support@comparebestwarranties.com

Choice Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 18, 2026 • 16 min read

Choice Home Warranty and First American Home Warranty are two of the names a homeowner is most likely to end up holding — but they arrive by completely different doors. Choice Home Warranty is the name you choose for yourself: a long-running national brand that sells directly to homeowners, with a deliberately simple shelf — a basic tier, a total tier that combines systems and appliances, and optional add-ons — priced entirely by quote. First American Home Warranty is the name that arrives with the house: it is the warranty buyers most often meet through a real-estate transaction — included, offered, or handed over at closing — sold in basic and premier tiers, and also priced entirely by quote, so its number depends on the home, the state, and the deal it rode in on. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure and public record, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full Choice Home Warranty review and First American Home Warranty review.

The short version: this is the rare head-to-head where neither company publishes the numbers that decide it. Choice publishes no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps — all three live inside its quote and its contract. First American publishes no starting price, no service fee, and no claim caps either — all three live inside its quote and its contract, and for many holders the first quote they ever saw was written into a closing packet by somebody else. Between the two, the honest differences are about how you buy and what you can read before you buy. Choice wins the rounds that rest on shopping for yourself: a direct-to-homeowner shelf with optional add-ons to shape it, and the longer homeowner-facing public record — a track record written by people who picked the plan, pay for it monthly, and file the claims themselves. First American wins the round that rests on the closing table: no company in this pairing is more deeply built into the moment a house changes hands, and for a buyer handed a plan at closing, that convenience is real. But convenience at closing is not the same as value over the years you hold the plan, and neither company changes the model behind the shelf: both run a traditional, phone-driven claims process, where a queue and a paperwork cycle come first. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect ranks first overall, because it publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, all printed in its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where our comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds, before you share a single detail about your home — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), on a fully digital platform where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that legacy sellers still do by phone queue, paperwork, and waiting — handled with integrity and respect, and with people available 24/7 when you want a person. Neither Choice nor First American publishes a starting price at all, and neither publishes its service fee or its claim caps in advance: with both of them, every number that decides value waits inside a quote. Empire prints its numbers first and lets the quote confirm them.

Between the two legacy brands, Choice Home Warranty edges First American Home Warranty for a homeowner choosing a plan for themselves — and the margin is about agency, not arithmetic, because neither side offers any arithmetic to check. Choice sells to the person who will hold the contract: you collect its quote yourself, you can shape its two tiers with optional add-ons, and its public record is the longer one written directly by homeowners. First American’s strength is the channel, not the shelf: it is at its best in the hands of an agent or a seller at closing, which means the person who chose it is often not the person who will live with its claims process. If a First American plan came with your house, it is real coverage and this comparison is not a reason to panic — it is a reason, at renewal time, to make the next choice a chosen one, against a published price. The rounds below score each category on its own facts, including the several rounds these two companies honestly tie.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Choice Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

Empire Home Protect (#1 overall): Silver / Supreme / Titanium full-home plans from a published $49/mo; flat $75 trade service call fee; $10,000 annual aggregate limit; 30-day waiting period; fully digital claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7; terms printed in the sample booklet (Aegis Administration, LLC; Assurance Express, LLC; Lexington National Insurance Corporation) before you buy; claims line (855) 203-9876 printed in the booklet.

Choice Home Warranty: a simple two-tier shelf — a basic tier and a total tier combining systems and appliances — plus optional add-ons; pricing by quote only, with no published starting figure a buyer can verify in advance; service fee and claim limits set in the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims process; a long-running national brand selling directly to homeowners, with tenure and the longer homeowner-facing public review history as its outright strengths.

First American Home Warranty: basic and premier (combined) tiers; pricing by quote only, with no published starting figure a buyer can verify in advance; service fee and claim limits set in the quote and contract; traditional phone-driven claims process; sold heavily through real-estate transactions, so many holders first meet it at closing — included, offered, or handed over with the house — rather than by shopping for it themselves.

