technology platform. Both companies run claims the way this industry has run them for decades: you call, a claim is opened, a contractor is dispatched through a network, paperwork moves, and a decision comes back on the network’s timeline. Empire Home Protect was built the other way — a fully digital platform where the claim, the approval, and the service scheduling move at software speed, with claims approved the same day and service approved in minutes, and people available around the clock when a human is what the moment needs. That contrast — digital platform against two different flavors of old school — is the through-line of every round below.

Round 1 — Price: a Sample Range vs No Published Price vs a Published $49/mo

Winner between the two: Cinch Home Services, clearly. Winner overall: Empire Home Protect.

Cinch does not publish a single national price, and we will not pretend otherwise. What it publishes is a sample range — from $24.99/mo to $131.99/mo across its tiers and ZIP codes — and worked samples a buyer can actually use. On its published Fairfax, Virginia sample, for a 2,500 square foot home at the $150 service-fee level, Repair + Replace is $49.99/mo and Premier is $72.99/mo. A sample is not a price for your home; your own Cinch price still arrives by quote, and it will move with your ZIP code, your home’s size, your tier, and the service fee you choose. But a sample range with worked examples is real information. It lets a buyer sanity-check a quote, spot an outlier, and walk into the conversation knowing roughly where the shelf sits.

First American publishes nothing equivalent. There is no starting price, no sample range, and no worked example on its public shelf — the price of a basic or premier plan for your home exists only inside a quote. For a plan bought at a closing table, where the warranty is one line in a stack of transaction documents, that opacity is easy to miss. For a homeowner shopping directly, comparing brands side by side, it is the whole ballgame: you cannot comparison-shop a number you are not shown, and you cannot tell whether the quote you receive is typical, generous, or padded until you have collected several others.

Empire Home Protect publishes the number itself: full-home plans from $49/mo, printed in the sample booklet and on the plan ladder, checkable in seconds before any conversation. That is why Empire wins this round outright, and why Cinch’s samples — genuinely useful, and better than most of the legacy field — still finish second. A range tells you where a price might land. A published starting price tells you where it starts.

Round 2 — Plans and Coverage: Three Tiers With a Repair-Only Door vs Two Doors at Closing vs Three Tiers Priced in the Open

Winner between the two: Cinch Home Services, on structure a buyer can read. Winner overall: Empire Home Protect.

Cinch’s ladder has three rungs, and the bottom one is unusual: Repair Only, a tier that pays to repair covered items without the replacement promise, priced accordingly, with a $1,000 per-item cap. Above it, Repair + Replace adds the replacement promise, and Premier sits at the top of the shelf (California sells the same ideas under different plan names). The structure rewards reading: a homeowner whose systems are newer and whose real risk is repair bills can buy the cheaper door honestly, while a homeowner with aging appliances can buy replacement coverage knowing exactly which cap schedule comes with it. Cinch also covers two things most legacy brands exclude — unknown pre-existing conditions, and rust and corrosion damage — and we score those again in Round 6, because they are the strongest coverage extras in this head-to-head.

First American’s shelf is simpler: a basic tier and a premier tier, both combined plans covering systems and appliances together, with the premier tier widening the list. Simple is not a defect — two doors are easy to choose between, and for a plan selected quickly during a home purchase, simplicity has real value. The problem is not the shape of the shelf; it is that the shelf comes without published terms attached. A buyer can learn what the tiers are called and roughly what they cover, but not what either costs, what a claim will cost in service fees, or where the caps sit, until the quote and contract for a specific home are in front of them.

Empire Home Protect runs a three-tier ladder too — Silver, Supreme, and Titanium — but with the terms attached in public: from $49/mo, a flat $75 fee, and a $10,000 annual limit, stated in the sample booklet before purchase. Three readable tiers with published terms beat three readable tiers with sample terms, and both beat two tiers whose terms live inside a quote. Empire takes the round; Cinch takes second place between the two legacy brands, because its structure can be studied before a sales conversation and First American’s cannot.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Hold any quote up against a published price: Empire Home Protect full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, claims approved the same day. Prefer to talk it through? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Menu You Choose From vs a Fee Inside the Quote vs a Flat $75 in Print

Winner between the two: Cinch Home Services. Winner overall: Empire Home Protect.

