support@comparebestwarranties.com

American Home Shield vs Select Home Warranty: Which Home Warranty Is Better in 2026?

Published November 17, 2026 • 16 min read

American Home Shield and Select Home Warranty are the two names a homeowner is most likely to be handed at the same moment — one at a closing table, the other while gathering quotes online — and a homeowner shortlisting both is really choosing between two versions of the same old-school model. American Home Shield is the established default: one of the longest-established national home warranty brands, the name real-estate professionals have handed to buyers for decades, selling systems, appliances, and combined tiers with optional add-ons, priced entirely by quote. Select Home Warranty is the familiar third quote: a seller of the industry’s standard three-part structure — a systems tier, an appliances tier, and a combined tier — also priced entirely by quote, so its number only appears once you are already in a sales conversation. If you are choosing between them, this head-to-head compares the things that actually decide value: published price, plan structure, service fees, claim limits, claims speed, standout features, tenure, and how you buy. It follows our best home warranty companies guide for 2026, where both companies are scored against the full field, and it draws on our full American Home Shield review and Select Home Warranty review.

The short version: between the two, American Home Shield wins the rounds that rest on history and tailoring, and Select Home Warranty wins almost nothing outright — and that asymmetry is the story. American Home Shield wins on tenure outright: no newer seller can match a decades-long national track record, a longer public review history a buyer can actually read, and a real-estate channel that has put its contracts into homes at closing for years. It also wins on add-on tailoring: a buyer who knows exactly what extras a specific home needs — a pool, a septic system, a second refrigerator — can layer them onto its standard ladder. Select Home Warranty’s honest strength is familiarity: it sells the standard three-part structure most shoppers already understand, in the shape they expect, which makes its quote a useful pressure test against any other offer. But on the checks a homeowner feels every month and on their worst day, the two are tied in the wrong direction. Neither publishes a starting price you can verify before a conversation begins. Neither publishes a flat service fee or an annual claim limit you can read in advance — both set the fee and the limits in your quote and your contract. And both run the traditional, phone-driven claims process: a phone queue and a paperwork cycle first, a repair after. That is why our #1 pick in this comparison is neither of them. Empire Home Protect publishes one clear starting price for full-home tiers — from $49/mo, with a flat $75 trade service call fee and a $10,000 annual coverage limit, from its public sample contract — and approves claims the same day, with service approved in minutes, on a fully digital platform. Every quote button on this page goes to Empire Home Protect, because that is where the comparison lands.

Our Verdict: Empire Home Protect Ranks #1 — American Home Shield Wins the Legacy Rounds, Select Is the Familiar Third Quote

Top pick: Empire Home Protect. From $49/mo — a published starting price you can check in seconds — across a simple Silver / Supreme / Titanium ladder, with a published flat $75 service fee, a published $10,000 annual limit, a published 30-day waiting period, and a fully digital claims process where claims are approved the same day and service is approved in minutes. That is the technology difference in this industry: a digital platform doing the work that old-school sellers still do by phone, paperwork, and waiting — handled with integrity and respect, and backed in its sample contract by Aegis Administration, with Assurance Express as obligor backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation; claims at (855) 203-9876. Terms come from the Comprehensive sample booklet and vary by plan, administrator, and state.

Where American Home Shield stands: the established default done the traditional way — systems, appliances, and combined tiers with optional add-ons, priced by quote varying by home and state, with the service fee and claim limits set in your quote and contract, and claims through the traditional phone-driven process. It wins the tenure round outright between the two, and the tailoring half of the plans round, on a decades-long national record no quote-only rival in this pairing can match.

Where Select Home Warranty stands: the standard-structure seller — systems, appliances, and combined tiers in the familiar three-part shape, also priced by quote varying by home and state, with the service fee and claim limits set in your quote and contract, and the same traditional phone-driven claims process. Its strength is legibility: a first-time buyer can understand its shelf in one pass, and a quote from it is a reasonable way to pressure-test any other offer.

Integrity note: we do not publish a star rating or review count for Empire Home Protect — there is no verified review record to quote yet, and we will not invent one — and we do not print a single rating for American Home Shield or Select Home Warranty either, because we publish only figures from our own verified comparison set. Read current public listings on two platforms yourself before you buy, from anyone. Where a company prices only by quote, this comparison says so instead of inventing a number; that absence is itself a scored fact.