What Each Company Actually Is: the Plan You Choose vs the Plan That Arrives With the House

A home warranty is a service contract: when a named system or appliance in your tier fails from normal wear and tear, you file a claim, pay a per-claim service fee, and the plan arranges and pays toward the repair or replacement, up to the contract’s limits. It is not homeowners insurance (that covers perils like fire and theft), and it is not maintenance (filters, flushing, and servicing stay your job, and keep systems eligible). Both companies in this head-to-head sell that same underlying contract. What differs is who the company was built to sell to — and that difference shapes everything else in this comparison.

Choice Home Warranty sells the contract to the homeowner directly, and its shelf is built to be understood in one look. The basic tier covers the core of the home; the total tier combines systems and appliances in one plan; and optional add-ons let a buyer bolt on coverage for the extras their particular home has. There is no channel between Choice and its customer: the person reading the quote is the person who will pay the premium and file the claims. That directness is Choice’s real architecture, and it is why its public record means what it appears to mean — it was written, over a long national run, by homeowners who chose the plan themselves. The rest of the model is the older pattern: the price arrives by quote after you share details about your home and state, the fee and the caps live in the contract, and claims move through a phone-driven process.

First American Home Warranty sells the same contract from inside the real-estate transaction. Its basic tier and its premier tier — the combined plan — are the shelf a buyer, a seller, or an agent selects around a closing, and a large share of its holders never comparison-shopped a home warranty at all: the plan was part of the deal, a line in the packet that made a listing easier to buy or a seller’s home easier to hand over. That channel is a genuine strength, and this comparison scores it as one: at the most stressful moment in homeownership, First American is simply there, already arranged. But a buyer should see the trade clearly. A channel-built company’s deepest relationships are with the professionals who place its plans — agents, brokers, and transaction partners — not necessarily with the homeowner who will call it, two winters later, about a furnace. And because the plan so often arrives pre-chosen, many holders meet its price, its fee, and its caps for the first time when they open the contract after closing.

The question this head-to-head asks is narrower and more useful than which name is more familiar: on the day your furnace dies in January, what does each model actually do for you — and did you ever get to choose it, at a price you could check first? In the traditional process both of these companies run, a phone queue and a paperwork cycle come first. On a digital platform, a claim approved the same day and service approved in minutes is the whole point. Keep that day in mind through every round below.

Round 1 — Price: Two Quotes, No Published Numbers, vs a Published $49/mo

Start where every buyer starts, and where this pairing immediately stalls: neither company will tell you its price. Choice Home Warranty publishes no starting price. Its basic and total tiers are priced by quote, varying by home, state, and tier, so the first real number a Choice buyer sees arrives inside a sales conversation they started by handing over their details. First American Home Warranty publishes no starting price either. Its basic and premier tiers are priced by quote on the same variables — and in its case the quote is often not even addressed to the homeowner: it is written for the transaction, folded into closing costs or a seller concession, where a warranty’s price is one small line among hundreds and gets the least scrutiny of any of them.

Score the round honestly: between the two, price publication is a tie at zero. Neither earns the transparency credit that a published figure earns, because neither publishes one. If there is a shade of difference, it is in who sees the quote at all. A Choice buyer at least collects their own number and can walk away from it. A First American holder may never see a standalone price until renewal — the moment, not coincidentally, when this comparison matters most. We do not score that shade as a round win; we note it because it is the difference between a price you declined and a price you never met.

Empire Home Protect publishes its starting price: full-home plans from $49/mo, checkable in seconds, before a name, an address, or a phone number changes hands. A published price does not mean every home pays $49 — tier and home decide the final quote, as they do everywhere — but it means the negotiation starts from a number the company was willing to print, and every other quote in this comparison can be measured against it the moment it arrives. Round 1 to Empire Home Protect outright; Choice and First American tie, with nothing published on either side.

Round 2 — Plans and Coverage: a Two-Tier Shelf With Add-Ons vs a Two-Tier Shelf Built for Closing

On the shelf itself, the two companies look like twins: two tiers each. Choice pairs a basic tier with a total tier that combines the home’s systems and its appliances in one plan. First American pairs a basic tier with a premier tier that does the same combining. In both cases the logic is identical — start with the core, step up for the whole home — and in both cases the step up to the combined tier is the purchase that actually matches why most people buy a home warranty, which is the furnace and the refrigerator in the same bad month.