Cinch is the rare legacy brand that treats the service fee as a choice instead of a surprise. At purchase you pick $100, $125, or $150 per claim, and the trade is stated in the open: choose the lower fee and your monthly premium rises by roughly $10–12/mo. That trade deserves honest scoring in both directions. The transparency is genuinely good — you know all three fee levels and the price of choosing between them before you buy. But run the math and the menu is less generous than it looks: dropping from the $150 fee to the $100 fee saves $50 per claim while adding roughly $120–144 a year in premium, so a homeowner needs about three claims a year just to break even on the cheaper fee. Most households file one or two. For the typical buyer, Cinch’s own numbers say the $150 fee is the rational pick — which makes the menu mostly a way to pay more premium for a discount you will rarely collect.

First American does not publish its service fee at all. The figure is set in the quote and contract for your home, which means a buyer cannot compare it, cannot budget for it, and cannot check it against any other brand’s fee until the transaction is already moving. A fee you learn about inside a contract is a fee you have effectively agreed to before you have seen it.

Empire Home Protect publishes one flat fee: $75 per trade service call, printed in the sample booklet, with no premium trade attached and no menu to game out. It is lower than the cheapest option on Cinch’s menu — $25 less per claim than Cinch’s $100 floor, $75 less than the $150 level its own math pushes most buyers toward — and it is knowable before you buy, which First American’s fee is not. Empire wins the round outright. Between the two, Cinch’s published menu, trade and all, beats a fee hidden inside a quote.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: Published Caps vs Caps Inside the Contract vs a $10,000 Annual Limit

Winner between the two: Cinch Home Services. Winner overall: Empire Home Protect.

Cinch publishes its cap schedule, and a published cap schedule can be judged — so let us judge it. Repair Only caps each item at $1,000. The replacement tiers cap each item at $2,000, with tighter sub-limits where claims actually cluster: HVAC at $1,500, plumbing at $1,000, kitchen and laundry appliances at $2,000, and refrigerant covered to $10 per pound. The aggregate is $10,000 per term. Those are real, checkable numbers, and publishing them puts Cinch ahead of most of the legacy field. They are also, plainly, thin where it hurts most: a full HVAC replacement runs well past a $1,500 cap, and a $1,000 plumbing cap can be consumed by a single serious failure. A buyer who reads Cinch’s schedule knows exactly how much risk stays on their own side of the contract — which is the point of publishing it, and the reason it wins this round between the two.

First American publishes no cap schedule. Its per-item and per-term limits are set in the quote and contract for your home, so they cannot be verified, compared, or budgeted before a sales conversation. That does not prove First American’s caps are worse than Cinch’s — it proves something more basic: a buyer cannot know. In a product whose entire value is a promise about future repair bills, the limits on that promise are not fine print. They are the product. A brand that will not show them in public is asking to be trusted on the exact point where trust should be earned with numbers.

Empire Home Protect publishes its limit in the same place it publishes its price and fee: a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, printed in the sample contract booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), alongside the $49/mo starting price, the flat $75 fee, and the 30-day waiting period. Terms vary by plan, administrator, and state, and the booklet says so — but the headline limit a buyer is shopping on is stated in the open, matching Cinch’s published aggregate while arriving without Cinch’s thicket of per-item sub-caps as the headline story. Empire takes the round. Between the two legacy brands, published-but-thin beats unpublished: Cinch second, First American third.

Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Phone Queues vs Same-Day Digital Approval

Winner between the two: neither — both run the traditional process. Winner overall: Empire Home Protect, outright.

This is the round the legacy model loses as a model, and it is the round that matters most on the worst day of homeownership — the day the heat, the water heater, or the refrigerator actually fails. Cinch runs claims traditionally: a claim is opened, reviewed, and dispatched through its contractor network, with dispatch response windows that can run up to 48 hours before a technician is even scheduled. First American runs the same generation of process: phone-driven intake, review on the company’s cycle, dispatch through a network, paperwork at each step. Neither brand publishes a same-day approval standard, because neither brand’s process was built to deliver one.