American Home Shield vs Select Home Warranty at a Glance — Against the #1 Pick

American Home ShieldSelect Home WarrantyEmpire Home Protect (#1 pick)
Starting priceQuote-based; varies by home and state — no published starting figure we can verifyQuote-based; varies by home and state — no published starting figure we can verify$49/mo, published
PlansSystems, appliances, and combined tiers, with optional add-onsSystems, appliances, and combined tiersSilver (Core Systems) / Supreme (Full Home) / Titanium (Total Coverage + Premium Perks)
Service feeSet in your quote and contractSet in your quote and contract$75 flat per trade service call, published in the sample booklet
Annual claim limitSet in your contract — read the limits sectionSet in your contract — read the limits section$10,000 per year aggregate, published in the sample booklet
Waiting periodConfirm in your quote and contract; waiting periods are standard across the industry, commonly around 30 daysConfirm in your quote and contract; waiting periods are standard across the industry, commonly around 30 days30 days, published
Claims processTraditional: phone-driven, paperwork cycleTraditional: phone-driven, paperwork cycleFully digital; claims approved the same day, service approved in minutes, people available 24/7
How you buyTraditionally quoted and completed with a sales representative or through a real-estate transactionQuoted after you share details about your homeOnline quote and checkout, no sales call needed
StandoutLongest-established national tenure, real-estate default, add-on tailoringThe standard three-part structure most shoppers already understandPublished price, fee, and limit in a public sample contract, with same-day digital approval
Best forBuyers who put a decades-long track record first and will work a quote, a service fee, and caps hard before buyingShoppers gathering a third quote before deciding, who will work that quote, a service fee, and caps hard before buyingHomeowners who want a published price, the fastest approvals, and a plan they can size themselves

Facts: our published 2026 home warranty comparison and the head-to-heads at Empire Home Protect vs American Home Shield and Empire Home Protect vs Select Home Warranty. Prices are starting monthly rates where a provider publishes one; your tier, home, and state set the real figure. Empire Home Protect terms above come from its Comprehensive sample booklet (form AEGIS-HW-TERM-COMP-010824) and vary by plan, administrator, and state. The full field is scored in our best home warranty companies guide.

See Your Empire Home Protect Price

Get your quote online in minutes — plans from $49/mo, a flat $75 service fee, no sales call required. No obligation.

Get My Empire Quote

What Each Company Actually Is: the Closing-Table Default vs the Third Quote

A home warranty is a service contract: when a named system or appliance in your tier fails from normal wear and tear, you file a claim, pay a per-claim service fee, and the plan arranges and pays toward the repair or replacement, up to the contract’s limits. It is not homeowners insurance (that covers perils like fire and theft), and it is not maintenance (filters, flushing, and servicing stay your job, and keep systems eligible). Both companies in this pairing sell that contract. What differs is the story around the same shelf — and, more importantly, what neither of them will show you before you buy.

American Home Shield sells the contract the way the industry was built to sell it: the price arrives by quote after you share details about your home, tiers are layered with optional add-ons, and claims move through a phone-driven process built in an earlier era. That architecture is not an accident, and for a long time it was the only architecture there was — which is exactly how the brand became the default name at closing tables. Select Home Warranty sells the same contract in the industry’s standard shape, without the closing-table history: a systems tier, an appliances tier, and a combined tier that joins them, priced by quote, with claims through the same traditional process. That is a genuinely legible way to sell a home warranty, and this comparison gives it credit — a first-time buyer can understand the shelf in one pass.

The question this head-to-head asks is narrower and more useful than which name you have heard more often: on the day your furnace dies in January, what does each model actually do for you, and what did you know about its price, its fee, and its limits before that day arrived? In the traditional process both companies use, a phone queue and a paperwork cycle come first. On a digital platform, a claim approved the same day and service approved in minutes. That difference is the center of this comparison, and of every head-to-head on this site.

Round 1 — Price: Two Quotes vs a Published $49/mo

This is the clearest round in the pairing, and it is a tie between the two for the wrong reason. Empire Home Protect publishes a starting price — $49/mo at the Silver tier, about $588 a year at the starting tier (12 × $49, plain arithmetic on the published price) — that you can hold every other quote up against before you share a single detail about your home. American Home Shield does not publish a single starting price we can verify; it prices by quote, varying by home size, state, and tier, plus a per-claim service fee. Select Home Warranty does not publish a single starting price we can verify either; it prices by quote the same way, varying by home size, state, and tier, plus a per-claim service fee. That does not automatically make either of them more expensive for your house — quotes move with the home — but it does mean there is no published starting figure for us, or for you, to verify in advance, from either legacy seller.