The difference is what hangs off the shelf. Choice offers optional add-ons: extra coverage a buyer can attach for the specific extras their home carries, chosen item by item by the homeowner who knows the house. That makes Choice’s two tiers behave a little like a base and a toolkit — the shelf is simple, but it bends. First American’s shelf bends a different way: its tiers are shaped for the transaction, where the choice is usually made quickly, by checklist, around a closing date, and where “which tier did the deal include” is a more common question than “which tier fits my home.” Neither structure is dishonest. But only one of them was designed around the person who will live under it.

Empire Home Protect runs three tiers — Silver, Supreme, and Titanium — sized as a ladder a homeowner climbs by how much of the home they want covered, at a published starting price. Three doors instead of two is a small thing until the middle door is exactly your home: the combined-everything tier is not the only way to cover more than the basics. Round 2 to Choice Home Warranty between the two, narrowly, for the add-on flexibility on a direct shelf; Empire Home Protect’s three published tiers sit above both.

Round 3 — Service Fees: a Fee Inside the Quote vs a Fee Inside the Closing Packet vs a Flat $75 in Print

The service fee is the price you pay on your worst day, per claim, before any repair begins — and in this pairing, neither company prints it. Choice Home Warranty sets its service fee inside the quote and the contract for your home and tier: the figure exists, it is knowable, but only once you are inside its process, and a buyer comparing two quotes has to extract it deliberately or it hides behind the premium. First American Home Warranty sets its service fee the same way, inside the quote and contract — with the channel’s extra wrinkle that the person who agreed to the fee at closing is frequently not the person who will pay it at claim time, and may never have read it at all.

Between the two, there is nothing to separate: a fee in a quote you requested and a fee in a contract you inherited are both unpublished fees, and we score the round a tie. What a buyer can do with either company is the same discipline: get the fee in writing, next to the premium, before signing or renewing, and refuse to compare any two plans on premiums alone. A low premium with a high per-claim fee is a different product than it looks like in the headline, and both of these companies leave that arithmetic as homework.

Empire Home Protect prints its fee: a flat $75 trade service call fee, stated in the sample contract booklet any buyer can read before purchasing. Flat means the worst-day price is the same in January as in June, for a furnace as for a dishwasher, and it can be added to the premium on paper before you buy — which is exactly what Round 8 does. Round 3 to Empire Home Protect outright; Choice and First American tie, with the fee unpublished on both sides.

Round 4 — Claim Limits: Caps Inside Two Contracts vs a $10,000 Annual Limit in Print

Claim limits decide what a plan is worth on the expensive day — the full HVAC replacement, not the minor repair — and they are the second set of numbers this pairing keeps indoors. Choice Home Warranty’s claim limits are set in the quote and contract and are not published in advance: a buyer learns the ceiling on their coverage by reading their own agreement, carefully, after the sales conversation. First American Home Warranty’s claim limits are set the same way, in the quote and contract, unpublished in advance — and again the channel compounds it, because a contract first opened after closing is a contract whose caps were never part of any decision the holder made.

We score caps exactly as we score fees: unpublished is unpublished, and the round between the two is a tie. The practical warning is identical for both, and it is the most important sentence in this section: a home warranty’s value is its caps divided by its surprises, and with either of these companies you cannot run that division until the paperwork is in front of you. Read the per-item and aggregate limits in the actual contract, not the brochure, and read them before the renewal date, not after the breakdown.

Empire Home Protect publishes its limit the same place it publishes its fee: a $10,000 annual aggregate limit, printed in the sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824), administered by Aegis Administration, LLC, with the obligor Assurance Express, LLC backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation, and the claims line — (855) 203-9876 — printed alongside it. A buyer can hold that $10,000 figure against their own home’s realistic worst year before spending a dollar. Round 4 to Empire Home Protect outright; Choice and First American tie, with caps unpublished on both sides.