We score this round a draw between the two, and we will not manufacture a winner out of two similar phone queues. A homeowner choosing only between Cinch and First American should not pick on claims speed; there is no meaningful, checkable speed advantage on either side of this head-to-head.

Empire Home Protect wins the round outright because its process is a different kind of thing. Claims are filed and approved on a fully digital platform — approved the same day, with service approved in minutes — instead of moving at the speed of a phone queue and a paperwork cycle. That is the Tesla-and-Apple difference applied to a warranty: the work a legacy company does with hold music and callbacks, a digital platform does in software, with people available 24/7 behind it for the moments that need a human. When a furnace dies on a cold night, the difference between a 48-hour dispatch window and same-day approval is not a feature comparison. It is the whole purchase.

Round 6 — Standout Features: Cinch’s Guarantee and Coverage Extras Win Outright

Winner between the two: Cinch Home Services, outright. Empire Home Protect does not contest this round — and we say so.

Cinch carries the strongest standout package in this head-to-head, and it is not close. Start with the 180-day workmanship guarantee: when a covered repair is completed, the work is guaranteed for 180 days — the longest workmanship guarantee we compare — so if the same failure returns inside that window, the plan stands behind the repair instead of opening a fresh argument. Add coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions, which most legacy brands exclude outright, and coverage for rust and corrosion damage, another standard exclusion Cinch chooses to cover. Add the $500/yr deductible reimbursement on the replacement tiers. That is a package of extras with real dollar value, aimed at the exact failure modes — repeat repairs, inherited problems in a newly bought home, corroded systems — that generate the angriest warranty disputes.

First American publishes no equivalent standout package in this comparison. Its case is channel and tenure, scored in the next round, not extras. A buyer weighing only these two brands on features should weigh Cinch’s package heavily; for a home with older systems, unknown pre-existing coverage alone can be the deciding fact.

Empire Home Protect’s case does not rest on a guarantee package, and this comparison will not invent one for it. Empire’s standouts are the published terms themselves — price, flat fee, and annual limit in print before you buy — and the digital claims speed scored in Round 5. On standout features as such, Cinch wins outright, against both other brands in this piece. A ranking that only awards rounds to its #1 pick is not a ranking; it is an advertisement. Cinch earned this one.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Get an instant Empire Home Protect quote in minutes — plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, no sales call needed. No obligation.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 7 — Channel and Tenure: First American Wins Outright

Winner between the two: First American Home Warranty, outright. Empire Home Protect does not contest this round either.

Every comparison has a round the legacy brand simply owns, and this is First American’s. It is the name built into the real-estate transaction: the warranty offered at the closing table, carried by agents and transaction packages, renewed by homeowners who received it with their home. That channel is a genuine asset. A seller offering a First American plan as part of a listing, or a buyer receiving one at closing, is using the product exactly as it was designed to be used, backed by the longer record in that channel and a public record a buyer can read and weigh.

Cinch has tenure of its own — the Sears lineage is real, and its contractor heritage runs deep — but its record is a retail service record, not a closing-table record. In the specific arena of the home sale itself, First American’s placement and history win, and no amount of published-sample transparency changes that fact.

Empire Home Protect is the newer, digital-first entrant in this comparison, sold directly to homeowners rather than embedded in closings, and we publish no review count for it because none is verified yet. On channel and tenure, First American wins outright. Where Empire competes — published terms, flat fees, digital speed — it wins those rounds on numbers any buyer can check today, which is the ground a new platform should have to win on.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

Winner overall: Empire Home Protect — the only fully computable purchase in this comparison.

A home warranty’s real price is not its monthly premium. It is the premium plus the service fees you will actually pay in a normal year, judged against the limits that cap what comes back. So let us do the two-claim-year math for each brand, using only published figures — and notice, as we go, which brands let us do it at all. Empire Home Protect sells online, on your own schedule — quote and plan choice without a sales call — with its starting price, fee, and limit published before the quote begins. Prefer to talk it through instead? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382 and compare out loud.