The honest full math, applied evenly to all three: the monthly price is only the first of three numbers. Add the per-claim service fee, paid each time a technician is dispatched, and weigh the payout limits, which cap what a large claim returns. Two or three claims in a busy year at a high service fee can erase the gap between a cheap plan and a pricier one — and a thin cap on a major system can erase it in a single claim. Our home warranty cost guide works that math claim by claim, so you can sanity-check any quote you are given, from anyone. Against that full math, one unmanaged major failure — a furnace, a water heater, a major appliance — is an emergency bill at emergency prices. A plan’s job is to cap that exposure for covered items, and Empire Home Protect caps it from the lowest published starting price in our comparison, with the other two numbers published alongside it.

Edge: Empire Home Protect, on a published starting price you can verify in seconds, against two quotes you cannot verify until a sales conversation produces each of them. Between the two, this round is a tie — neither legacy seller gives a buyer a number to budget around today.

Round 2 — Plans and Coverage: Add-On Tailoring vs the Standard Three Doors vs Three Named Tiers

On structure, both legacy sellers use the industry’s standard ladder. Across home warranty, coverage splits into two buckets, and plan tiers are combinations of them: systems — heating (furnace/HVAC), air conditioning, plumbing, electrical, water heater, and ductwork are the standard named systems — and appliances — refrigerator, oven/range, dishwasher, built-in microwave, garbage disposal, and washer/dryer are the standard named appliances. Combined plans cover both buckets and are the most commonly bought tier — and the tier where comparing claim caps matters most, because the expensive failures live here.

American Home Shield packages that as systems coverage, appliances coverage, and a combined tier, and layers optional add-ons on top — which suits a buyer who wants to tailor coverage to a specific home (a pool, a septic system, a second refrigerator) and is disciplined enough to add only what the home actually has. Select Home Warranty packages the same underlying structure as systems, appliances, and combined tiers, without that closing-table add-on story in our comparison set: the trade a buyer makes with the standard structure is real in both directions — choosing is familiar and fast, but the doors are generic, every house is sorted into the same three shapes, and the tailoring happens in the quote conversation, not on the page. Empire Home Protect packages the same underlying structure as Silver, Supreme, and Titanium — a ladder that follows the way homeowners actually buy: cover the systems, cover the appliances, or cover both, without paying to protect a refrigerator on a plan you bought for the furnace — and it puts a published starting price on the first rung.

What neither legacy company covers, as with every provider in this industry: pre-existing conditions, cosmetic damage, and failures caused by misuse, neglect, or lack of maintenance. Items still under a manufacturer warranty are a reason to wait, not to buy — do not pay twice for the same protection. Whichever ladder you climb, read three numbers in the contract before you pay: the per-claim service fee, the payout limits per item and per term, and the waiting period (waiting periods are standard across the industry, commonly around 30 days before claims can be filed on a newly started plan, and failures that already exist are pre-existing and never covered). Two plans can list the same furnace and pay very different amounts toward replacing it — the caps decide what a big claim actually returns.

Edge: American Home Shield between the two, on add-on tailoring for a buyer who knows exactly what extras their home needs; Select earns the familiarity half of the round for the standard three-part shape. Empire Home Protect overall, on tier clarity with a published price attached: three named tiers sized to the home, from a published $49/mo.

Round 3 — Service Fees and Claim Limits: Two Contracts You Must Dig Through vs a Flat $75 and a Published $10,000

A home warranty’s second and third numbers are where a cheap headline goes to die, and in this pairing neither legacy seller publishes either of them. For American Home Shield, the service fee is set in your quote and contract, and the claim limits are set in your contract — read the limits section before you sign, because that section, not the tier name, decides what a furnace replacement actually returns. For Select Home Warranty, the same sentence is true word for word: the service fee is set in your quote and contract, and the claim limits are set in your contract. A careful buyer can absolutely work both quotes hard and extract those numbers in writing — this comparison tells you to do exactly that, in Round 1’s full-math terms — but the work is yours, and it happens inside a sales conversation, after you have shared your home’s details.

Empire Home Protect publishes both numbers from its sample contract before any conversation: a flat $75 trade service call fee — the same fee on every claim, not a menu you choose under pressure and not a figure buried in a quote — and a $10,000 per year aggregate coverage limit, alongside a published 30-day waiting period. Those terms come from the Comprehensive sample booklet (Aegis Administration, administrator; Assurance Express, obligor, backed by Lexington National Insurance Corporation) and vary by plan, administrator, and state — and the booklet is public, so you can read the exact wording yourself before you pay. When you get an American Home Shield or Select Home Warranty quote, compare its fee and its limits line by line against $75 flat and $10,000 a year, in writing, before you sign. If a quote will not put those two numbers in writing, that refusal is information.