Round 5 — Claims Speed: Two Traditional Dispatch Models vs Same-Day Digital Approval

If price is where a plan is bought, claims are where it is kept or cancelled — and here the two legacy companies converge completely. Choice Home Warranty runs the traditional model: a claim begins with a phone call, enters a queue, waits on authorization and dispatch paperwork, and a technician is scheduled through that cycle. First American Home Warranty runs the same traditional model: phone-driven intake, a paperwork cycle, and dispatch on the process’s schedule rather than the breakdown’s. Neither company publishes a same-day approval standard, because neither company’s process was built to offer one. The furnace does not care which legacy brand’s queue it is sitting in.

That makes Round 5 an honest tie between the two — and the clearest round in the comparison for the #1 pick. Empire Home Protect was built as a technology company in an industry of phone queues: its platform is fully digital, claims are approved the same day, and service is approved in minutes, with people available 24/7 behind the platform when a claim needs a human. That is not a faster version of the traditional process; it is a different process, the same difference a digital platform makes everywhere else it replaces a call center with software. On the worst day of homeownership, same-day approval versus a queue is not a feature difference. It is the product. Round 5 to Empire Home Protect outright; Choice and First American tie, both traditional.

Compare the #1 Pick Against Your Quote

Already holding a Choice quote, or a First American plan that came with the house? Price Empire Home Protect first — from $49/mo, a flat $75 fee, a $10,000 annual limit, claims approved the same day. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

Round 6 — Standout Features: Add-Ons You Choose vs a Plan That Is Simply There at Closing

Every company in a head-to-head gets the round where its best argument stands alone, and here the two arguments could not be more different in kind. Choice Home Warranty’s standout is its optional add-ons on a direct shelf: the homeowner who knows their house can extend a basic or total plan item by item, shaping coverage around the extras they actually own instead of paying for a bigger tier to reach one extra system. It is a modest feature, honestly scored — add-ons exist across this industry — but on Choice’s deliberately simple two-tier shelf, the add-ons are what keep simple from becoming rigid, and they are chosen by the buyer, for the buyer’s reasons.

First American Home Warranty’s standout is not a feature of the contract at all. It is placement. First American is the plan that is simply there at the closing table: offered by the agent, included by the seller, written into the transaction so a buyer walks into a new home with coverage already running and no shopping left to do in the busiest month of their life. For a first-time buyer with no bandwidth to compare service contracts, that is a real service, and this comparison credits it without irony. Its limit is equally real: a standout about distribution says nothing about the years after closing day, when the plan has to perform as a product rather than as a convenience — on price nobody published, fees nobody printed, and a phone queue.

Empire Home Protect’s standout is the combination neither legacy company attempts: published terms and a digital claims platform in the same product, sold directly to the homeowner who will hold it. Round 6 is a split decision between the two — Choice for the buyer shaping a plan, First American for the buyer who never had to shop — with Empire Home Protect above both, because it is the only company here whose standout feature is how the plan itself performs.

Round 7 — Tenure and Public Record: a Record Written by Choosers vs a Record Written by Transactions

Both of these companies have been selling home warranties for a long time, and this comparison invents no rating or review count for either of them — or for Empire Home Protect. What can be read, without inventing a number, is the shape of each record. Choice Home Warranty’s public record is the longer homeowner-facing one in this pairing, and its tenure is its outright lead across every comparison on this site: a long-running national brand, selling directly to homeowners the whole way, means its reviews and complaints were written by people who picked the plan, chose the tier, and filed the claims. That is the most legible kind of record a legacy seller can have, and Choice has it.

First American Home Warranty’s history runs just as long through its channel, but its record reads differently, for a structural reason: when a large share of holders never chose the product, their reviews judge two things at once — the plan, and the fact that it arrived unchosen, with terms they met late. That does not make First American’s record unfair to read; it makes it a record of a distribution model as much as of a service contract. A buyer handed a First American plan at closing should read its record knowing which of those two things each complaint is really about — and should notice that the fix for the second one is entirely in their hands at renewal.