Empire Home Protect: $738, fully checkable. Twelve months from $49/mo is $588 in premiums. Two claims at the flat $75 fee add $150. Total: $738 for a two-claim year, against a $10,000 annual limit — every input published before purchase, in the sample booklet.

Cinch Home Services: computable on its sample, not on your home. On the published Fairfax, Virginia sample (2,500 sq ft home, $150 fee level), Repair + Replace at $49.99/mo is $599.88 a year in premiums, plus two $150 fees, for a two-claim year of $899.88. Premier at $72.99/mo is $875.88 in premiums, plus $300 in fees, for $1,175.88. Choosing Cinch’s $100 fee instead does not rescue the math: it trims $100 off the fees while adding roughly $120–144 to the year’s premium, landing the Repair + Replace year around $919.88–$943.88 — more, not less, for a typical two-claim household. And all of it is sample math: your own ZIP code and home will be quoted individually, so your real Cinch year cannot be computed until Cinch computes it for you.

First American Home Warranty: not computable. No published premium, no published fee, and no published caps means no honest total can be printed here — not by us, and not by you at your kitchen table the night before you buy. That is not a rounding problem. It is the finding. A purchase whose first-year cost cannot be estimated from anything the seller publishes is a purchase made on trust alone, in a category where the contract’s limits are the product.

Stack the three results and the ranking explains itself. Empire Home Protect is the only brand in this head-to-head whose two-claim year can be verified, to the dollar, before a sales conversation — and it is also the cheapest of the computable years. Cinch’s sample years run $161.88 to $437.88 more than Empire’s published year, under caps a buyer can at least read. First American’s year is a blank until a quote fills it in.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Buy Cinch Home Services if you are choosing only between these two legacy brands, you buy directly rather than at a closing, and you value coverage extras over headline price: the 180-day workmanship guarantee, unknown pre-existing condition coverage, and rust and corrosion coverage are real protections, and Cinch is the only brand in this pair that publishes its samples, fee menu, and caps for you to study first. Take the $150 fee level unless you reliably file three or more claims a year — Cinch’s own premium trade says so.

Take First American Home Warranty if it arrives the way it was designed to arrive: as part of a home purchase, offered by a seller or agent at closing, where its channel, tenure, and closing-table record are the point. Read the contract’s fee and cap figures carefully at that moment, because the closing documents are the first place those numbers will ever be shown to you — and compare what you find there against the published math above before you renew it a year later.

Buy Empire Home Protect if you want the purchase itself to be checkable: a published price from $49/mo, one flat $75 fee, a $10,000 annual limit in a booklet you can read first, and a claim approved the same day on a digital platform when something breaks — with service approved in minutes and people available 24/7. That is the buyer this comparison is really for: the homeowner who compares first and buys second. On the published facts, that buyer lands on Empire Home Protect, which is why every quote button on this page goes there.

The Bottom Line

Cinch Home Services vs First American Home Warranty is a fair fight with a clear shape. Cinch wins on transparency — published samples, a published fee menu, published caps — and wins outright on standout protections, led by the 180-day workmanship guarantee and unknown pre-existing coverage. First American wins outright on channel and tenure, as the closing-table name with the longer record in the real-estate channel. Both price your own home by quote, both hide or sample the numbers a buyer most needs, and both run claims through the traditional phone-and-paperwork process their generation built.

Empire Home Protect ranks #1 overall because it removes the two defects both legacy brands share. Its terms are published, not quoted or sampled: full-home plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 trade service call fee, and a $10,000 annual limit, printed in its sample contract booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824; administered by Aegis Administration, LLC; obligor Assurance Express, LLC; backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims (855) 203-9876; terms vary by plan, administrator, and state). And its claims process is digital, not traditional: approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7. The two-claim-year math says the same thing as the rounds do — $738, checkable before you buy, against sample years of $899.88 and $1,175.88 and a third year that cannot be computed at all.

If you came here deciding between Cinch and First American, you now have the honest split between them — and the published alternative that beats both on the facts a buyer can verify. Get the Empire Home Protect quote, read the booklet, and buy the warranty whose numbers you were allowed to check first. Questions before you decide? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.