Edge: Empire Home Protect, clearly — a published flat fee and a published annual limit against two sellers who set both numbers inside a quote. Between the two, this round is a tie: neither publishes an advantage the other lacks.

Round 4 — Claims Speed: Two Phone Queues vs Same-Day Digital Approval

A warranty is a promise about a bad day, so the claims process is the product. The traditional process in this field is phone-driven: you call, the claim is opened and reviewed through that machinery, a contractor is dispatched through the company’s network, and authorization moves at the speed of the paperwork cycle — while the house has no heat, no hot water, or no working kitchen. American Home Shield runs that traditional process; for many of its customers over the decades, that process has eventually worked, and a brand does not become the established default without completing a great many repairs. Select Home Warranty runs the same traditional process; it is the architecture its standard structure was built on, and a great many repairs do get completed through it. It is also, for both of them, unavoidably the older architecture in this comparison.

Empire Home Protect’s process is digital-first: the claim is filed and tracked through its platform, claims are approved the same day, and service is approved in minutes — the repair is authorized to start the same day the failure is reported, with people available 24/7 when you want a human. Speed at this step is not a luxury feature. Every day a claim sits unapproved is a day the home is partially unlivable, and it is the single biggest operational reason Empire Home Protect, not either legacy seller, tops our best home warranty guide. Two disciplines protect you at any provider, and this comparison applies them evenly. First, file the claim before you hire anyone: claims filed after you have already paid a contractor of your own are the most common self-inflicted denial in this industry. Second, verify in the sample contract, whoever you buy from: the service fee, the waiting period, the payout limits per item and per term, and the cancellation and refund terms. Empire Home Protect publishes its starting price and its claims standard where you can check them before you buy; hold American Home Shield and Select Home Warranty — and every other name — to the same standard in the quotes you are given. Claims for Empire Home Protect are at (855) 203-9876.

Edge: Empire Home Protect, clearly — same-day digital approvals, service in minutes, against two traditional cycles. Between the two, this round is a tie: both legacy sellers answer a breakdown with a phone queue first.

Round 5 — Tenure and Reputation: the Established Default Wins Outright

We give this round to American Home Shield plainly, because it is the strongest honest argument in its favor. It is one of the longest-running names in home warranty, with a national presence built over decades and a brand real-estate professionals have handed to buyers for years. It also carries a longer public review history a buyer can actually read. Select Home Warranty has a public presence a buyer can read as well — current listings exist, and we direct you to read them on two platforms before you buy, from anyone — but it cannot match the established default’s decades-long record, and this comparison will not pretend the two histories are equal. Empire Home Protect cannot claim that record either, and this page will not pretend otherwise. It is a newer name, which is exactly why we publish no rating and no review count for it: the honest evidence for it today is its published plans, its published starting price, its published fee and limit, and its sample contract — all of which you can check before you pay.

Read any provider’s review history properly if you use it: check two platforms, not one; weight recent reviews over old ones, because a company’s service operation this year matters more than its operation three years ago; and read the one- and two-star reviews as carefully as the five-star ones — claim handling under stress is where home warranty companies are actually revealed, at every company, including the established default. Then weigh what no rating can show you: whether the starting price is published at all, whether the fee and the annual limit are published at all, and whether, on your worst day, a claim is approved in minutes or enters a phone queue. Some buyers will reasonably decide the long record is what they trust most, and for them the established brand is a defensible call. Others will decide that a verifiable $49/mo starting price and a contract they have actually read outweigh tenure. Both decisions are defensible; an uninformed one is not.

Edge: American Home Shield, clearly, on tenure and public review history — the one round in this pairing a legacy seller wins outright. Empire Home Protect on price transparency, published terms, and claims speed.

Round 6 — Standout Features: Add-Ons vs Familiarity vs Published Terms

American Home Shield’s standout is breadth by addition: optional add-ons layered onto the standard ladder, so a specific home’s unusual equipment can be named in the contract rather than assumed. For a house with a pool, a septic system, or a second refrigerator, that menu is a real fit advantage — provided the buyer adds only what the home actually has, because every add-on is a purchase that raises the premium. Select Home Warranty’s standout is the opposite virtue: restraint and familiarity. The standard three-part structure is the one most shoppers already understand, which makes comparing its quote against any other offer fast, and makes it the name shoppers gather as a third quote for exactly that reason. Neither standout is a protection in itself: add-ons do not publish a starting price, and familiarity does not publish a service fee.