Empire Home Protect publishes no star rating or review count in this comparison, because no verified review record exists for it yet — we print that absence rather than a number, the same discipline we apply to every brand here. What it offers instead of a borrowed record is a readable contract: the sample booklet, the printed fee, the printed limit, the printed claims line. Round 7 to Choice Home Warranty outright between the two, for the longer record written directly by the homeowners who hold its plans.

Round 8 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

How you buy decides how much of the truth you hold when you sign. Choice Home Warranty sells by quote to the homeowner: you start the conversation, share your home’s details, receive a number, and decide — a normal sales process, with the normal caveat that price, fee, and caps all arrive together, inside that conversation, and checking any one of them means engaging the whole process. First American Home Warranty sells by quote through a transaction: the conversation is often between professionals, the number is folded into a closing, and the homeowner’s decision point may be a signature on a stack of documents where the warranty is the smallest line. Empire Home Protect sells the way the #1 pick should: a published starting price, a printed fee and limit, and an online quote you can complete on your own schedule, before any conversation at all.

Now the two-claim year, computed only from figures each company itself publishes. Empire Home Protect: $49/mo across twelve months is $588 in premiums, plus two claims at the flat $75 fee is $150 — $738 for the year, fully checkable before you buy. Choice Home Warranty: the year cannot be computed. No published premium, no published fee, no published caps — the total exists only inside a quote. First American Home Warranty: the year cannot be computed, for exactly the same reason — and in its case the missing total is worse than a missing number, because a holder who never saw a quote cannot even reconstruct what their first year was supposed to cost until the renewal quote arrives.

Read that math the way a buyer should. Two established companies, decades of selling, and neither one lets a stranger add up a year of ownership from its own published figures. Empire publishes every line. That is not a marketing difference; it is the difference between a price and a process. Round 8 to Empire Home Protect outright; between the two, Choice’s self-collected quote beats First American’s inherited one, because a number you asked for is a number you can refuse.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Brand

Choose Choice Home Warranty if you are shopping for yourself and simplicity is your first filter: you want a basic-or-total shelf you can understand in one look, optional add-ons to shape it around your home’s extras, and the confidence of the longer homeowner-written record — and you are willing to work its quote hard, with premium, service fee, and caps all extracted and compared in writing before you sign, because none of those numbers is published for you in advance.

Choose First American Home Warranty if the closing table is your context: a plan is being included or offered in your transaction, the convenience of coverage that starts with the house is worth more to you this month than a comparison you have no time to run, and you treat the first renewal as the real purchase — the moment you re-shop the plan you inherited against published alternatives, with its fee and caps finally read in full. Inherited coverage is a reasonable start. It is a poor reason to never choose.

Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the comparison settled before the sales conversation starts: full-home plans from a published $49/mo that any Choice quote or First American renewal can be checked against the moment it arrives, a flat $75 service fee and a $10,000 annual limit printed in a sample booklet you can read first, and a claims process built to approve the same day and approve service in minutes, with people available 24/7. For most homeowners reading a head-to-head like this one, that combination is why Empire ranks #1 here.

See What the #1 Pick Costs for Your Home

Get your Empire Home Protect quote online in minutes — from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. Prefer to talk? Call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Get My Empire Quote

The Bottom Line

Choice Home Warranty vs First American Home Warranty is a choice between choosing and inheriting. Choice asks you to trust a simple shelf and a long record written by the homeowners who picked it, and earns real credit on both — so long as you accept that every number that decides value waits inside its quote. First American asks you to trust the transaction it arrived in, and earns real credit for being there at closing when a buyer needed one less thing to arrange — so long as you accept that its price, its fee, and its caps were set in a conversation you may never have been part of. Between the two, Choice wins more rounds for a homeowner buying deliberately: the add-on shelf, the homeowner-facing record, and a quote you collect and can refuse yourself.

Empire Home Protect ranks #1 in this comparison because it refuses both asks. It prints the numbers — from $49/mo, a flat $75 fee, a $10,000 annual limit, all in a sample contract you can read before you buy — it sells directly to the person who will hold the plan, and it replaces the traditional claims queue both of these companies run with a fully digital process that approves claims the same day and service in minutes, handled with integrity and respect. Start with your Empire quote, then hold every other number in this comparison up against it.