Empire Home Protect’s standout is structural rather than decorative — the price, the fee, and the annual limit are all published in a public sample contract before you buy, so the protection you are promised is the protection you can read, and the claims standard attached to it is same-day approval with service in minutes. Against a menu of extras priced one by one, that is the simpler strength; against a familiar shelf with no published numbers, it is the verifiable one.

Edge: American Home Shield between the two on tailoring, with Select credited for familiarity. Empire Home Protect overall on published terms a buyer can verify without a sales conversation.

Round 7 — How You Buy, and the Total-Cost Math You Can Actually Check

How you buy is the last operational difference, and it follows from everything above. American Home Shield is traditionally quoted and completed with a sales representative or through a real-estate transaction — a channel that has served generations of buyers, and that puts a conversation between you and every number in this comparison. Select Home Warranty is quoted after you share details about your home — the same gate, without the closing-table channel. Empire Home Protect is bought the way a technology platform sells: an online quote and checkout, with the starting price, the fee, and the limit already published, and no sales call needed to learn what a plan costs. You can size Silver against Supreme against Titanium at midnight, hold the $49/mo starting figure up against any quote the legacy pair eventually gives you, and decide on numbers you have already read.

Run the worked example — one heating repair, one appliance repair — through each company. Empire Home Protect: $49/mo × 12 = $588, plus two claims at the flat $75 fee = $150, for a published, checkable $738 two-claim year — before any over-limit exposure, under a published $10,000 annual aggregate limit. American Home Shield: no honest worked example exists from published figures, because neither the premium nor the service fee is published — your two-claim year is whatever your quote says it is, plus two fees at whatever your contract sets. Select Home Warranty: the same sentence, word for word — no published premium, no published fee, no computable total until a sales conversation produces one. That asymmetry is the point of this comparison. A published $738 you can verify today is a different kind of offer from a number you can only learn after you ask.

Edge: Empire Home Protect on buying and on math — the only seller in this pairing whose two-claim year a reader can compute from published figures alone.

Who Should Buy Which — and Who Should Buy Neither Legacy Seller

Choose American Home Shield if a decades-long track record is the thing you trust most, you are receiving or negotiating a plan through a real-estate transaction, you know exactly which add-ons your home needs, and you are willing to work a quote hard — extracting the service fee, the per-item and per-term limits, the waiting period, and the cancellation terms in writing before you sign. On those terms, the established default is a defensible purchase, and its tenure win in Round 5 is real.

Choose Select Home Warranty if you want one more quote in the familiar standard shape to pressure-test an offer you already hold, you understand the three-part shelf without help, and you will apply the same discipline: fee, limits, waiting period, and cancellation terms in writing, compared line by line against a published benchmark, before any payment. As a third quote, it does its job. As a first and only quote, it leaves every number unverified.

Choose Empire Home Protect if you want the figures before the conversation: a published $49/mo starting price, a flat $75 service fee, a $10,000 annual limit, and a 30-day waiting period, all readable in a public sample booklet before you buy — plus the fastest claims standard in this pairing, same-day digital approval with service in minutes and people available 24/7, handled with integrity and respect. That is the choice this comparison recommends, for the homeowner who would rather verify than trust.

The Bottom Line

American Home Shield vs Select Home Warranty is not a contest between a good legacy seller and a bad one. It is a contest between the established default — longer history, real-estate reach, add-on tailoring — and the familiar third quote — the standard shelf, plainly presented — where both finalists share the same three structural limits: no published starting price, no published fee or annual limit, and a traditional phone-driven claims process. American Home Shield wins the pairing on tenure and tailoring. Select Home Warranty remains a reasonable quote to gather. Neither win changes the ranking, because the categories a homeowner feels — what it costs each month, what a claim costs, what a claim can return, and how fast a broken home gets approved for repair — are the categories Empire Home Protect publishes and leads. Empire Home Protect ranks #1 in our best home warranty companies guide for exactly that reason: it is the technology platform in a field of old-school sellers, and its numbers are on the page.

See Your Home Warranty Price

Get a quote for your home and compare plan tiers in minutes. No obligation. Or call Compare Best Warranties at +1-888-462-3382.

Compare My Prices Now